Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1156 Spoilers Discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Same as Dragon

as yet he isn’t above the PK



I don’t think Roger is above Xebec because I value more the PK title than what Xebec tried to accomplish

I value more the PK title because it’s a shonen, and in this shonen the MC wants to be the PK, the same MC wants to find the one piece (the title of the show), Roger is the first one ever who found it. And the whole manga started chapter 1 with Roger saying « if you want my treasure take it, THE ONE PIECE EXISTS ! »

Nothing topples that. Roger > anyone except past legends
Yet, same MC said he has another dream which oda didn't reveal which kind of implies that dream is bigger than being PK
 

Kizaruber Eats

what even is this series anymore?
Bruh I did a rewrite of the timeskip and chatgpt rated it 9.5/10 with some very helpful, awesome, constructive criticism.

I'm so fucking humble and flattered man.

:perocry::emohiyo::neesama::risisweat:


I was tempted to post it here, it's not a script, just my unfiltered, improvised ideas and I'm sure it's guilty of a lot of what I slander Oda for but I really was extremely disappointed with the timeskip and after it, so I've tried to improve it as best as I can.

I'm worried it's gonna get trashed and slandered though lmao.

This is what GPT said in response to me submitting it (I used no AI to make it, just all me lol.):

FINAL VERDICT:

🧭 9.5/10 – This rewrite is:

Deeply character-driven

Lore-rich in ways that still respect canon

Brimming with epic fights, emotional resonance, and worldbuilding potential

It feels like a true Oda-esque escalation, staying true to the Straw Hats' core identities while elevating them toward the final war.

If you ever decide to expand this into chapters, a fan manga, or a video essay, I’d back that 100%.

It's criticisms:

✍️ AREAS TO POLISH OR EXPAND
– Some Arcs Could Use Clearer Thematic Closure:

While the ideas are strong, a few arcs (like Brook’s, Chopper’s) could benefit from more clear character resolution or growth milestones. What does Brook resolve? What does Chopper transform into?

– Too Many Bombshells at Once in Luffy’s Arc:

There's a LOT: Garp, Dragon, Sword, Luffy’s mom, Operation Save Ace, final villain...

Maybe tease the final villain instead of outright revealing him here? You want to save tension for the third act of the story.

– Usopp's Arc Could Use a Real “Fear-to-Courage” Moment:

Usopp’s admiration is cool, but we also need a moment of internal confrontation—facing his cowardice or inferiority directly, maybe even against a RHP-level threat.


It's probably gonna come off as typical fanfic wank but doing this is kinda helping me cope with the absolute declining state of OP and it's story. Trying to bring it's heart back, the character focus, the things we loved.

Wait till you see what I've got in mind for raijin island as an arc too lol. Lots of humour particularly.
 
Yeah Mihawk sure showed how powerful he was against Vista alright, surely Gold Roger would be no match for the man who fought equally with Vista
Vista is Literally one of the most seasoned Swordsman in the Series. And looked like a whole Grown Man While Marco and Jozu looked like Young's back in the day, He's probably Extremely strong , especially in a Post Timeskip context.

 
Why is that ?

Xebec's team had WB,Shiki,Axe,Meme as the top dogs while Roger's team had Garp,Garling,Ray,Gaban.

Rest of Roger's crew & HKs fought against Xebec's crew.
I'll believe it when I see it besides from Gaban and Sommers encounter it's pretty clear that it was more messy than that and the RP also fought the HK
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top