General & Others One Piece voted as the best manga of all time in a Japanese survey consisting of 150 000 people

[AL sama]

i said the last third of the show , and iam pretty sure that many will agree with me
DN is one of my favorites

but he is being hypocrite when preaching others about subjectivity then saying definitely

the latter end of DN went downhill yes but its still above KNY

KNY is massively overrated cause of the anime's mind blowing animation

the story itself is generic and the characters are plain shounen type characters

 

[Manoomar2000]

the latter end of DN went downhill yes but its still above KNY

KNY is massively overrated cause of the anime's mind blowing animation

the story itself is generic and the characters are plain shounen type characters

Maybe iam exaggerating, I really hate KNY , I can’t even enjoy the animation because of the weak plot

 

[AkainuTheGrimReaper]

65. Fairy Tail
91. Berserk

Popularity =/= quality. I don’t understand why people still don’t get this.

Post automatically merged: Mar 23, 2022

No Vagabond.

It does mot make sense in reality unless all art is subjective.



I mean berserk is very famous in Japan. Japan is famous for manga and anime. None world compare to Japan when compare to anime/manga popular. Korea Like second one, I guess.

If berserk is like 5 . And fairy tail is 91. Someone can counter your popular =/= quality argument.

USA is famous for world police , superheroes comics-not popliar as anime in world. Heck American comics are rarely popular nowdays , it is movies make superheroes comic popular .

There are people who genuine dislike elder scroll games, does it mean it is literally impossible to exists in real life even they play it ?

150k is huge sample compare to studies sample.

lots of people view different than you.

Edit: yes you can have opinion on different media as you want

Edited: There are people who disagree elder rings as best game even they play it. It is subjective opinion.

 

[AL sama]

Maybe iam exaggerating, I really hate KNY , I can’t even enjoy the animation because of the weak plot

yeah the plot is just way too generic

 

[DarkWitch]

While I can understand some people not liking Demon Slayer, however the amount of hate for it just because it's popular and people like it is a bit ridiculous.

 

[AL sama]

While I can understand some people not liking Demon Slayer, however the amount of hate for it just because it's popular and people like it is a bit ridiculous.

I enjoy KNY for what it is but that's about it

can you really deny that its massively overrated??

 

[DarkWitch]

I enjoy KNY for what it is but that's about it

can you really deny that its massively overrated??

It's not overrated at least not to me.

And you can you really deny the amount of hate it gets just because of how popular it is?

A lot of people hate on the series just because it's popular and also because the series is above one of their favorites.

This isn't just Demon Slayer, MHA was also in a similar position. Once MHA became really popular, more people started to hate on the series and started to call it overrated.

I don't think Demon Slayer deserves all the hate, and as for the whole thing about it being overrated well that is just based on opinions.

 

[AL sama]

It's not overrated at least not to me.

since its your own "opinion" then I won't argue but yes I do believe its massively overrated

And you can you really deny the amount of hate it gets just because of how popular it is?

A lot of people hate on the series just because it's popular and also because the series is above one of their favorites.

This isn't just Demon Slayer, MHA was also in a similar position. Once MHA became really popular, more people started to hate on the series and started to call it overrated.

I don't think Demon Slayer deserves all the hate, and as for the whole thing about it being overrated well that is just based on opinions.

I understand why people hate its plot and characters I do think that much is justified as the story and characters are pretty generically done

however it gets more hate then it deserves due to it being overrated

 

[Steven]

Demonslayers is great.I dont know the Manga but the Anime shits on One Piss so hard

 

[AL sama]

Demonslayers is great.I dont know the Manga but the Anime shits on One Piss so hard

animation wise its mind blowing but story wise its not

also people will latch onto me for saying this but one piece is pretty average and no way near the top that's out there

 

[mario time]

One piece > hunter x Hunter and death note

 

[Finalbeta]

Votes don't matter, they are subjected to quantity rather than quality of voting most of the time.

An expert eye is aware of the strenghts and weaknesses this series entails.

 

[Paperchampion23]

150k isnt a good sample size.

? It's far greater than most polls even taken in the US for policy opinions lmao

Anyway, this is what Japan considers the greatest manga, doubt it's the same around the world

 

[Kiiro]

Nice list, great anime listed, hard to make a list where our opinions are in, so many people still like Naruto and even though is has been almost 10 years since it ended, it is in number 7, wow.

 

[BlackLegFring]

Rurouni Kenshin at 31...

 

[Tai long]

Am I the only one that feel that demon slayer having a great animation is a good thing and not something that should cause it to be downgraded. Like animation should also be important in the rating of an anime like you don’t see people saying marvel is carried by its vfx.

 

[ShinmenTakezo]

Am I the only one that feel that demon slayer having a great animation is a good thing and not something that should cause it to be downgraded. Like animation should also be important in the rating of an anime like you don’t see people saying marvel is carried by its vfx.

What does the god like animation of the anime have to do with the manga?

 

[Hanzo hattori]

Fist of the north star > One Piece

 

[JerAx]

Rurouni Kenshin at 31...

pedo effect

 

[Tai long]

What does the god like animation of the anime have to do with the manga?

I meant that the list is actually not just manga it has a mix of anime in it to, that is why demon slayer is at the top