Esp since Ultra‘s case wasn’t even good. I larped as the Serial Killer in the Xmas game. I only ever open scum as Town. As scum I don‘t have the guts for it anyway.
Michelle
Post where they pinged everybody / frustration with the thread state is pretty village alligned, seems interested in solving and is p agressive. Probably never going to shake on this read.
Ultra Hi, I think you're probably town here due to the confidence of your reads. Mostly on the Flower push, but can you elaborate on why you're pushing Michelle here, given I think she's really villagery especially as of late @Ultra. I don't really see Michelle / Flower here being SvS either, so if you're still on the angle of Flower being wolf here given p#168, bit confused why you would vote Michelle. Can you look at Michelle's ISO if you have time? I think they're just. yeah.
Yoho
Hi Yoho, not very confident on your read. I think that your most recent post IE: Adamant that you're town feels village alligned, but I can't see the point in interrogating people for flavor @Yoho. I only didn't stop that last game since I was wolf and wanted to pocket you, feel like it's my obligation to point out that it doesn't really gain much for village to out flavor given scum no matter what is likely going to stick to the same flavor. It's mostly Yoho's most recent post that I like here, and the basic binary questionings of are you scum for a simple reaction test is probably villagery.
Jag Asking how you're read especially from a new player is normally >rand scum given scum wants to know there thread positioning, for ego bosting curiosity or seeing what they can get away with. Town can sometimes too but I generally see it more from woof, small thing. Also, a lack of solving in this directon and a lack of blatent town telling, feels like they're just lurking in thread in all honesty . The posts regarding Reloaded are generally village alligned I think though, feels like a new players form of solving.
Cal
Not very confident in this read, due to the qouted messages. I don't like pushing Michelle since I have her as lock V, of course his read could have changed since he most recently posted but I can't find that in his ISO. Ultra / Flower SvS read (two very strong players) who would easily just powerwolf especially on worstgen. The only thought that comes to mind if they're SvS is that they're throwing so that read coming to mind feels really wolfy. @RippedCal can you elaborate on your thought process of Ultra / Flower SvS? I can't see that angle at all, and has your read on Michelle updated?
I don't like the Yoho read here due to lack of elaboration, can you give more thoughts on that? The only thing near them there is them character speculating on Michelle which you justified with it didn't feel predatory, but can't a scum have not predatory thoughts. I get a town lean here but it seems like a jump to make. I'm also not sure on you being self depricating here given from what I've seen you're genuinly kind of a very yknow confident player if you get what I mean.
Feels genuine analyzing what a scum player would do in this instance, can see it coming from both village and wolf here granted.
Flower Not to confident in this read either. I don't like there reaction to Ultra scum reading them and calling Ultra v, felt a bit pockety when I think a GTH village reaction is to OMGUS on Ultra here, especially when she respects Ultra as a player and Ultra's read on her. @Flower can you elaborate on why you think Ultra is town? I get you think that S!Ultra would attempt to pocket you, but can't Ultra make the WIFOM argument of that?
Can you also elaborate on a few of the posts below:
This Jag read feels super weird given for Jag he didn't do anything the first few pages, it was just him getting the hang of the game and didn't make any real reads. Especially this early on so I'm confused what you mean by this, do you think you can give me an example of a few posts you thought were solvy from Jag?
Can you elaborate on this Red Night read? I don't actually think they're very wolfy this game and I'm kind of confused where you're coming to this conclusion.
This feels like a kind of town alligned read although, specifically calling yourself town as a gut reaction. The more I think about it the more I'm just not sure about this read, given S!Flower might just try to OMGUS? This is why I hate dealing with god reads. Thinking of just sheeping Ultra here and moving on in all honesty.
That's all of the actual like, qouting I'm going to do for now. I skimmed other ISO's and if you wanted GTHs on other posters: Polar Bear
Indigo
Yo Tan Wa Reloaded
Red Night
The Orca Pot Goblin
Yoho just feels like they're playing with a blind fold on. They're shooting from the hip a lot and there doesn't seem to be a lot of evidence of advice going on there
Which isn't indicitive on its own but I do feel they'd be more reserved as scum and cautious with their posting
You accused him of "posting too quickly" (Reloaded too, but for no reason you swapped him to town), and then accused him of OMGUS when he pressed back
You basically railroaded him out of the gate and decided you were going to case him, and then used his reactions as further evidence even though there's nothing on his part that requires explaining
Considering Flower's confidence and the fact that she knows whatever she says will be scrutinized, don't see it as impossible for them to be teamed either
You accused him of "posting too quickly" (Reloaded too, but for no reason you swapped him to town), and then accused him of OMGUS when he pressed back
You basically railroaded him out of the gate and decided you were going to case him, and then used his reactions as further evidence even though there's nothing on his part that requires explaining
I never accused yoho of posting too quickly, I just wanted to know why he did and see what type of response he had, his answer wasn't just terrible it was asinine
I never accused yoho of posting too quickly, I just wanted to know why he did and see what type of response he had, his answer wasn't just terrible it was asinine
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.