General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[AL sama]

You didn't know that? apparently Robin was just another side character in Alabasta lol

in that arc??

You know the Character that can read the PG. the only character that can help Luffy achieve his dream. The most important one. Yeah Carrot shits on that character importance wise.
BTW guys after wano Luffy is just a side character and Carrot will take over the story. She’ll bring the Dawn and find the one piece

 

[Animangaboy]

the scabbards..

Or Hiyori..

Or Momo...

Yeah.. pretty much all the main arc characters hm

But where is the “Rumor strawhat” on this lists not to mention kidd killer apo drake and Law all have a moment in Wano Meanwhile carrot doing nothing 😭

 

[Logiko]

isn't that what you implied ??

Nah. What I said is that Carrot was more important in Whole Cake in the narration of the arc that Robin was in the narration of Alabasta.

Robin's importance only appeared at the end of the arc while being absent for the majority of Alabasta while Carrot was always here, participated to save the strawhat multiple time, had multiple interactions with the main character had multiple emotionnal and strong moment and had two chapter for her Sulong form with one chapter almost entirely given to her character only.

So yeh.. Carrot was more important in whole cake than Robin in alabasta.. narratively but Robin is more important than Carrot overall in the story.

Tama won't join the crew Luffy is about to go against The Blackbeard Pirates so tell me where Tama could join the crew

Recruitments are not about strenght.

carrot can't even fight anyone in the BB crew without using her sulong form too 😭🤔

I would not be so sure of that - what's your proof for saying that ? Did you have a panel of Carrot defeated by each BB pirates ?

Post automatically merged: Apr 19, 2022

But where is the “Rumor strawhat” on this lists not to mention kidd killer apo drake and Law all have a moment in Wano Meanwhile carrot doing nothing 😭

"The rumor strawhat ?" what is this ? A new kind of hat ?

 

[Animangaboy]

Recruitments are not about strenght

Tama won't be joining the free so let's not with the recruitment bullshit cause shanks and buggy was still fighting in the roger pirates

 

[Logiko]

Tama won't be joining the free so let's not with the recruitment bullshit cause shanks and buggy was still fighting in the roger pirates

Actually we don't know if Tama will join or not. But there are sign that Tama COULD be joining the crew so yeah.. we CAN go there.

 

[Animangaboy]

would not be so sure of that - what's your proof for saying that ? Did you have a panel of Carrot defeated by each BB pirate?

The BB pirates were in impel down at level 6 U think carrot what it takes to go against the BB pirates? Let alone shanks pirates in a friendly match

 

[Roo]

in that arc??

lol I had this argument with them before, they truly believe Robin wasn't important in Alabasta

 

[AL sama]

Nah. What I said is that Carrot was more important in Whole Cake in the narration of the arc that Robin was in the narration of Alabasta.

Robin's importance only appeared at the end of the arc while being absent for the majority of Alabasta while Carrot was always here, participated to save the strawhat multiple time, had multiple interactions with the main character had multiple emotionnal and strong moment and had two chapter for her Sulong form with one chapter almost entirely given to her character only.

I guess I can agree with that to a degree

 

[Logiko]

The BB pirates were in impel down at level 6 U think carrot what it takes to go against the BB pirates? Let alone shanks pirates in a friendly match

Why not ? Yes I think she has what it takes. There is nothing in the story showing that Carrot could not be up to the challenge. It doesn't mean that it would be easy but it's possible.

 

[Animangaboy]

Actually we don't know if Tama will join or not. But there are sign that Tama COULD be joining the crew so yeah.. we CAN go there.

Where are the signs showing tama wants to join luffy? 👀 where did tama say she wants to go with luffy? 🤔

Post automatically merged: Apr 19, 2022

Why not ? Yes I think she has what it takes. There is nothing in the story showing that Carrot could not be up to the challenge. It doesn't mean that it would be easy but it's possible.

😭😭😂 she couldn't even beat persopers in her sulong form with even Wander meanwhile if it was Yamato she would simply do a thunder Bagua with ACOC

 

[Monkey D Al]

Why not ? Yes I think she has what it takes. There is nothing in the story showing that Carrot could not be up to the challenge. It doesn't mean that it would be easy but it's possible.

Seriously??? She got her ass handed by persopero in sulong form. At best she could fight a headliner from the beast pirates. And that’s in sulong form.

