Theory Kid WILL become a yonko after Elbaf. How Oda writes Eustass Kid

#1
A lot of people don't understand how Oda writes Kid.
Yes, Kid loses a lot. But like Luffy, he always comes back from his losses.

I remember Mr. Morj made an observation about Kid that I thought was very insightful. Luffy is rubber and hence he always bounces back from his defeats. This can be seen in how Luffy gets defeated multiple times in a single fight but always comes out stronger(see: Katakuri, Kaido). Kid on the other hand is magnetism, while he gets defeated often, he always rebuilds himself from his defeats.


This concept of Kid "rebuilding" himself can be seen in his actual powers. This is something he reiterates about his metal structures. However this is something you can see in Kid's character as well.

Before Shanks, the worst loss that Kid took was against Beckman, where Kid lost his arm. However this didn't stop Kid and end his journey, rather he simply replaced his arm with metal. This proved to be useful later on.

Not only did it save him from Hawkins's powers, it led to the creation of Kid's ultimate technique.


With damned punk, Kid transforms his metal arm into the rail gun. Both times we have seen this technique, it has consistently been used in this manner.


So with Kid's defeat at the hands of Shanks and the giants and the seeming "eradication" of the Kid pirates, one wonders how Kid will rebuild himself after this.

Now while the narration says the Kid pirates were eradicated, it doesn't say specifically that Kid died. No, Oda has never killed an important character in such an ambiguous manner. So its safe to say that Kid probably survived somehow. Maybe Killer did as well, as Oda thought he was important enough to be on the roof and get a fight in wano. However Kid's crew? I feel like its very likely that they died. Hence there likely were some words of truth to the narration.

Much how Kid's loss against Beckman led him to replace his missing limb with metal, his loss to Shanks will cause Kid to replace his missing crew with metal.


We know that somewhere in Elbaf, there is a library containing the Ohara books. Books that Vegapunk gained knowledge of advanced ancient kingdom technology from. I believe that Kid will study these books after his defeat and ultimately learn to create automata from them.

Kid will replace his dead crew with an army of robots. In doing so, he will create a massive and powerful crew capable of making him emperor after the elbaf arc.

My guess is that he will replace Shanks after Blackbeard defeats him.
 
#6
Meme -> Buggy
Kaido -> Joyboy
Shanks
WB -> BB

The clown position is filled.
Joyboy will not be overthrown.
BB is endgame.
Shanks already whooped Midds ass twice.

By the end of the story there won’t be a Yonko system. Fraudstass Midd is finished. Best case for him is as a dicksucker for Luffy against clown ass Gorosei when Luffy is fighting the incompetent clown ass Goroseis God
 

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
#9
Oda does not give two shits about making Kidd a Yonkou, that idea should of died after Wano. The least he could have done was pick up some Tobiroppo post Onigashima. His crew didn't get the least bit stronger despite taking down a Yonkou.

It is a bit infuriating why Oda couldn't just let him beef up his crew after such a big event. Just a plain head scratcher, reminds me of when Jean Bart was losing to a fodder mink on Zou...like why? There's literally zero reason for it.
 
#10
Oda does not give two shits about making Kidd a Yonkou, that idea should of died after Wano. The least he could have done was pick up some Tobiroppo post Onigashima. His crew didn't get the least bit stronger despite taking down a Yonkou.

It is a bit infuriating why Oda couldn't just let him beef up his crew after such a big event. Just a plain head scratcher, reminds me of when Jean Bart was losing to a fodder mink on Zou...like why? There's literally zero reason for it.
It’s because Kid(and Law) are supposed to be bronze medalers.

While they are Luffy’s peers, Oda will never write them as actual rivals of Luffy’s. Hence, the only way Kid or Law could become Yonko is if Luffy gets a far more prestigious title, aka PK.

That’s why I see them getting crew buffs only post elbaf. Because by then it won’t matter since Luffy will have like 3 top tiers under him.
Post automatically merged:

So shanks and Ben destroying Kidd wasn't enough for you and now you want either cross guild or BB do it as well?:milaugh:
Ben = takes Kid’s arm; Kid replaces it with metal

Shanks = takes Kid’s crew; Kid replaces them with robot army.
 

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
#11
It’s because Kid(and Law) are supposed to be bronze medalers.

While they are Luffy’s peers, Oda will never write them as actual rivals of Luffy’s. Hence, the only way Kid or Law could become Yonko is if Luffy gets a far more prestigious title, aka PK.

That’s why I see them getting crew buffs only post elbaf. Because by then it won’t matter since Luffy will have like 3 top tiers under him.
Post automatically merged:


Ben = takes Kid’s arm; Kid replaces it with metal

Shanks = takes Kid’s crew; Kid replaces them with robot army.
What I don't understand is how picking up a couple Tobiroppo and not making Jean Bart a fodder suddenly means they have a Strawhat level crew lmfao.

Remove Luffy AND Zoro, and the Strawhats still have a good shot at beating the Heart Pirates and Kidd Pirates at full strength.
 
#14
What I don't understand is how picking up a couple Tobiroppo and not making Jean Bart a fodder suddenly means they have a Strawhat level crew lmfao.
Bart ain’t a fodder. He has haki. He was able to block a bullet with his bare body.

As for picking up Tobi roppo, Kid and Law aren’t Kaido. They don’t pick up just anyone. It seems like their crew are mostly their friends, like Luffy’s.

They‘ll probably become yonko with the strength of their own crew, rather than recruiting others.

Kid = create robot army with his DF
Law = use awakened ope ope no mi to do body modification on his crew.
Post automatically merged:

It’s gonna happen
 
G

Gorosei Informer

#15

(This is a copypasta/meme ofc:)

STOP POSTING ABOUT KIDD SLANDER! I'M SICK OF SEEING IT! MY PIRATE FRIENDS ON WORSTGEN SEND ME HATE, ON TWITTER IT'S NON-STOP HATE! I was on WorstGen, right? and ALL OF THE THREADS were just Kidd bashing. I WAS READING A THREAD, AND EVERY SINGLE POST WAS ABOUT KIDD'S DEFEAT TO SHANKS. I SHOWED MY PIRATE HAT COLLECTION TO MY BUDDY, AND I TURNED IT UPSIDE DOWN, SAYING, "SEE, JUST LIKE KIDD'S CREW AFTER SHANKS!" HAHA DING DING DING DING DING DING DING DI DI DING" I fucking looked at a picture of Shanks and said "THAT'S A BIT OVERPOWERED" I looked at my One Piece theory collection, thinking of Kidd's potential, and I go "Eustass Kidd? MORE LIKE Useless Midd/Kidding!"
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!


I really can't be bothered to argue for Kidd anymore, I'm too exhausted and fed up.

This is a pretty cool theory and post though, thanks for the tag @Mr. Reloaded.

I'm not saying anymore on Kidd until we get an update on him eventually or more like IF we do, whatever the hell Oda intends for him even if its the worst case scenario as seen so far already.

I have my own beliefs on Kidds character, future, role etc but I'm keeping it to myself now, as most people just want to slander and downplay him regardless so it's pointless to discuss him now imo.
The same old arguments and obvious issues repeated ad nauseum.

Nobody butchers their characters better than Gaston I mean Oda.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
#16
https://youtube.com/shorts/6F2kOvicn_E?feature=share

(This is a copypasta/meme ofc:)

STOP POSTING ABOUT KIDD SLANDER! I'M SICK OF SEEING IT! MY PIRATE FRIENDS ON WORSTGEN SEND ME HATE, ON TWITTER IT'S NON-STOP HATE! I was on WorstGen, right? and ALL OF THE THREADS were just Kidd bashing. I WAS READING A THREAD, AND EVERY SINGLE POST WAS ABOUT KIDD'S DEFEAT TO SHANKS. I SHOWED MY PIRATE HAT COLLECTION TO MY BUDDY, AND I TURNED IT UPSIDE DOWN, SAYING, "SEE, JUST LIKE KIDD'S CREW AFTER SHANKS!" HAHA DING DING DING DING DING DING DING DI DI DING" I fucking looked at a picture of Shanks and said "THAT'S A BIT OVERPOWERED" I looked at my One Piece theory collection, thinking of Kidd's potential, and I go "Eustass Kidd? MORE LIKE Useless Midd/Kidding!"
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!


