Speculations Mihawk Won his Duel With Shanks

What was the Outcome of Shanks and Mihawk's Duel?

  • Mihawk Won

  • Shanks Won

  • Draw

  • The duel was unresolved/otherwise didn't have a conclusion


Results are only viewable after voting.
#21
Unless Shanks lost his arm stopped aiming for WSS and Mihawk continued progressing reaching the peak of Swordsmanship by
fighting Marines Swordsmen..
Who cares, the Marines and the World still considers Mihawk as a stronger combatant. That's all matters. Who cares what the top tier did in 20 years, because to be frankly, none of them did shit. Where they stand now is what matters, and Mihawk got the World Strongest Swordman title.
 
#22
If it's purely a swordfight then Mihawk won... If Shanks used other abilities then Shanks won... But if it's a popular duel then Shanks probably fought fairly and only used swordsmanship...
 
#23
The scene where Shanks from off an island, nearly 100s of miles away. Breaking an admiral into a cold sweat, doesn’t indicate ACoC beams can hurt anybody?

lmao mihawk truly are something else. So I’m guess shank doing the same thing in front of greenbull won’t actually hurt greenbull lmao….see u when that debunked lol.

Why’d u make the first statement, to make this sound less foolish?
Because you adressed me as shanks hater. No intimidation was never seen hurting or damaging anyone. Its not the same as physicaly hurting someone. You really think his fighting style will be starring his opponents angrily and sending acoc shockwaves?
 
#25
Who cares, the Marines and the World still considers Mihawk as a stronger combatant. That's all matters. Who cares what the top tier did in 20 years, because to be frankly, none of them did shit. Where they stand now is what matters, and Mihawk got the World Strongest Swordman title.
no i was responding to your comment saying that Mihawk's victory or else it was pointless.. lf Mihawk kept progressing as a swordsman he would become a better Swordsman than Shanks who stopped pursuing Swordsmanship on the highest level..
 
#26
If shanks defeated an admiral from 100 miles away you’d have shit ur self literally. Point was mihawk dumbass before it happened would’ve claimed it was impossible.
:gokulaugh:
I must have missed the scene shows GB unconscious on the ground in Two Piece because in One Piece it just showed Shanks knock GB out of his element form and he decide to leave because he doesn't want to fight the entire RHP at that time.
 
#27
no i was responding to your comment saying that Mihawk's victory or else it was pointless.. lf Mihawk kept progressing as a swordsman he would become a better Swordsman than Shanks who stopped pursuing Swordsmanship on the highest level..
And that makes Mihawk the Strongest Swordman in the world and stronger than his fellow Swordman Shanks. Thanks for pointing that out :feelsokeman:
 
#28
Not a small indication that Shanks ever beaten Mihawk 1v1 either, and Mihawk is still the World Strongest Swordman
Good thing shank fans aren’t desperately trying to convince people he did….. Valueless he couldn’t beat shanks 1-1, after shank lost his main sword hand. Mihawk finally surpassed him. In swordsmanship “alone”.
:kayneshrug:
There's no indication that Whitebeard ever beat Shanks 1v1 either, and Whitebeard is still the World Strongest Man
No need WB fought characters established above Shanks. Mihawk never fought a character within the same tier as shanks let alone someone superior.

There's no indication that Kaido ever beat Shanks 1v1 either, and Kaido is still the World Strongest Creature.
:pepehawk:
Kaido individual strength well known having clashed with navy/Yonko. So much so his bounty/reputation are attributed to sheer strength People have something to compare.

Mihawk has nothing of shanks. He’s the superior swordsman largely in part to his main competition losing his main sword hand. Hardly worth the hype
:seriously:
 
#30
It was clear their duel is draw if they always fought many times that only indicate to the fact no one comes at the top.

if someone of them manage to bested the other even with single match, it would have already mention, just like how Kaido beated Moria, Mihawk loss interest fighting him when he loss his arm.

that means if shanks didnt loss his arm, they will continue to fought untill someone beat the other. :kayneshrug:
 
#31
I must have missed the scene shows GB unconscious on the ground in Two Piece because in One Piece it just showed Shanks knock GB out of his element form and he decide to leave because he doesn't want to fight the entire RHP at that time.
Did I claim shank knock him unconscious fool? The point is from an island distance shank CoC was able to make an admiral shit himself. 10 feet way he’d have done plenty more!!!!
 
