General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
I don't think you understand how Oda handles roles then. He shows them off all the time, even when it's not relevant or important.
For example, all the names of Sanji's attacks are food puns and he constantly makes cooking one-liners in the middle of fights
In Zou, Brook sang a song about Nekomamushi. It added nothing to the story but he did it anyway
Or for a super minor example, when the crew found the ship that fell from Skypiea, Nami was the one to first examine the map. It could've been any other character and the plot wouldn't change but it was Nami, the navigator/cartographer of the crew.
None of these examples have any real relevance and could have been cut/changed without losing anything, but they happened anyway. Why? Because little moments like these show that the crew's talents are things that they all worked hard to be good at. They don't only show their roles when the plot demands it or when it's important, but all the time. Their roles are a part of their character.
So what does it say that when the crew was sneaking into enemy territory and Usopp, not Carrot, was the one to serve as the lookout? If this was really what Carrot's role was supposed to be, then why wasn't she doing more?
I can get where you're coming from, but I feel like Drum Island was the arc where I actually understood what inherited will was. It had been referenced earlier, but I assumed it was supposed to be some reincarnation thing at first. But anyway my point is that the main theme of the arc where Chopper joined was Inherited Will, so I consider that the theme of his character. Just like how the theme of Enies Lobby, Robin's arc, was that every friend is irreplaceable.
Though I guess we could just agree to disagree on this
Luffy, Sanji, Robin, and maybe Zoro probably could. Jimbei could as well if he wasn't the one steering the ship
No?
Even Luffy knows not to engage in a fight when it puts his crew in danger. That's why he told them to run away in Sabaody
What Carrot did was destroy the helms of the enemy fleet. Which is fine and good, but couldn't Robin just create some hands, smash or break the helms, and then despawn her hands before the enemies can do anything about it?
When the crew arrives on Laugh Tale, do you think they just won't care or won't have any wonder when they're arriving on the legendary island?
Usopp's whole thing is that he's a sniper and he arguably has the best CoO feat we've seen so far in Dressrosa. And since he'll definitely surpass Yasopp and Augur by the end of the series, he'll only get better.
Sure it's debatable, but she can only use Sulong once a month
Recon is intel
Then why would you bring it up?
Show me one instance that would suggest this
And? Would Carrot somehow do it better?
Except that Brook was also a musician, so he had skills that no other Strawhat did
And part of being the perfect fit is being really good at it
For example, all the names of Sanji's attacks are food puns and he constantly makes cooking one-liners in the middle of fights
None of these examples have any real relevance and could have been cut/changed without losing anything, but they happened anyway. Why? Because little moments like these show that the crew's talents are things that they all worked hard to be good at. They don't only show their roles when the plot demands it or when it's important, but all the time. Their roles are a part of their character.
So what does it say that when the crew was sneaking into enemy territory and Usopp, not Carrot, was the one to serve as the lookout? If this was really what Carrot's role was supposed to be, then why wasn't she doing more?
I can get where you're coming from, but I feel like Drum Island was the arc where I actually understood what inherited will was. It had been referenced earlier, but I assumed it was supposed to be some reincarnation thing at first. But anyway my point is that the main theme of the arc where Chopper joined was Inherited Will, so I consider that the theme of his character. Just like how the theme of Enies Lobby, Robin's arc, was that every friend is irreplaceable.
Though I guess we could just agree to disagree on this
Luffy, Sanji, Robin, and maybe Zoro probably could. Jimbei could as well if he wasn't the one steering the ship
No?
Even Luffy knows not to engage in a fight when it puts his crew in danger. That's why he told them to run away in Sabaody
What Carrot did was destroy the helms of the enemy fleet. Which is fine and good, but couldn't Robin just create some hands, smash or break the helms, and then despawn her hands before the enemies can do anything about it?
When the crew arrives on Laugh Tale, do you think they just won't care or won't have any wonder when they're arriving on the legendary island?
Usopp's whole thing is that he's a sniper and he arguably has the best CoO feat we've seen so far in Dressrosa. And since he'll definitely surpass Yasopp and Augur by the end of the series, he'll only get better.
Sure it's debatable, but she can only use Sulong once a month
Recon is intel
Then why would you bring it up?
