Who will be the next Strawhat


  • Total voters
    895
Status
Not open for further replies.
All great examples of mental gymnastics when we have the very easy and simple reality that Yamato will go to sea because it’s her dream to do so.
Don't talk about mental gymnastics, Mr. Carrot is going to leave the sunny to hunt all the ponegliffs in the world!
Hiyori would be the example of the usual arc princess. Even Momo is more in that mould given how useless he was for a good chunk of Wano.

Yamato, even if not joining, would be a Law figure, not a princess. The One Piece damsel in distresses aren’t the dynamic fighting figures that Yamato is
So the daughter of an emperor that is nicknamed the "oni princess", is in fact not the princess of Onigashima..?

Garp...you're a treasure.
Well done, you’ve managed to arrive at the shocking revelation that not everything a character said will come true.
This is news to you, not me.
You’re also throwing in a lot more “possibles” and “mights” now, not the absolute convictions you started with.
Clearly this is a lot for you so I'm trying to ease you into it.
Yes, I can admit I’m wrong, we’ll see how well you take it when Carrot continues to not sail with the Strawhats.

I still win cause I got the man I really wanted in Jinbei, so Yamato’s just a bonus.
Nothing wrong with admitting when you're wrong. That's not what I was laughing over. That would your lack of basic understanding of what the story of OP is about.
There’s never been much worry about Carrot’s association with it
You literally said you let your Carrot hate cloud your judgement on the obvious. Carrot is connected to the dawn. And so you downplayed the plot to minimise Carrot's potential role. Those are your words, not mine, lmao.

We had to baby you and explain that although the dawn is only being explicitly mentioned now, it's actually been happening from the very beginning of the series since Luffy set out from dawn island. It took post after post before you finally understood something so simple.
No, it‘s a really shit argument that makes no sense at all. Where you get this idea that the aftermath of Wano will be Momo and Yamato randomly sailing off into the sunset together in search for allies I have no clue.
It's from reading the story and applying basic analysis. Momo's entire character has been about his personal development into a leader and recognising that it's ok to accept help from others. Yamao's character is about wanting to be Oden. Someone who protected Wano, adventured around the world, and was loved by all.

The WG is threatening not only Wano, but the entire world in a great cleansing. So it makes perfect sense for Yamao and Momo to go together to rally the nations of the world to finally come together. Momo demonstrating what he learnt about working with others as well as his growth as a leader in organising such a huge allied force. Yamao demonstrating that she can be friends with humans and become someone respected the world over, like Oden.
Can’t say yet until we know why Wano is so important to all these figures and why it had to be shut in the first place.
We already know that Wano had to be shut to protect it from a "great external force", (i.e. the WG).
“Threads.” There’s one thread and that’s “why are the Strawhats important.“ She’ll find that out along with everyone else at the end of the arc and that’s it for her. A short stint as a cover story awaits her, which is more focus than she’s had on Wano at least.
There's more than that, but for the sake of argument let's just stick with that one. Carrot needs to find out why the straw hats are important. This being the final statement of her dead mentor, and something yet to be resolved over 150 chapters later. Sure.

So why is Carrot the one that has a plot about her coming to this realisation? And you're wrong that everyone else also needs to realise this. The straw hat's importance is something that is already known to them. Inu and Neko showing the ponegliffs to the crew, Marco saying they're the real stars. Kin emon declaring that Luffy will stand at the top of the seas...This is all something that's known. Yet Carrot is the only one Oda had go through the process of needing to learn exactly why they're important. That's huge set up. Why you think she'll finally understand this after hundreds of chapters of travelling with them as close friends, and then decide to just go off and do her own thing, I have no idea.
Oh yeah, who can forget that time Luffy said Carrot’s name in a list inckuding Brulee. Memorable.
Sweet Jesus, what...?
If you're in fact talking about this scene then I can't think of a better example to illustrate the decline in your reading comprehension. Instead of seeing Katakuri questioning Brulee's sudden appearance and what's about to happen, you see Luffy asking his bestie Brulee to hold things down on the sunny without him...You're washed... Bring back Hero Garp. He could read.
Don’t give a fuck what names Luffy calls Yamato
Lmaooo. I'm sure you don't. Fortunately you're not Oda though. So I in turn don't need to give a fuck about that.

And if you paid attention to names you'd realise that like Yamao, Luffy doesn't call Brulee by her name but instead "branch", which would've made it even easier to realise that it was very obviously Katakuri speaking.
 





a reminder that Luffy knew Sanji and Franky’s name, yet Luffy still called them as he wanted. Luffy and Yamato met in the middle of the raid, they’ve been together not even a day.

