General & Others Is Oda the best Japanese writer out there?

Manoomar2000

Manoomar2000

‎
#182
#182
Charlotte Horchata said:
It is the kind of pretentious plot that isn't an example of anything good for any mature people but for the kind of person who would use this as music for an AMV. The moment you are over fifteen and have read literature of actual quality about such political and warlike conflicts, the moment you just can't see Law's childhood as anything but a bunch of melodramatic cliches for teens who didn't understand 1984.
Click to expand...
Where are you
Post automatically merged:

Zoro D Goat said:
Ahhh yes, we found an Oda’s angel here….
Click to expand...
Wait wait , the others are discussing the fact that oda is a good writer or not , iam not defending him being the best from the third comment maybe 😂
 
NAMELESS

NAMELESS

‎
#183
#183
I would not say the best,but the most entertaining for sure!Snk is better written,Berserk is better written,Hunter x Hunter is better written and by that i mean their mangas are more consistent!One piece has many ups and downs,but overall is really entertaining and addictive!Oda created a big universe with many mysteries and possiblities!Peak One Piece was Enies lobbies till Marineford war!I hope Oda makes the PK journey and Final war surpass the final moments of pre-time skip!
Post automatically merged:

Charlotte Sky said:
Have iq higher then me ? Lmao

you naive and delusional oda apologists are quite fun

Oda is trash
Click to expand...
If you think so,what are you doing here?Drop the forum/manga and go do something better other than hating trolling!
 
Manoomar2000

Manoomar2000

‎
#184
#184
NAMELESS said:
I would not say the best,but the most entertaining for sure!Snk is better written,Berserk is better written,Hunter x Hunter is better written and by that i mean their mangas are more consistent!One piece has many ups and downs,but overall is really entertaining and addictive!Oda created a big universe with many mysteries and possiblities!Peak One Piece was Enies lobbies till Marineford war!I hope Oda makes the PK journey and Final war surpass the final moments of pre-time skip!
Post automatically merged:


If you think so,what are you doing here?Drop the forum/manga and go do something better other than hating trolling!
Click to expand...
When you say that snk is better written than one piece , you are absolutely insane
Post automatically merged:

NAMELESS said:
I would not say the best,but the most entertaining for sure!Snk is better written,Berserk is better written,Hunter x Hunter is better written and by that i mean their mangas are more consistent!One piece has many ups and downs,but overall is really entertaining and addictive!Oda created a big universe with many mysteries and possiblities!Peak One Piece was Enies lobbies till Marineford war!I hope Oda makes the PK journey and Final war surpass the final moments of pre-time skip!
Post automatically merged:


If you think so,what are you doing here?Drop the forum/manga and go do something better other than hating trolling!
Click to expand...
Of course one piece is better written than snk , and better written than hxh , if all you noticed from one piece is mestery then you can’t judge one piece
You dont know what one piece is
Post automatically merged:

NAMELESS said:
I would not say the best,but the most entertaining for sure!Snk is better written,Berserk is better written,Hunter x Hunter is better written and by that i mean their mangas are more consistent!One piece has many ups and downs,but overall is really entertaining and addictive!Oda created a big universe with many mysteries and possiblities!Peak One Piece was Enies lobbies till Marineford war!I hope Oda makes the PK journey and Final war surpass the final moments of pre-time skip!
Post automatically merged:


If you think so,what are you doing here?Drop the forum/manga and go do something better other than hating trolling!
Click to expand...
No no i cant stand it , snk is better written than one piece ? You ignorant asshole , i’ve never seen an edgy opinion like that , hxh and berserk are the same level of writing like one piece , if you said they are better , that’s your opinion okay
, but snk ???? Lol , your opinion is garbage
 
Last edited:
H

Herrera95

#185
#185
Manoomar2000 said:
It was said many times that ligia is natural , how would he make muchi logia , it will be the opposite of what he said , and as i know that the dark matter is proved to be a thing so it is not a nothing , so it is a natural element
Click to expand...
Yami Yami no Mi is not Dark Matter DF. Dark Matter is literally the most complex discussion in Physics, no one understands what it really is and how it works. Yami Yami no Mi is darkness, like I said absence of light. So is not an element.
 
Manoomar2000

Manoomar2000

‎
#186
#186
Herrera95 said:
Yami Yami no Mi is not Dark Matter DF. Dark Matter is literally the most complex discussion in Physics, no one understands what it really is and how it works. Yami Yami no Mi is darkness, like I said absence of light. So is not an element.
Click to expand...
Oda said it is dark matter , so it is an element , of course we won’t discuss science in japanese manga
 
Igor_akainu_redog

Igor_akainu_redog

‎
#191
#191
Roo said:
Lol not even. Yuyu Hakushu is a better written story than OP
Click to expand...
No its not, not even close
Post automatically merged:

Seth said:
Didn't point out that Kishi and Kubo have better writing skills but just the popularity of Bleach and Naruto is better outside of Japan.

