General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Uncle Van
- Start date
- Tags #c4ng2g carrot fans are still losers carrot haters are real losers seethe at the rabbit carrot is doing nothing because she doesn't matter carrot will never join the straw hats carrot's story never even began cry about carrot everyone else in the verse neg diffs the bunny imagine thinking stussy won't join its over furry bros keep the bunny on zou nobody else needs her let it go furry bros momo is breeding yamato no character is less relevant than carrot oden larper fans can't read stussy > carrot & yamato stussy supremacy who will be the next nakama of the week? yamato always had a better chance than carrot yamato story is over
That's the thing. Contrary to Yamato, the threads of Carrot storlines are not closed. Maybe Oda think they are, but in reality, some things are still hanging.
Like I said, nop
I do and I think you don't. I proved you multiple times already, but you are in denial so whats the point ?
You need to stop listening to hater online.
Like I said, nop
I do and I think you don't. I proved you multiple times already, but you are in denial so whats the point ?
You need to stop listening to hater online.
I can’t think of any right now, but you don’t need an example for something to happen. Oda‘s writing isn’t perfect, and he can easily throw a curveball when he feels the need to.
It was near the end, and that’s inevitable when you make an arc too long. Zoro never visited Ryuma’s grave (I’m pretty sure he said he would), and I still question why Oda made it seem like Yamato would join only to make her stay behind.
He left the door open so she could join later on, but I don’t see the point in reintroducing her so late into the story. A Wano Act 4 would need to happen soon, unless Yamato can somehow find the Straw Hats.
The chaos that ensued in the Yamato fandom after Wano ended was kinda funny.
If Carrot was introduced in Wano, I don’t think you’d be content with her only being in a few arcs if she joined near the end. She wouldn’t have much time to get character development and grow on you.
It was near the end, and that’s inevitable when you make an arc too long. Zoro never visited Ryuma’s grave (I’m pretty sure he said he would), and I still question why Oda made it seem like Yamato would join only to make her stay behind.
He left the door open so she could join later on, but I don’t see the point in reintroducing her so late into the story. A Wano Act 4 would need to happen soon, unless Yamato can somehow find the Straw Hats.
The chaos that ensued in the Yamato fandom after Wano ended was kinda funny.
If Carrot was introduced in Wano, I don’t think you’d be content with her only being in a few arcs if she joined near the end. She wouldn’t have much time to get character development and grow on you.
Yes you do. Because there is no example of relevant Character in the story put aside like Carrot was. Actually none. ALL the character in One Piece have an ending corresponding to their character arc even if for that it has to be in a cover story.
Carrot is the ONLY ONE - if we suppose that her character arc ended - with a open ended character arc.
It was not. There is no evidences of things being rushed in Wano. There are some mistakes here and there but the pacing of the arc stayed consistant. Wano being rushed (like whole cake being dragged out) are fan thoughts not actual storytelling facts.
I don't think he did but even if it was, that's not an element showing a rush in the story.
I already explained that multiple time. Its the foudnation of Yamato's story arc. Yamato wanted to be free at all cost. With the arrival of Ace, she became to think that the sea and therefore Luffy was the only way she could be free. But Yamato at the time didn't understand that freedom is more than just sailing. Freedom is being able to make your own choices. Choices that in that case are in direct opposition to what her father wated her to become. Yamato face a choice, sailing to the sea but leaving Wano alone, or making the choice to stay but letting the sea goes. SHe decided that freedom was for her to stay in Wano.
That's her arc.
Logically, the fandom can't understand subtext.
It depend, a character could be very well developped in the last arc and join. And I would be glad. There are no actual reasons why a character should join before the end.
No it wasn't rushed, there are no evidences pointing at a rush. Shanks being here is not an evidence of that. This is just a plot point that you didn't like
Carrot is the ONLY ONE - if we suppose that her character arc ended - with a open ended character arc.
It was not. There is no evidences of things being rushed in Wano. There are some mistakes here and there but the pacing of the arc stayed consistant. Wano being rushed (like whole cake being dragged out) are fan thoughts not actual storytelling facts.
I don't think he did but even if it was, that's not an element showing a rush in the story.
I already explained that multiple time. Its the foudnation of Yamato's story arc. Yamato wanted to be free at all cost. With the arrival of Ace, she became to think that the sea and therefore Luffy was the only way she could be free. But Yamato at the time didn't understand that freedom is more than just sailing. Freedom is being able to make your own choices. Choices that in that case are in direct opposition to what her father wated her to become. Yamato face a choice, sailing to the sea but leaving Wano alone, or making the choice to stay but letting the sea goes. SHe decided that freedom was for her to stay in Wano.
That's her arc.
Logically, the fandom can't understand subtext.
It depend, a character could be very well developped in the last arc and join. And I would be glad. There are no actual reasons why a character should join before the end.
No it wasn't rushed, there are no evidences pointing at a rush. Shanks being here is not an evidence of that. This is just a plot point that you didn't like
Last edited:
I know this is because of C4N but why does this have to be relitagated for years and years, yes Carrot, Yamato and Vivi can all easilly become nakama if Oda wants them too, are they right now? No
You just need to write Carrot running away from being king of Zou to the SH and them going "sure whatever join", Yamato to just have Momo be strong or have some mini time skip going to the SH and them going "sure whatever join" or Vivi comming to them and asking for shelter and the Sh going " yes vivi-chwan sure".
They all have weak and strong points but at this stage, anything goes to be honest. If anyone is saying its too late to introduce new nakamas at say Elbaf, this better be the last arc where someone gushes for a new nakama of the week.
You just need to write Carrot running away from being king of Zou to the SH and them going "sure whatever join", Yamato to just have Momo be strong or have some mini time skip going to the SH and them going "sure whatever join" or Vivi comming to them and asking for shelter and the Sh going " yes vivi-chwan sure".
They all have weak and strong points but at this stage, anything goes to be honest. If anyone is saying its too late to introduce new nakamas at say Elbaf, this better be the last arc where someone gushes for a new nakama of the week.
I know this is because of C4N but why does this have to be relitagated for years and years, yes Carrot, Yamato and Vivi can all easilly become nakama if Oda wants them too, are they right now? No
You just need to write Carrot running away from being king of Zou to the SH and them going "sure whatever join", Yamato to just have Momo be strong or have some mini time skip going to the SH and them going "sure whatever join" or Vivi comming to them and asking for shelter and the Sh going " yes vivi-chwan sure".
They all have weak and strong points but at this stage, anything goes to be honest. If anyone is saying its too late to introduce new nakamas at say Elbaf, this better be the last arc where someone gushes for a new nakama of the week.
You just need to write Carrot running away from being king of Zou to the SH and them going "sure whatever join", Yamato to just have Momo be strong or have some mini time skip going to the SH and them going "sure whatever join" or Vivi comming to them and asking for shelter and the Sh going " yes vivi-chwan sure".
They all have weak and strong points but at this stage, anything goes to be honest. If anyone is saying its too late to introduce new nakamas at say Elbaf, this better be the last arc where someone gushes for a new nakama of the week.
G
Post automatically merged:
"It was completely reasonable to think a character with no dream who never had their own arc and was absent for 250 chapters in a row was about to join the crew. How could anyone have guessed except for literally everyone but me
Last edited by a moderator:
