General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Animangaboy]

I explained you multiple time that Carrot is a teenagers fan of wonders who choose to see a world of wonders and adventure. Only people who don't read story or don't have children would think that a teen would just go back home on her own when she has the choice to sneak back again. It wouldn't make sence on a narrative perspective and it wouldn't make sence on her character perspective.

Stop looking at Carrot with the same prism you are looking at any character, Carrot is not Robin, Carrot is not Yamato, Carrot is not Luffy, Carrot had her own characterization.

But didn't she already go on her adventure with the crew already?
U keep saying to sneak on the ship like there is any reason for her to do that again it's hasn't been shown that she wants to do that again but u keep saying it CAN happen again like what would be the purpose and reason for it and if you said the “Pedro will” is doesn't show that carrot wants to know what he meant by.
But when Yamato who was waiting on luffy for a couple of years want to go with luffy on his adventures is a MAJOR NO for u but it's okay for carrot “sneaks on board".

 

[hk1992]

The next SH who will take the place of the captain is joy boy

 

[Staticshadic]

None. She just had nowhere else to go and she was probably intrigued by Luffy

Robin join luffy Because she originally, thought she was meant to die in alabasta. She was willing give up her own ambition and her ideals. But it was luffy that save her life
Robin stated there was no where else to go or return to. She end up deciding joining luffy.
Throughout alabasta arc Robin there so much mystery surrounding her character.
For example
Her knowing about the will of d
To many enemies with in her dream
Void century
Possible sinking 10 battle warship at the age of 8
the government has been looking for her for 20 years
When she asked Luffy Join his crew he did not seem be problem it letting her join the crew. Because she was not bad person begin with

All those things would end up being relevant in water 7 and enies lobby
Vs
carrot


Who does not have a future potential backstory surrounding her character
All of Carrot enemies that affected her in her past life Have already been defeated by Non straw hats. So, there is no incentive for her to continue her path with the straw hats If everything in personal life has already been resolve.

Throughout this entire raid Carrot was not even display a alongside the strawhats and their alliance while they are fighting against their opponents. Her fight was completely skip over. We did not even see Carrot reaction when Luffy lost his fight against Kaido and him saying he will comeback defeat Kaido..
She is not a special mink as you say. She has not shown with new abilities that make her standout.
Carrot even in this chapter showing to be more to be support of role rather than main character status. She does not give epic speech that makes her stand out character in terms what they are fighting for. When you say Carrot going be stowaway again it just seems your worried about your character falling in the background, she might not join strawhats at all.

 

[Fuckthis3]

Larrot has become nothing more than Neko's shadow following him around because she's that much of a weak ass fodder she'd probably get negged by a beast pirate fodder especially when she can only Sulong once without dying

Again "probably" still not confidence in your words lol

 

[Animangaboy]

Robin join luffy Because she originally, thought she was meant to die in alabasta. She was willing give up her own ambition and her ideals. But it was luffy that save her life
Robin stated there was no where else to go or return to. She end up deciding joining luffy.
Throughout alabasta arc Robin there so much mystery surrounding her character.
For example
Her knowing about the will of d
To many enemies with in her dream
Void century
Possible sinking 10 battle warship at the age of 8
the government has been looking for her for 20 years
When she asked Luffy Join his crew he did not seem be problem it letting her join the crew. Because she was not bad person begin with

All those things would end up being relevant in water 7 and enies lobby
Vs
carrot


Who does not have a future potential backstory surrounding her character
All of Carrot enemies that affected her in her past life Have already been defeated by Non straw hats. So, there is no incentive for her to continue her path with the straw hats If everything in personal life has already been resolve.

Throughout this entire raid Carrot was not even display a alongside the strawhats and their alliance while they are fighting against their opponents. Her fight was completely skip over. We did not even see Carrot reaction when Luffy lost his fight against Kaido and him saying he will comeback defeat Kaido..
She is not a special mink as you say. She has not shown with new abilities that make her standout.
Carrot even in this chapter showing to be more to be support of role rather than main character status. She does not give epic speech that makes her stand out character in terms what they are fighting for. When you say Carrot going be stowaway again it just seems your worried about your character falling in the background, she might not join strawhats at all.

Robin join luffy Because she originally, thought she was meant to die in alabasta. She was willing give up her own ambition and her ideals. But it was luffy that save her life
Robin stated there was no where else to go or return to. She end up deciding joining luffy.
Throughout alabasta arc Robin there so much mystery surrounding her character.
For example
Her knowing about the will of d
To many enemies with in her dream
Void century
Possible sinking 10 battle warship at the age of 8
the government has been looking for her for 20 years
When she asked Luffy Join his crew he did not seem be problem it letting her join the crew. Because she was not bad person begin with

All those things would end up being relevant in water 7 and enies lobby
Vs
carrot


Who does not have a future potential backstory surrounding her character
All of Carrot enemies that affected her in her past life Have already been defeated by Non straw hats. So, there is no incentive for her to continue her path with the straw hats If everything in personal life has already been resolve.