I really can't be bothered to argue for Kidd anymore, I'm too exhausted and fed up.

This is a pretty cool theory and post though, thanks for the tag @Mr. Reloaded.

I'm not saying anymore on Kidd until we get an update on him eventually or more like IF we do, whatever the hell Oda intends for him even if its the worst case scenario as seen so far already.

I have my own beliefs on Kidds character, future, role etc but I'm keeping it to myself now, as most people just want to slander and downplay him regardless so it's pointless to discuss him now imo.
The same old arguments and obvious issues repeated ad nauseum.

Nobody butchers their characters better than Gaston I mean Oda.
Nice development ghostly:myman: don't argue for dead people
 
#17
https://youtube.com/shorts/6F2kOvicn_E?feature=share

(This is a copypasta/meme ofc:)

STOP POSTING ABOUT KIDD SLANDER! I'M SICK OF SEEING IT! MY PIRATE FRIENDS ON WORSTGEN SEND ME HATE, ON TWITTER IT'S NON-STOP HATE! I was on WorstGen, right? and ALL OF THE THREADS were just Kidd bashing. I WAS READING A THREAD, AND EVERY SINGLE POST WAS ABOUT KIDD'S DEFEAT TO SHANKS. I SHOWED MY PIRATE HAT COLLECTION TO MY BUDDY, AND I TURNED IT UPSIDE DOWN, SAYING, "SEE, JUST LIKE KIDD'S CREW AFTER SHANKS!" HAHA DING DING DING DING DING DING DING DI DI DING" I fucking looked at a picture of Shanks and said "THAT'S A BIT OVERPOWERED" I looked at my One Piece theory collection, thinking of Kidd's potential, and I go "Eustass Kidd? MORE LIKE Useless Midd/Kidding!"
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!


I really can't be bothered to argue for Kidd anymore, I'm too exhausted and fed up.

This is a pretty cool theory and post though, thanks for the tag @Mr. Reloaded.

I'm not saying anymore on Kidd until we get an update on him eventually or more like IF we do, whatever the hell Oda intends for him even if its the worst case scenario as seen so far already.

I have my own beliefs on Kidds character, future, role etc but I'm keeping it to myself now, as most people just want to slander and downplay him regardless so it's pointless to discuss him now imo.
The same old arguments and obvious issues repeated ad nauseum.

Nobody butchers their characters better than Gaston I mean Oda.
They don’t understand how Kid’s written.

His loss to Shanks is nothing new. Beckman took his arm over the time skip and then later Kaido imprisoned and tortured him.

fact is through all of that he always rebuilds himself and comes back stronger.

The giants murdered Kid’s crew? He’ll just build a robot army that’s far stronger than his old crew.
 
#18
Interesting. I don't like the idea but it still could be true that Kidd is Shanks family. Kidd wanting to prove himself next to Shanks, the red hair and him wearing a feathered cape just like Doflamingo an other Celatial Dragon.
If Shanks fullfills his role in Elbaf he doesn't need to be Yonkou anymore. Maybe Kidd will take over?
 
#20
Having an army of robots is surprising. He likes to build or craft robots since he was a kid.

Luffy :
WCI --> 5th EMEPEROR but not crowned Yonko
Wano --> gets easily beaten by Kaido and then ends up winning after many tries, and finally becomes Yonko in power and status as he replaced Kaido!

Kid :
Wano --> Wisdom King (yonko candidate) but not crowned Yonko
Elbaf --> gets easily beaten by Shanks (for the 2nd time he's lost to a top tier)
He will finaly beat a top tier (BM or Greenbull or Giant...) 1vs1 once he gets PUs
He will replace Shanks (who will fall to Teach)

Perhaps...Teach will ally with Kid to take down RHP + CG alliance
Kid after a 3rd chance to take down RHP

Kid and Luffy have similar paths, it is just that Luffy is just 2 steps ahead
 
Top