General & Others Is this the best fight of Wano?

[Sugimoto 14]

Jinbe vs Who's Who has the choreography and well-thought out attacks from both sides that is sorely lacking in most post-timeskip fights. Also, the fight isn't just one clash, a couple of lines from each character, and then off-panel. There's actually a whole chapter and half dedicated to it, which is a shocker.

There's also a lot of lore revealed and characterization for both parties, which will set up future plot points (Sun God and the frequent references to the Dawn, Sun, etc in One Piece).

It's a pretty low-bar considering how the fights in Wano have been so far, but this could be the best fight in Wano. What surpasses it writing-wise?

 

[Salah WG]

It's definitely a Cool Fight
But i think there is a Fight about 5 Youngsters vs 2 Oldies that takes the Top Spot for now

 

[Sword God Ryuma]

Supernovas vs Yonko and sccabards vs Kaido were better.

 

[Red Admiral]

wano had some kick ass god tier duel

people forgot about 1000-10 so easily?

 

[Garp the Fist]

Might be mildly heretical, but it was much better technically than the rooftop fight (barring the bit at the end where Luffy and Kaido started attacking each other with CoC).

I enjoyed the roof top fight, don’t get me wrong, but a lot of it was

DOUBLE-SPREAD OF AN AWESOME ATTACK
THE ENEMY COUNTERS WITH A DOUBLE-SPREAD OF AN AWESOME ATTACK OF THEIR OWN

Which was cool, but didn’t quite have much of a flow to it.

 

[Finalbeta]

It's one of the most intense post the rooftop clash I would suggest.

If this is related to 1v1s I place it on top for now. Which doesn't necessarily mean top 1.

Other candidates are for instance Early Luffy v Kaido Rioftoop Luffy v Kaido despite we didn't witness much of those.

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Jinbei vs Who's Who is easily one of the best fights in Onigashima.

 

[NotTommy]

I thought it was really good and hopefully more fights are this interesting but I prefer Marco vs King and Queen and the rooftop fight.

 

[Luffy is the mc]

Might be mildly heretical, but it was much better technically than the rooftop fight (barring the bit at the end where Luffy and Kaido started attacking each other with CoC).

I enjoyed the roof top fight, don’t get me wrong, but a lot of it was

DOUBLE-SPREAD OF AN AWESOME ATTACK
THE ENEMY COUNTERS WITH A DOUBLE-SPREAD OF AN AWESOME ATTACK OF THEIR OWN

Which was cool, but didn’t quite have much of a flow to it.

Nah I also agree. There was some good actions on the rooftop but it was a bit messed up sometimes.
Best part was Luffy and Kaido 1v1 but it's was too short and off paneled.
1v1 are always better and the Jimbei fight was very good, plenty of different techniques and style from both of them.

I can only hope that the same will happen for Sanji vs Queen, Zoro vs King and Luffy vs Kaido.

It has to be 1v1s and a bit longer or it's going to be below Jimbei vs WW.

 

[Hades]

yes so far it is a best fight in wano.....rooftop is cool but lacking impact....and I think this is just the beginning....if Oda rolls this way and even better we will see more from other straw hats and calamities/Kaido/Bigmom/Supernovas etc.

 

[kumae]

Let's see if he is not defeated and he has more techniques of course yes

 

[nik87]

When it comes to fighting choreography, this one is the best so far.
Rooftop wasnt as smooth as this.

 

[Sanji D Cook]

I'll wait until the arc is over to answer this question.

 

[Paperchampion23]

I'll wait until the arc is over to answer this question.

Yeah there's only like a 100 other fights thst need to happen lol

 

[Finalbeta]

Rooftop was hype, not necessarily massive quality. Those are not necessarily mutually exclusive.

 

[York]

Its the only fight with a proper conclusion so far(unless you count the mess that was roof piece) so yeah I'll give it that



Only counting Onigashima because all fights prior to that weren't really anything. Itd be like trying to compare Franky vs Zipper Guy to Zoro cutting down T Bone

 

[KageFumi]

If there's no rooftop battle, then yes.

 

[RayanOO]

I didn’t like the rooftop battle choreography wise , it’s flow, coherence, plot etc

The best fight in Wano / Onigashima is likely Zoro vs Kamazo for me

Marco moments with King and Queen were cool but overall a bit weird because either King or Queen missed half of the time and we didn’t know at all what they were doing

About WsW vs Jimbe it had potential and had rhythm but maybe I expected too much but it didn’t deliver the way I wanted. I think WsW use of his DF was really limited. Only the fang shigan. And I wanted WsW to do other things having other skills with his sword etc.

The shigan Madara wasn’t my cup of tea

And the whole Jimbe / WsW connection : I see you already etc etc was kinda cheap

 

[Peroroncino]

Rooftop was the best for me, seeing the supernovas working together was awesome, and while the rooftop was going on every week's spoilers was hype af.
Until it ended and we got Tama.

 

[The White Crane]

Jinbe vs Who's Who has the choreography and well-thought out attacks from both sides that is sorely lacking in most post-timeskip fights. Also, the fight isn't just one clash, a couple of lines from each character, and then off-panel. There's actually a whole chapter and half dedicated to it, which is a shocker.

There's also a lot of lore revealed and characterization for both parties, which will set up future plot points (Sun God and the frequent references to the Dawn, Sun, etc in One Piece).

It's a pretty low-bar considering how the fights in Wano have been so far, but this could be the best fight in Wano. What surpasses it writing-wise?

Roof Piece > Any One Piece fight not named Luffy vs Lucci.

But, yes, Jinbe vs WW is Wano's best 1-on-1 so far.