 

[AL sama]

lol I had this argument with them before, they truly believe Robin wasn't important in Alabasta

robin was important but we didn't understand that till almost the end of the arc

that's what he is saying so I can give him that much

 

[Monkey D Al]

Geezer tree and unicorn for Nakama. Most important characters in thriller bark. If they would’ve been part of the crew Kuma would have died right there.

 

[BOCCHI]

It's not about what I want or don't want. It's about what the story is hinting at

The story definitely not hinting anything regarding Carrot let alone her joining the crew.

 

[Logiko]

lol I had this argument with them before, they truly believe Robin wasn't important in Alabasta

Funny how most of people here are deforming what I'm saying and inventing stuff like you are doing here.

Never said Robin was not important in Alabasta. I said that her importance only shined at the end of the arc while she was just slighly important before (just to remind you because you don't seems to remember the arc, Robin was an henchman during most of Alabasta with only two big moment (when she stops Pell and when she saves Luffy)

Where are the signs showing tama wants to join luffy? 👀 where did tama say she wants to go with luffy? 🤔

- Tama asked Ace to join his crew, so their is a possibility that she asked Luffy too
- Tama had a dream dream setup and there hasn't been anypayoff yet. There is a possibility that Tama decide to accomplish her dream with Luffy
- Tama follows momo everywhere so if Momo joins the crew, there is a possibility that Tama will follow him using the same tactic (maturing like him)
- Tama is one of the few people in the story who whore the strawhat.

Seriously??? She got her ass handed by persopero in sulong form.

Wrong, She had the advantage in Sulong with wanda.

she couldn't even beat persopers in her sulong form with even Wander meanwhile if it was Yamato she would simply do a thunder Bagua with ACOC

Perospero is comparable to Jack in term of strenght and Carrot had the advantage Sulong went out. So you can divide the strenght of Jack by two and you have the strenght of Carrot without power up: Something between a 300 and a 500 B man.

robin was important but we didn't understand that till almost the end of the arc

that's what he is saying so I can give him that much

Yes. Robin for the overall story it definitely more important than Carrot. But in the narration of the arc itself, Robin is just a henchman who is a bit mysterious and helps Luffy once. So she is a bit important but nothing like Carrot in whole cake who had multiple interactions with the crew, who helped the strawhats multiple times, who saved them multiple times, who had multiple strong emotionnal moments and had a very strong character moment during the Sulong transformation who focus the attention of everything on her for almost an entire chapter.

That's why I often say that Carrot is much more legitimate to join the crew at the current time than Robin after Alabasta if we are talking about the relevance of the character to join the crew.

The story definitely not hinting anything regarding Carrot let alone her joining the crew.

Well read again. You missed a lot.

 

[Roo]

Funny how most of people here are deforming what I'm saying and inventing stuff like you are doing here.

Never said Robin was not important in Alabasta. I said that her importance only shined at the end of the arc while she was just slighly important before (just to remind you because you don't seems to remember the arc, Robin was an henchman during most of Alabasta with only two big moment (when she stops Pell and when she saves Luffy)

No you didn't, you can easily search our argument here and you cant find a quote of you putting that disclaimer in

 

[BOCCHI]

Well read again. You missed a lot.

I read it well. Tho it seems you read stuff that doesn’t exist.

 

[Animangaboy]

Tama asked Ace to join his crew, so their is a possibility that she asked Luffy too
- Tama had a dream dream setup and there hasn't been anypayoff yet. There is a possibility that Tama decide to accomplish her dream with Luffy
- Tama follows momo everywhere so if Momo joins the crew, there is a possibility that Tama will follow him using the same tactic (maturing like him)
- Tama is one of the few people in the story who whore the strawhat.

No one who reads the story thinks she will join and also didn't ace tell her that she has to get older first?

 

[Monkey D Al]

Wrong, She had the advantage in Sulong with wanda

 

[Logiko]

No you didn't, you can easily search our argument here and you cant find a quote of you putting that disclaimer in

Yes like I said, never said that Robin was not important. Glad you agree.

I read it well. Tho it seems you read stuff that doesn’t exist

Or maybe I see things you can't see :cheers:

No one who reads the story thinks she will join and also didn't ace tell her that she has to get older first?

I didn't say she will join, I said that was a possibility, and yes some people are thinking about it. And read what I'm saying please, your last comment shows that you didn't.