It is a canonical fact that Warlords must never be publicly defeated while possessing the title or else they are stripped of said title. The betrayal is irrelevant, they were all going to lose their title regardless due to their respective defeats. The respective betrayals of Doflamingo and Crocodile were merely additional reasons to strip them of their title.
Oda also chose for there to be Ten Titanic Captains, which is the group that I have noticed that you are avoiding to address since they do not fit the criteria of the theory that you are peddling.
Dude, the difference in lore reveal between Cracker and Snack is going to be about a chapter, maybe two chapters. Lel. It is not some “later” retcon.
Oda chose for there to be four individuals who all held the title of Sweet Commander at the same time in the lore. End of.
Hmm, it is almost as if first, second and third strongest are always going to be comparatively stronger than anyone who is fourth strongest or below.
Who would have guessed?
Also, did you know that the second strongest Yonko Commander in a crew is always stronger than the third strongest Yonko Commander?
Or that countries with a larger population than France have more people in them?
The things one learns in a day.
Oda chose to only reveal the names of three of Shanks’ original crew members. For all we know, everyone that stood by Shanks side at Marineford is going to be revealed as a Yonko Commander or maybe Shanks just has a First Mate.
We literally know nothing about the RHPs and everything regarding their crew dynamics is purely an assumption.
Look man, if you want to invent “evidence” to back up your perception regarding the definition of certain fan terms that have never officially existed in the actual manga then go ahead, I do not care.
Just do not be surprised when no one buys whatever it is that you are selling.
Oda also chose for there to be Ten Titanic Captains, which is the group that I have noticed that you are avoiding to address since they do not fit the criteria of the theory that you are peddling.
Dude, the difference in lore reveal between Cracker and Snack is going to be about a chapter, maybe two chapters. Lel. It is not some “later” retcon.
Oda chose for there to be four individuals who all held the title of Sweet Commander at the same time in the lore. End of.
Hmm, it is almost as if first, second and third strongest are always going to be comparatively stronger than anyone who is fourth strongest or below.
Who would have guessed?
Also, did you know that the second strongest Yonko Commander in a crew is always stronger than the third strongest Yonko Commander?
Or that countries with a larger population than France have more people in them?
The things one learns in a day.
Oda chose to only reveal the names of three of Shanks’ original crew members. For all we know, everyone that stood by Shanks side at Marineford is going to be revealed as a Yonko Commander or maybe Shanks just has a First Mate.
We literally know nothing about the RHPs and everything regarding their crew dynamics is purely an assumption.
Look man, if you want to invent “evidence” to back up your perception regarding the definition of certain fan terms that have never officially existed in the actual manga then go ahead, I do not care.
Just do not be surprised when no one buys whatever it is that you are selling.
Did @nik87 finally convert you to believing that Zoro > Luffy? Surprised you rank Luffy at #4 in the crew though...or is this another "One captain 3 commanders" thing? Why would the Straw Hats need "commanders"? There's nothing for them to command...and the Grand Fleet are mostly independent, so the representatives of those divisions will lead them. If anything, the crew hierarchy will follow Shanks and Roger's crews - Luffy as captain, Zoro as VC.
