Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1009 Spoilers Discussion
- Thread starter Gol D. Roger
- Start date
- Tags #ulti is best girl #yamato4nakama #zoro is unparralled under all of heavan #zoro mid diffs the yonkos #zoro one shots your fave #zoro szn bao huang>king never bet on lanji he sucks orochi>kaido seth wrote that #yamato4nakama tag not jdb zoro > lanji the cook
- Status
@Sentinel ok I get it, he measures the first branch as 103px and translates it to the brunch in the far background. But I think this is flawed. The branch he calcs as 103px is right in front of us viewers, while the ships are far away from us viewers. Just like a building would scale smaller compared to your body, if you are right in front of me while the building is 1km away.
Just compare the stairs that lead into Onigashima with Onigashima itself. You have normal sized people just running up stairs.
Look at this cabin which as broad as the stairs:
Now look at how many people fit into the stairs:
If the skull is 10km in width, the stairs must be at least 1km in width. When in fact they are no more than 10m in width. And that is pretty accurate to calc since the stairs lead right into Onigashima, so we cannot be fooled by perspective.
Here are some branches compared to humans in the near vicinity.
So what would you say is more accurate? Scaling the stairs that lead into Onigashima to Onigashima itself, or ignore perspective by scaling some random branch which is right at the readers face to far away ships to make a point to the overall size of Onigashima?
Just to further strengthen my point. Here is a ship falling off Onigashima which is located right next to the island's body (not far away, which would fuck with the perspective):
If the skull has a width of 10km, that ship falling off Onigashima should have a width of 1km.
Well, at least we can agree that Oda's drawings are pretty inconsistent, lol. I just think 10km is too big. But very well several kilometers.
In the end it doesn't matter for us to say that the feats displayed in this chapter are insane.
Just compare the stairs that lead into Onigashima with Onigashima itself. You have normal sized people just running up stairs.
Look at this cabin which as broad as the stairs:
Now look at how many people fit into the stairs:
If the skull is 10km in width, the stairs must be at least 1km in width. When in fact they are no more than 10m in width. And that is pretty accurate to calc since the stairs lead right into Onigashima, so we cannot be fooled by perspective.
Here are some branches compared to humans in the near vicinity.
So what would you say is more accurate? Scaling the stairs that lead into Onigashima to Onigashima itself, or ignore perspective by scaling some random branch which is right at the readers face to far away ships to make a point to the overall size of Onigashima?
Just to further strengthen my point. Here is a ship falling off Onigashima which is located right next to the island's body (not far away, which would fuck with the perspective):
If the skull has a width of 10km, that ship falling off Onigashima should have a width of 1km.
Well, at least we can agree that Oda's drawings are pretty inconsistent, lol. I just think 10km is too big. But very well several kilometers.
In the end it doesn't matter for us to say that the feats displayed in this chapter are insane.
I consider the Doflamingo fight, when Law complained about Luffy just deciding things on his own.
Doesn't matter if Luffy is 'big brained".
We have 5 people that are not used to fight alongside each other, except in some pairs, but Luffy is acting like they will already know what to do by following his lead.
Now, Oda CAN make they all fight quite nicely together and don't address this issue at all, which seems to be the way he is doing things right now, but I was expecting something a little bit more elaborate from this fight.
If Luffy would SCREAM for them to deal with BM, while jumping at Kaido, it wouldn't make a difference from the Yonkos' persperctive, since they legit believe the SN's aren't more than a nuisance. But it would make a world of difference for us to see ALL 5 of them doing things in order to achieve success.
Aggroing 1 enemy, while the rest of the team focus fire the other, is a valuable thing to do, I would actually rate it as THE MOST significant contribution, above even the "attack delay" from Zoro, but the "intent" is pivotal for me to actually think like that.
The "Roof 5" are not the "Batman Family" that is used to fighting together everyday and dont need to communicate during a fight, because they are all in sync.
We see that the 4 actually talk to each other and make a plan. Luffy is the ONLY one who doens't. Serious. A mere SCREAM would have made a world of difference here.
As things stand, I would love for Kaido to drop Luffy from the dome and he gets trapped fighting BM on a 1v1, while we ACTUALLY have a PROPER team fight on the roof with the remaining 4 against Kaido.
Doesn't matter if Luffy is 'big brained".
We have 5 people that are not used to fight alongside each other, except in some pairs, but Luffy is acting like they will already know what to do by following his lead.
Now, Oda CAN make they all fight quite nicely together and don't address this issue at all, which seems to be the way he is doing things right now, but I was expecting something a little bit more elaborate from this fight.
If Luffy would SCREAM for them to deal with BM, while jumping at Kaido, it wouldn't make a difference from the Yonkos' persperctive, since they legit believe the SN's aren't more than a nuisance. But it would make a world of difference for us to see ALL 5 of them doing things in order to achieve success.
Aggroing 1 enemy, while the rest of the team focus fire the other, is a valuable thing to do, I would actually rate it as THE MOST significant contribution, above even the "attack delay" from Zoro, but the "intent" is pivotal for me to actually think like that.
The "Roof 5" are not the "Batman Family" that is used to fighting together everyday and dont need to communicate during a fight, because they are all in sync.
We see that the 4 actually talk to each other and make a plan. Luffy is the ONLY one who doens't. Serious. A mere SCREAM would have made a world of difference here.
As things stand, I would love for Kaido to drop Luffy from the dome and he gets trapped fighting BM on a 1v1, while we ACTUALLY have a PROPER team fight on the roof with the remaining 4 against Kaido.
But I cut him some slack because
- it paid off
- cool 1v1 Kaido moment
- and Luffy's character is about being selfish/helping others at times.
It actually means a lot to me for the way Eustass was grateful to Zoro, this dramatically shifts my perspective on his character.
Law is always clutch. And Zoro, ya already know
.Overall solid chapter. Love the teamwork. And hope we get many more synchronized teamwork chapters.
You and me both.
I'm sure @Shisui_038 as well.
@Paperchampion23
Real talk.
What King's fight does for Zoro aside from the feat of beating the commander while injured?
Zoro's ap will soon be off the charts for his current level.
King is probably a mediocre swordsman at best.
You expect King to give Zoro some kind of Rapier alike PVP?
Real talk.
What King's fight does for Zoro aside from the feat of beating the commander while injured?
Zoro's ap will soon be off the charts for his current level.
King is probably a mediocre swordsman at best.
You expect King to give Zoro some kind of Rapier alike PVP?
Yeah I totally get you, it was a missed opportunity for Luffy to not be Vocal about it.
But I cut him some slack because
It actually means a lot to me for the way Eustass was grateful to Zoro, this dramatically shifts my perspective on his character.
Law is always clutch. And Zoro, ya already know.
Overall solid chapter. Love the teamwork. And hope we get many more synchronized teamwork chapters.
You and me both.
I'm sure @Shisui_038 as well.
But I cut him some slack because
- it paid off
- cool 1v1 Kaido moment
- and Luffy's character is about being selfish/helping others at times.
It actually means a lot to me for the way Eustass was grateful to Zoro, this dramatically shifts my perspective on his character.
Law is always clutch. And Zoro, ya already know
.Overall solid chapter. Love the teamwork. And hope we get many more synchronized teamwork chapters.
You and me both.
I'm sure @Shisui_038 as well.
Hope we get to see more teamwork like that against Kaido.
- Status