Show me one instance that would suggest this
And? Would Carrot somehow do it better?
Except that Brook was also a musician, so he had skills that no other Strawhat did
And part of being the perfect fit is being really good at it
Like I said, the fact that Oda choosed to lay low Carrot while giving her everything in whole cake is odd..
But it can be explained narratively. (I won't explain that here again)
Trust me that once Carrot rejoin the group, Oda will show her at the post right away.
(Also, Remember, the post is an extension of the character theme and arc. For Carrot it's wonder, that's why you can see Lunar Attacks with Carrot, it's in line with that theme and the theme of the moon Rabbit.)
Not in that context. Not with such a precision. It had to be quick and precise.
Yes he is.. In the air, Sanji is pretty slow (compared to the speed of the SUlong fly)
Yeah.. in that situation on the other hand I wouldn't be so sure.
Robin doesn't have that kind of Power and/or stamina. At that distance, it would have been possible but much slower.
Of course they will, just like Luffy has pride or Chopper determination.. but the one who will still holds the torch for that theme will still be Carrot. Because that's how she was created and that's how she will grow.
That's the thing.. he didn't at least not right now. It means therefore that yasopp and Van Augur are the best feat for the post.. Either that or we forget that the skill plays such an important part into the job.. and the construction of the post becomes much more logical.
Everything in a story is determined to play a role. If Oda wants the character to shine he will find a way.
That's why I prefer to use the word "sentinell" for Carrot: A sentry being both a sentinell and a look out.
Granted, but only because it's part of the job of the Sentry not the whole thing, but I did forgot that. I may make evolve that point.
I don't have the time to make a montage right now, but comapre the speed of Sanji go higher in the air when he skywalks and Carrot flying thorugh the air in chapter 888, you will see a difference in term of speed treatment.
Yes, by the simple fact that Carrot is a experienced look out. And that being able to float and go high is not alll there is to it, you need to see far too and be able to distinguish ennemy, locate and communicate properly.
Look out is a real job mate.
Franky is a musician too.
And she is.
"I can totally explain why Carrot never showed her role except for one time a hundred sixty chapters ago."
"I won't explain that here though"
Why does it have to be precise? Just punch/kick it
You're comparing the speed on still images
If she's strong enough to break spines she's strong enough to break some wooden boards
But we see Usopp doing it when they go into Onigashima
Not everything in a story has a role. Especially in a story that has been serialized for over 20 years
Then what is a sentry? I read your blog and I genuinely don't understand what about it is unique
Then why don't we see her doing it when they're entering Onigashima instead of Usopp if she's a better lookout than him?
True but it's not as prominent an aspect of his character as it is with Brook
And what are you basing this off of again?
"I won't explain that here though"
Why does it have to be precise? Just punch/kick it
You're comparing the speed on still images
If she's strong enough to break spines she's strong enough to break some wooden boards
But we see Usopp doing it when they go into Onigashima
Not everything in a story has a role. Especially in a story that has been serialized for over 20 years
Then what is a sentry? I read your blog and I genuinely don't understand what about it is unique
Then why don't we see her doing it when they're entering Onigashima instead of Usopp if she's a better lookout than him?
True but it's not as prominent an aspect of his character as it is with Brook
And what are you basing this off of again?
I already have done that 1000 times already..
Because the goal is to be quick and not to fight for nothing.
Yes it's possible. When you look at how it's drawn.
Maybe but not at that speed.
We see Usopp be a sniper, not a look out.
Well read that article again: If you still don't understand.. i don't know what to say to you.. What makes Carrot exceptionnal is what she did on 888 andhow she did it. I won't debate on that anymore.
Because we needed a Sniper, not a look out.
Everything in the story.
Because the goal is to be quick and not to fight for nothing.
Yes it's possible. When you look at how it's drawn.
Maybe but not at that speed.
We see Usopp be a sniper, not a look out.
Well read that article again: If you still don't understand.. i don't know what to say to you.. What makes Carrot exceptionnal is what she did on 888 andhow she did it. I won't debate on that anymore.
Because we needed a Sniper, not a look out.
Everything in the story.
You're way too rude with @CarrotForNakama and anyway, I prefer 100 times more her than stupid Raizo or Momonosuke
- Status