Seriously? Calling name correctly is more important than dealing with the real threat which is Kaido, Big Mom, Orochi and Beast Pirates? Any dumber argument please?:whitepress:
Thank you for ending this pathetic argument point. :cheers:
 
About that xd. I was rereading Dressrosa recently:
That line strongly reminds me of some other recent claims. It never turned the way in was stated tho. At all.
It was her last day in the coliseum and Doflamingo was raken care of in her stead by Luffy, as we already knew it would. Yamato wanting to liberate Wano and leave with Luffy is a entirely different thing. Who is gonna leave with Luffy in her stead, and for what purpose?
 
Who is gonna leave with Luffy in her stead, and for what purpose?
In her stead? Well that's very presumptuous I must say xd There is no obligation or rule set by Oda that someone absolutely must leave Wano with Luffy I believe. And if we are talking about purposes, Yamato's purpose looks as one of the most generic ones anyway, half of OP characters wants to go to the sea and have adventures. Tama and Carrot wants the same, idk why (or maybe I do actually lol) but Oda doesn't put much effort in there recently and just goes with ctrl+s ctrl+v motivation. Like what, he couldn't came up with something more unique rather than hop on a ship and have fun without any specific purpose? And that actually bugs me a little regardless the next SH discussion.
 
Can we stop pretending that Yamato staying in Wano would make any difference at all whether or not the world government takes control? The most powerful orginization in the world is not going to be stopped by one yonko commander level "gaurdian". What will stop them from taking Wano is having it be declared a yonko's territory (Luffy's specifically). There's a reason the world government never fucked with fishman island with Whitebeard and Big Mom protecting it, even though the celestial dragons really wanted those fishman and mermaid slaves. The same reason they only plan to take Wano if Kaido loses. The best way Yamato can protect Wano is by taking down the world goverment alongside Luffy.
 
He is literally the next Shogun of Wano
Yeah. But Maybe first he change the world alongside Luffy and then became the shogun or something. I am aware that it is difficult but for me make sense
The best way Yamato can protect Wano is by taking down the world goverment alongside Luffy.
Good point. But Wano really is protected by tama army and the followers of Oden. And the minks are also connected with wano. In my opinion yamato is out of wano than inside.
I don't think she fits. The whole oden roger thing is stupid since she can't read poneglyphs and she isn't oden. She better drop that whole act if she joins the crew since every straw hat has a personality of his own not of some "dead legend". Even if she drops it I'd like her to stay in wano.
Sorry I almost forget to answer that. Yep. But I was thinking about Yamato being the "writter of adventures" like oden did and not phoneglyfs issue. But maybe she will obtain a role that we can´t imagine. Exploration or something.
 





a reminder that Luffy knew Sanji and Franky’s name, yet Luffy still called them as he wanted. Luffy and Yamato met in the middle of the raid, they’ve been together not even a day.

Seriously? Calling name correctly is more important than dealing with the real threat which is Kaido, Big Mom, Orochi and Beast Pirates? Any dumber argument please?:whitepress:
@dizzy2341 @CarrotForNakama
Oh no, I thought Luffy calling Chopper a nickname was different because he didn't hear his name yet! Where do you want to move the goalpost now? Is it different for Yamato because she has a name based in Japanese mythology? Or is it because Luffy would never use a nickname for a FEMALE strawhat:milaugh:
 
@dizzy2341 @CarrotForNakama
Oh no, I thought Luffy calling Chopper a nickname was different because he didn't hear his name yet! Where do you want to move the goalpost now? Is it different for Yamato because she has a name based in Japanese mythology? Or is it because Luffy would never use a nickname for a FEMALE strawhat:milaugh:
The goal post was never the name, but the correction of the name from the character. There is no occurence of Luffy calling a strawhat something else that their name when said strawhat demands correction.

Yamato asked for a correction and Luffy did nothing.

Creating therefore the same direspect for Luffy over Yamato than Luffy over Law or Luffy over Kid. Luffy does not care what Yamato thinks and this, is a fact.
 
Last edited:
The goal post was never the name, but the correction of the name from the character. There is no occurence of Luffy calling a strawhat something else that their name when said strawhat demands correction.

Yamato asked for a correction and Luffy did nothing.

Creating therefore the same direspect for Luffy over Yamato than Luffy over Law or Luffy over Kid. Luffy does not care what Yamato thinks and this, is a fact.
Brook And Straw Hat Pirates Having Dinner! (One Piece - 338) - YouTube
 
Let them join to starwhat pirates to face Blackbeard pirates war.

I am fine with carrot and Yamato joining so the Blackbeard pirates would beat them and win unless luffy will save them.

Theb nah that is stupid idea.

Solution is Jinbe is last member of luffy crew. Jinbe>>>>yamota and carro.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top