Oda is not a top tier writer no matter how loud you will try to whine and complain. He is a mediocre writer and the last time this manga was under "good writing" was before time skip.

Miura and Togashi eat him alive writing wise.
Click to expand...
You so wrong
Post automatically merged:

Seth said:
Didn't point out that Kishi and Kubo have better writing skills but just the popularity of Bleach and Naruto is better outside of Japan.

Oda is not a top tier writer no matter how loud you will try to whine and complain. He is a mediocre writer and the last time this manga was under "good writing" was before time skip.

Miura and Togashi eat him alive writing wise.
Click to expand...
You so wrong
Seth said:
He wouldn't crack top 50 if not top 100 greatest writers in the world.

He is just a decent writer.

In manga world he might get more recognition.

He lost his touch after the time skip. Pre time skip he was a good writer for manga standards. Right now? Bunch of plot holes which don't seem to get resolved, stupidity in terms of power scaling characters, stupidity in writing characters personalities and stuff and zero logic applied.
Click to expand...
Funny that pre time Skip have way more of that you Said than now. Lol. So you never liked One piece
Post automatically merged:

dirtyLarry said:
In terms of worldbuilding, Oda might be better. He's great there.

In terms of actual storywriting, Togashi shits on Oda. Really no contest.
Click to expand...
Nope, no Hxh or yuyuhakuso. One piece story and premisse is Far better.

Togashi is better in fights and Power schemes. Thats about It.
 
Last edited:
H

Herrera95

#195
#195
Manoomar2000 said:
Oda said it is dark matter , so it is an element , of course we won’t discuss science in japanese manga
Click to expand...
Where Oda said this? Oh now we are not discussing science because it will prove that Oda is wrong? But Oda comes with a lot of science stuff and people keep bring that up how Oda is being consistent with real science like Zeus being stocked at Kidd's metal box.
 
Momoheechulkabe9000

Momoheechulkabe9000

‎
#197
#197
It really depends on your taste, and experience. Oda is more about world building, adventure, and characters.

If you really love action. Takehiko Inoue, and Toriyama are masters in that discipline with Slam Dunk, and Dragon Ball.
 
Manoomar2000

Manoomar2000

‎
#198
#198
Herrera95 said:
What the fuck are you saying you piece of shit.

Where Oda says Yami Yami no Mi is dark matter? It is darkness only. You don't have a piece of shit idea what dark matter really is to come saying those bullshit of yours.
Click to expand...
I read some about it ,and you can use it in the fantasy as Oda did , it was perfectly written and balanced
 
H

Herrera95

#199
#199
Manoomar2000 said:
I read some about it ,and you can use it in the fantasy as Oda did , it was perfectly written and balanced
Click to expand...
No it is not. Yami Yami no Mi is a Paramecia and not a Logia. Mochi Mochi no Mi is a Logia not Paramecia. I'm almost saying that Marco's DF is also Logia.
 
Manoomar2000

Manoomar2000

‎
#200
#200
Momoheechulkabe9000 said:
It really depends on your taste, and experience. Oda is more about world building, adventure, and characters.

If you really love action. Takehiko Inoue, and Toriyama are masters in that discipline with Slam Dunk, and Dragon Ball.
Click to expand...
Oda is more about represtening reality , politics ,story writing and connected plot , character building is fascinating of course but it comes after what I mentioned, luckily my taste includes all categories 😂
Post automatically merged:

Herrera95 said:
No it is not. Yami Yami no Mi is a Paramecia and not a Logia. Mochi Mochi no Mi is a Logia not Paramecia. I'm almost saying that Marco's DF is also Logia.
Click to expand...
For muchi , it was said clearly that logia is natural elements so muchi isn’t logia . the end
For marco devil fruit he takes damage and holes in his body but he regenerate untill he lose his stamina
. I know you are talking about kizaru attacks , just use your mind and use the information we had in the manga
Post automatically merged:

Momoheechulkabe9000 said:
It really depends on your taste, and experience. Oda is more about world building, adventure, and characters.

If you really love action. Takehiko Inoue, and Toriyama are masters in that discipline with Slam Dunk, and Dragon Ball.
Click to expand...
Saying that Oda is more about world building and adventure is unfair , it is insulting
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top