Le Fishe Thread Looks like goofy fans are finished

#61
People of wano didn't mean OG joyboy. They were comparing luffy to ryuma and luffy's accomplishment to ryuma. Luffy was called as a joyboy by them.
Luffy didn't really defeat Kaido 1v1 either, he was weaker and Kaido got gassed out in the end. They just heard "Joyboy" defeated Kaido without context, and immediately though about Ryuma.
Kaido (who didn't know about Ryuma but knew of Joyboy's legend) thought only Joyboy can defeat him. Wano citizens (who didn't know of Joyboy but knew of Ryuma's legend) though Ryuma could defeat Kaido, and when they heard of "Joyboy" defeating Kaido thought he's as legendary as Ryuma
There is meaning to this narrative than the just straightforward implication that both Joyboy and Ryuma can defeat Kaido. It's classic tool for building narratives of comparison of their legends and powers as well, especially when looked in context of following supplemental portrayals as well:
Ryuma is already above Roger, and got similar narratives to Joyboy.
- only two characters (so far) revered as a God centuries after their demise
- two characters who gave world govt PTSD lasting for centuries
- Kaido (who didn't know about Ryuma but knew of Joyboy's legend) thought only Joyboy can defeat him. Wano citizens (who didn't know of Joyboy but knew of Ryuma's legend) though Ryuma could defeat Kaido, and when they heard of "Joyboy" defeating Kaido thought he's as legendary as Ryuma
- Ryuma was WSM in his days

Roger most likely have haki abilities which WB does not have. We have yet to see higher levels of haki imo. Otherwise WB stacking his DF should make him more powerful which is not the case. Shanks already showed wifi haki which Kaido does not have which was powerful enough to negate GB's broccoli mode.
What is to say that Ryuma or EoS Zoro won't have similar equalizers?
Any reason Roger and Shanks should have conqueror's haki superior to them?

Ok, let's ignore Roger and Whitebeard even for a moment.
Oden had no such special abilities aside from raw swordsmanship and offensive haki. Dude was very close to Kaido in power level, who had comparable haki on top of a top tier DF.
Why was this the case?

It just reiterates my point that overall combat stats matter.

Let's even look at current Luffy vs Zoro.
Let me know if you disagree, but haki vice: armament Zoro, conqeuror's and observation Luffy.
Starting with the question - which is the minimum gear Luffy needs to defeat Zoro? If it isn't base, doesn't that just prove my point that overall combat stats is the key, rather than just check list scaling of haki, DF etc?

Asura is indeed special but it is not a big amplifier as nika DF is.
100% disagree.

Asura is by far the biggest powerup/multiplier we've seen in the series so far.

There is a reason Zoro is not allowed to use it for more than a minute yet in the series. There is a reason Oda heavily gatekeeps this powerup, while everything else gets spammed into oblivion.

The issue is even after Kaido's defeat , WG never bothered to go after wano. Kaido himself was similar to ryuma where no one dared to infiltrate wano let it be WB or admirals like GB or WG.
There is a difference between being an active deterrent, versus having PTSD lasting centuries which acts as a deterrent.

I dont even remember the actual argument but I think the gist of it was that I think Luffy and Zoro neck and neck (as per many different canon and secondary sources (manga, databook, vc, official site) in terms of power level throughout the story and are a level ahead of Sanji. It is true though that Zoros opponents are closer to Sanjis in portrayal and/or power compared to Luffys though it does not equate to reflecting Zoro and Sanji power level. So yes there is a Luffy/Zoro duo, there is a Zoro/Sanji duo and I think there is now also somewhat of a Sanji/Jinbe duo (Sanji shown getting pissed about it twice). Then there is the M3 and the weak trio and the childish trio (Luffy/Usopp and Chopper). There are all different types of duos and trios in the crew with different dynamics.
Argument was simply that Sanji will end up roughly comparable to Zoro.
Even if the gap appears high at the moment, it's a matter of time before it becomes narrower.

Denying Zoro/Sanji dynamics is the mirror of "Zoro cannot catch up anymore" that happened after Lucci and Katakuri. Oda is a fan of these duos and monster trio, it will stay

With Jinbe, IDK to be honest. There is a duo with Sanji/Jinbe now, but Jinbe is in his peak, Sanji will soon outscale Jinbe. I doubt it will be relevant in the future
Post automatically merged:

By the way @Blazing Lion

It's time to necro this thread again:
https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/be-honest…if-luffy-is-a-10-what-is-zoro-currently.54255/page-18#post-5444405

Let's laugh at the dudes who voted at/below 5.
Lots of Sanji fans there as well, lets see them packpeddle now that they have material to push Sanji also to that level lmao
 
#62
Luffy didn't really defeat Kaido 1v1 either, he was weaker and Kaido got gassed out in the end. They just heard "Joyboy" defeated Kaido without context, and immediately though about Ryuma.