#32
Good thing shank fans aren’t desperately trying to convince people he did….. Valueless he couldn’t beat shanks 1-1, after shank lost his main sword hand. Mihawk finally surpassed him. In swordsmanship “alone”.
:kayneshrug:
No need WB fought characters established above Shanks. Mihawk never fought a character within the same tier as shanks let alone someone superior.


Kaido individual strength well known having clashed with navy/Yonko. So much so his bounty/reputation are attributed to sheer strength People have something to compare.

Mihawk has nothing of shanks. He’s the superior swordsman largely in part to his main competition losing his main sword hand. Hardly worth the hype
:seriously:
Why does Shanks losing hand even matter here? Current Shanks is the Shanks without hands. He's weaker than current Mihawk. Shanks is not gonna magically grow another hand lmao.
 
#35
Why does Shanks losing hand even matter here? Current Shanks is the Shanks without hands. He's weaker than current Mihawk. Shanks is not gonna magically grow another hand lmao.
This might be one of the sheer dumbest takes on the topic.

Why does shank losing his main sword hand matter? This is the lvl of trash shank fans deal with.
:josad:

Current shank CoC> 2 armed shanks. Mihawk fans pretend they can’t comprehend this for some reason. No he doesn’t need to grow another arm to get stronger fool lmao
 
#36
Ok, but i'm saying he doesn't need to win their last fight to become the WSS..

And yes as long as sword duel goes..
Of course there's need a clear winner. Or else Mihawk's title is invalid. Would Oda undermine Zoro's dream by saying but oh Mihawk is only the 2nd strongest Swordman.
But eh why do i even bother arguing with you..
[automerge]1662253645[/automerge]
This might be one of the sheer dumbest takes on the topic.

Why does shank losing his main sword hand matter? This is the lvl of trash shank fans deal with.
:josad:

Current shank CoC> 2 armed shanks. Mihawk fans pretend they can’t comprehend this for some reason. No he doesn’t need to grow another arm to get stronger fool lmao
Are you retarded? Current Shanks is the one armed dude, and he's weaker than Mihawk. There's no point in comparing the 2 armed version, since it's just a big if. If it's 2 handed Shanks, maybe he's stronger, maybe he's not. But current Shanks is
- The one armed one
- A swordman
- Weaker than Mihawk
That's all.
 
#37
Of course there's need a clear winner. Or else Mihawk's title is invalid. Would Oda undermine Zoro's dream by saying but oh Mihawk is only the 2nd strongest Swordman.
But eh why do i even bother arguing with you..
[automerge]1662253645[/automerge]

Are you retarded? Current Shanks is the one armed dude, and he's weaker than Mihawk. There's no point in comparing the 2 armed version, since it's just a big if. If it's 2 handed Shanks, maybe he's stronger, maybe he's not. But current Shanks is
- The one armed one
- A swordman
- Weaker than Mihawk
That's all.
Been Thro this foolishness enough. Shanks being a pure swordsman post arm lost, just mihawk fans coping. Logical just sounds dumb, ur basically trying to either convince everybody the arm lost pointless.

An shanks still superior to ever swordsman in the manga including an admiral regardless. Instead of just admitting shank grown in another way (CoC)!!!
 
#38
Did I claim shank knock him unconscious fool? The point is from an island distance shank CoC was able to make an admiral shit himself. L10 feet way he’d have done plenty more!!!!
You talked about Shanks attack defeating an admiral yet GB didn't even lose consciousness which means he wasn't defeated.

Wow, a surprise attack surprises an opponent. That's literally what surprises are meant to do.

There nothing to support the attack causing more damage the closer it is. That is your headcannon. That's nothing new from you.
 

Dickie D. Dick

SII - Sakazuki Incinerate Imu
#39
No indication whatsoever Mihawk ever beaten shank. The sheer fact there still no direct statements already telling enough.

but ur evidence just subpar, the vivre cards are virtually useless. That material secondary an also often found to be misinformed.

The rest is nothing of actual note, Shank lost his main sword hand. an the world viewed mihawk the strongest. Not wrong, but not technically right either. Overall shank will be the superior combatant
:gokulaugh:
Classic snitchtard a lot of saying nothing with many words and claiming Shanks > Mihawk because headcanon lmao
 
#40
Been Thro this foolishness enough. Shanks being a pure swordsman post arm lost, just mihawk fans coping.
Shanks has been called a swordman in every media out there, by Oda himself even, even with the one armed one. King is not a pure swordman yet he got beaten the shit out of by Zoro, who's a "pure" swordman. So, "pure", or "not pure", Shanks is still a swordman. And he's below Mihawk. That's all.
 
Top