Throughout this entire raid Carrot was not even display a alongside the strawhats and their alliance while they are fighting against their opponents. Her fight was completely skip over. We did not even see Carrot reaction when Luffy lost his fight against Kaido and him saying he will comeback defeat Kaido..
She is not a special mink as you say. She has not shown with new abilities that make her standout.
Carrot even in this chapter showing to be more to be support of role rather than main character status. She does not give epic speech that makes her stand out character in terms what they are fighting for. When you say Carrot going be stowaway again it just seems your worried about your character falling in the background, she might not join strawhats at all.

@CarrotForNakama open your eyes and read this and stop trying to make carrot an IMPORTANT character when she lacks all of those...

 

[RobinsFeet]

Come back to me in three chapter, and we will see who is laughing lol

I 100% will remind you!

No excuses this time ok mr. super analyst?

 

[TEACH D TEACH]

I 100% will remind you!

No excuses this time ok mr. super analyst?

How many times has he put a timeline for himself now? Hes obviously talking out of his ass, in 4 weeks he will say the same thing again

 

[Pot Goblin]

This thread will get real spicy after the 3 chapter time limit is up, whether or not the prediction comes true or not.

 

[Staticshadic]

How many times has he put a timeline for himself now? Hes obviously talking out of his ass, in 4 weeks he will say the same thing again

He will just say " just wait".

 

[Seatonnes]

Waribou >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Midrot, Midmato

Post automatically merged: Mar 12, 2022

 

[Cockycent]

Carrot might join the Straw Hat pirates.

 

[Rootbeer]

2 panel flashback, 1 panel protagonist, 0 panel relevant...
Welcome to wonderland..

 

[Topi Jerami]

2 panel with Luffy, 200 panels cosplaying, 200 panels babysiting...

Welcome the new guardian dog of Wano

 

[Logiko]

But didn't she already go on her adventure with the crew already?

Yes CArrot did go on an adventure, the question is.. why would she stop ??? THere is no narrative reason for her to stop. Carrot has been depicted enjoying this adventure TOO MUCH (even more after the death of Pedro) so.. in order for the return for Carrot to Zou to make sence, Oda needs to SHOW Carrot wanting to go back.

This is a fundamental rule in storytelling, you can't just change character's mindset out of nowhere, it has to be explained first. Carrot changed too much. So if Oda plans to make Carrot go back to Zou, he has to EXPLAIN WHY.

Not doing that would make no sence in the characterization, this is important! This is something writers learn in the very beginning of their carrier:

You don't create a teenager wanting to go out on a adventure and suddenly wanting to go home. If that teenager has the possibility to sneak again, you MUST make him sneak again UNLESS.. their is a reason for him not to do that.. That's something that happened often in "Malcom in the middle" for exemple. The author pushed the kid to do a stunt.. but to actually stop that kid from doing it, they had to give him a reason NOT to do it.. without that, it would not make sence for the kid to stop.

It's similar with Carrot

Robin join luffy Because she originally, thought she was meant to die in alabasta. She was willing give up her own ambition and her ideals. But it was luffy that save her life
Robin stated there was no where else to go or return to. She end up deciding joining luffy.
Throughout alabasta arc Robin there so much mystery surrounding her character.
For example
Her knowing about the will of d
To many enemies with in her dream
Void century
Possible sinking 10 battle warship at the age of 8
the government has been looking for her for 20 years
When she asked Luffy Join his crew he did not seem be problem it letting her join the crew. Because she was not bad person begin with

All those things would end up being relevant in water 7 and enies lobby
Vs
carrot


Who does not have a future potential backstory surrounding her character
All of Carrot enemies that affected her in her past life Have already been defeated by Non straw hats. So, there is no incentive for her to continue her path with the straw hats If everything in personal life has already been resolve.

Throughout this entire raid Carrot was not even display a alongside the strawhats and their alliance while they are fighting against their opponents. Her fight was completely skip over. We did not even see Carrot reaction when Luffy lost his fight against Kaido and him saying he will comeback defeat Kaido..
She is not a special mink as you say. She has not shown with new abilities that make her standout.
Carrot even in this chapter showing to be more to be support of role rather than main character status. She does not give epic speech that makes her stand out character in terms what they are fighting for. When you say Carrot going be stowaway again it just seems your worried about your character falling in the background, she might not join strawhats at all.