There is meaning to this narrative than the just straightforward implication that both Joyboy and Ryuma can defeat Kaido. It's classic tool for building narratives of comparison of their legends and powers as well, especially when looked in context of following supplemental portrayals as well:





What is to say that Ryuma or EoS Zoro won't have similar equalizers?
Any reason Roger and Shanks should have conqueror's haki superior to them?

Ok, let's ignore Roger and Whitebeard even for a moment.
Oden had no such special abilities aside from raw swordsmanship and offensive haki. Dude was very close to Kaido in power level, who had comparable haki on top of a top tier DF.
Why was this the case?

It just reiterates my point that overall combat stats matter.

Let's even look at current Luffy vs Zoro.
Let me know if you disagree, but haki vice: armament Zoro, conqeuror's and observation Luffy.
Starting with the question - which is the minimum gear Luffy needs to defeat Zoro? If it isn't base, doesn't that just prove my point that overall combat stats is the key, rather than just check list scaling of haki, DF etc?



100% disagree.

Asura is by far the biggest powerup/multiplier we've seen in the series so far.

There is a reason Zoro is not allowed to use it for more than a minute yet in the series. There is a reason Oda heavily gatekeeps this powerup, while everything else gets spammed into oblivion.



There is a difference between being an active deterrent, versus having PTSD lasting centuries which acts as a deterrent.



Argument was simply that Sanji will end up roughly comparable to Zoro.
Even if the gap appears high at the moment, it's a matter of time before it becomes narrower.

Denying Zoro/Sanji dynamics is the mirror of "Zoro cannot catch up anymore" that happened after Lucci and Katakuri. Oda is a fan of these duos and monster trio, it will stay

With Jinbe, IDK to be honest. There is a duo with Sanji/Jinbe now, but Jinbe is in his peak, Sanji will soon outscale Jinbe. I doubt it will be relevant in the future
Post automatically merged:

By the way @Blazing Lion

It's time to necro this thread again:
https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/be-honest…if-luffy-is-a-10-what-is-zoro-currently.54255/page-18#post-5444405

Let's laugh at the dudes who voted at/below 5.
Lots of Sanji fans there as well, lets see them packpeddle now that they have material to push Sanji also to that level lmao
Agreed mostly, tagged you in some other thread with my actual take.
 
#63
Luffy didn't really defeat Kaido 1v1 either, he was weaker and Kaido got gassed out in the end. They just heard "Joyboy" defeated Kaido without context, and immediately though about Ryuma.


There is meaning to this narrative than the just straightforward implication that both Joyboy and Ryuma can defeat Kaido. It's classic tool for building narratives of comparison of their legends and powers as well, especially when looked in context of following supplemental portrayals as well:





What is to say that Ryuma or EoS Zoro won't have similar equalizers?
Any reason Roger and Shanks should have conqueror's haki superior to them?

Ok, let's ignore Roger and Whitebeard even for a moment.
Oden had no such special abilities aside from raw swordsmanship and offensive haki. Dude was very close to Kaido in power level, who had comparable haki on top of a top tier DF.
Why was this the case?

It just reiterates my point that overall combat stats matter.

Let's even look at current Luffy vs Zoro.
Let me know if you disagree, but haki vice: armament Zoro, conqeuror's and observation Luffy.
Starting with the question - which is the minimum gear Luffy needs to defeat Zoro? If it isn't base, doesn't that just prove my point that overall combat stats is the key, rather than just check list scaling of haki, DF etc?



100% disagree.

Asura is by far the biggest powerup/multiplier we've seen in the series so far.

There is a reason Zoro is not allowed to use it for more than a minute yet in the series. There is a reason Oda heavily gatekeeps this powerup, while everything else gets spammed into oblivion.



There is a difference between being an active deterrent, versus having PTSD lasting centuries which acts as a deterrent.



Argument was simply that Sanji will end up roughly comparable to Zoro.
Even if the gap appears high at the moment, it's a matter of time before it becomes narrower.

Denying Zoro/Sanji dynamics is the mirror of "Zoro cannot catch up anymore" that happened after Lucci and Katakuri. Oda is a fan of these duos and monster trio, it will stay

With Jinbe, IDK to be honest. There is a duo with Sanji/Jinbe now, but Jinbe is in his peak, Sanji will soon outscale Jinbe. I doubt it will be relevant in the future
Post automatically merged:

By the way @Blazing Lion

It's time to necro this thread again:
https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/be-honest…if-luffy-is-a-10-what-is-zoro-currently.54255/page-18#post-5444405

Let's laugh at the dudes who voted at/below 5.
Lots of Sanji fans there as well, lets see them packpeddle now that they have material to push Sanji also to that level lmao
We will have to agree to disagree.
 
#66
So only Zoro and Luffy are allowed to be strong?
Zoro and luffy should always be stronger than Sanji. Idc how much u stan Sanji, he would never beat any of the strongest fighters currently. He needed his exoskeleton/tech to survive King. He usually fights the goofy types, that give him opportunities to win. He took the Kidd route, and we know what happened to him. :endthis:
 
Top