I don't care about all that. The discussion was not a comparison of what Robin did and Carrot did (this is irrelevant by the way) it was a comparison on the fact that both are stowaway.

Don't change the subject

I 100% will remind you!

No excuses this time ok mr. super analyst?

No problem. If that specific panel didn't happen in the next three chapter (because I think that Kaido will be beaten in the next three chapter, it could take a bit longer) I'm willing to say that Carrot chances dropped to 70%

How many times has he put a timeline for himself now? Hes obviously talking out of his ass, in 4 weeks he will say the same thing again

In 4 weeks, if that panel happened, I win

If not Carrot chances will be dropping fast. Simple.

 

[Staticshadic]

Yes CArrot did go on an adventure, the question is.. why would she stop ??? THere is no narrative reason for her to stop. Carrot has been depicted enjoying this adventure TOO MUCH (even more after the death of Pedro) so.. in order for the return for Carrot to Zou to make sence, Oda needs to SHOW Carrot wanting to go back.

This is a fundamental rule in storytelling, you can't just change character's mindset out of nowhere, it has to be explained first. Carrot changed too much. So if Oda plans to make Carrot go back to Zou, he has to EXPLAIN WHY.

Not doing that would make no sence in the characterization, this is important! This is something writers learn in the very beginning of their carrier:

You don't create a teenager wanting to go out on a adventure and suddenly wanting to go home. If that teenager has the possibility to sneak again, you MUST make him sneak again UNLESS.. their is a reason for him not to do that.. That's something that happened often in "Malcom in the middle" for exemple. The author pushed the kid to do a stunt.. but to actually stop that kid from doing it, they had to give him a reason NOT to do it.. without that, it would not make sence for the kid to stop.

It's similar with Carrot



I don't care about all that. The discussion was not a comparison of what Robin did and Carrot did (this is irrelevant by the way) it was a comparison on the fact that both are stowaway.

Don't change the subject



No problem. If that specific panel didn't happen in the next three chapter (because I think that Kaido will be beaten in the next three chapter, it could take a bit longer) I'm willing to say that Carrot chances dropped to 70%




In 4 weeks, if that panel happened, I win if not Carrot chances are dropping fast. Simple.

I’m not changing the subject. You’re the one who’s making fucking excuses for your precious bunny girl not irrelevant in the fucking story

 

[Cockycent]

Carrot has spent time with multiple Straw Hats and built bonds with them.

 

[Logiko]

I’m not changing the subject. You’re the one who’s making fucking excuses for your precious bunny girl who’s barely irrelevant in the fucking story

Yes you are. The question was: why would fan accept Carrot stowawing, the answer was, because fan accepted already a stowaway before. Simple.

Now, there more reason for Carrot to join than any other character, there is no need for "excuses", it's in the story, you will just have to read it. It will be to late for you to switch side once Carrot is on the ship.

 

[Monkey D Al]

Yes you are. The question was: why would fan accept Carrot stowawing, the answer was, because fan accepted already a stowaway before. Simple.

Now, there more reason for Carrot to join than any other character, there is no need for "excuses", it's in the story, you will just have to read it. It will be to late for you to switch side once Carrot is on the ship.

Well the majority of the fans will never except Larrot.

So if Oda plans to make Carrot go back to Zou, he has to EXPLAIN WHY.

Simple after the party of wano. Before the departure from wano Momo and the scabbards will all about the dawn that Luffy will bring that they need to prepare for that. The minks are going back to Zou to prepare for that day. And bunny girl will as well. She will get 1 panel saying something deep and long like okay or yes or mhm

 

[Topi Jerami]

Well the majority of the fans will never except Larrot.

Simple after the party of wano. Before the departure from wano Momo and the scabbards will all about the dawn that Luffy will bring that they need to prepare for that. The minks are going back to Zou to prepare for that day. And bunny girl will as well. She will get 1 panel saying something deep and long like okay or yes or mhm

Not sure you guys are trolling together and convince each other that you all are actually serious, or just genuinely dumb in general.

How can you all keep shitting on Carrot because she now interacts with the minks and not with the Straw Hats anymore like how it used to be during WCI days.. while also dumbly celebrating that Yamao is babysitting Momo in every chapters?
The guardian bitch babysitted Momo in the beginning, then she came to Rooftop and you were celebrating, that actually still makes sense...
But then she went down from Rooftop, and come back babysitting the same kid again. Yet you all apparently celebrating again, wtf???????

After Rooftop, Oda could have made her interacting with other Straw Hats, like Robin and Brook. Protecting Robin from CP0, together with all new members after Ennies Lobby arc, Brook and Jinbe.
Yet nope, Oda intentionally separated her from Robin and Brook, and then she came back babysitting again.

 

[Seatonnes]

@CarrotForNakama explain this