General & Others Out of rooftop 5 who's your least favorite?

Who do you like the least?


  • Total voters
    144
And he hasn't eaten up panel time since then at all.
Well yeah
Scabbards Oden and Yamato are reason for wano being trash

Law is reason for Dressrosa being trash

Any character who takes time that Zoro should be getting is responsible for One Piece being trash since Zoro is the reason for One Piece being great
 

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
Law is reason for Dressrosa being trash
😂 this is basically Nidai's argument.

Basically confirmed what I said in my first response (where the hate stems from). The issue is quality writing vs garbage writing. Law and Doffy in Dressrosa is an example of great writing. Yamato, Scabbards, Oden in Wano are an example of abysmal writing.
 
Moments that are widely considered shining spots of wano
-Zoro seppuku knife killing magistrate
-Zoro taming Enma
-Zoro one shotting Apoo
-Zoro blocking Hakai
-Zoro King of Hell
-Zoro Ashura
-Zoro making Kaido and Big Mom shit their pants at the same time

Its not just Zoro fans, majority of One Piece fans love these moments
Most fans hate Oden trash Yamato and Mom's bullshit scabbards etc.

If Zoro is constantly giving popular and well received momemts he should be featured more

@ZenZu @Nidai_Kitetsu
Post automatically merged:

😂 this is basically Nidai's argument.

Basically confirmed what I said in my first response (where the hate stems from). The issue is quality writing vs garbage writing. Law and Doffy in Dressrosa is an example of great writing. Yamato, Scabbards, Oden in Wano are an example of abysmal writing.
I am describing to you his argument
Law in Dressrosa didn't bother him
I didn't love it but I didn't hate it either


Zoro mountain busting and making admiral follow his lead were best moments of Dressrosa tho @ZenZu

Anytime Zoro does something its well received
Post automatically merged:

Law and Doffy in Dressrosa is an example of great writing
Doffy is good
Law is passable

Doffy is also kinda overrated when people say he is any where near as great as pre time skip Zoro
 

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
Moments that are widely considered shining spots of wano
-Zoro seppuku knife killing magistrate
-Zoro taming Enma
-Zoro one shotting Apoo
-Zoro blocking Hakai
-Zoro King of Hell
-Zoro Ashura
-Zoro making Kaido and Big Mom shit their pants at the same time

Its not just Zoro fans, majority of One Piece fans love these moments
Most fans hate Oden trash Yamato and Mom's bullshit scabbards etc.

If Zoro is constantly giving popular and well received momemts he should be featured more

@ZenZu @Nidai_Kitetsu
Oda has no interest in making anyone but Luffy be the center of attention, that's the reality. He'll throw other characters the bone but when it's time to finish things off he will shit on everything for Luffy embellishment. He'll bend over backwards to give Luffy his moment even at the cost of good writing. It was more acceptable pre skip, but now with no focus on the Strawhats it sticks out like a sore thumb.
 
Oda has no interest in making anyone but Luffy be the center of attention, that's the reality. He'll throw other characters the bone but when it's time to finish things off he will shit on everything for Luffy embellishment. He'll bend over backwards to give Luffy his moment even at the cost of good writing. It was more acceptable pre skip, but now with no focus on the Strawhats it sticks out like a sore thumb.
For some reason Luffy never bothered me pre time skip as a Zoro fan
It always felt like Zoro did more than enough with Zoro

Post time skip I wish Zoro would just betray luffy or some shit
Post automatically merged:

Still tho you have to be special kind of inbred to pick Zoro in this poll over Kidd and Killer @ZenZu
 
And it looks like I hit the nail right on the head lmfao when I said most of the hate stems from stealing shine. Which is why the few people who hate on Law don't bother me.
Duh, its the story of strawhat crew. Oda should have created a Law spin off for you guys who cheers his stupid tsundere shit. I can guarantee you the story will get better now that Kidd and Law (and Big Mom) are out.
 
Duh, its the story of strawhat crew. Oda should have created a Law spin off for you guys who cheers his stupid tsundere shit. I can guarantee you the story will get better now that Kidd and Law (and Big Mom) are out.
Issue isn't laws presence
Its Zoros absence
Post automatically merged:

Other straw hats are trash anyways
 
Issue isn't laws presence
Its Zoros absence
Post automatically merged:

Other straw hats are trash anyways
Lol you are not wrong. I am not saying Law is less interesting than Chopper or Franky. But the storytelling aspect suffered because the other strawhats haven't got enough panel time. Imagine if its possible for Oda to create the Usopp-Luffy fight at Ennis Lobby with Law also traveling with the crew. Without that fight, we dont get Zoro's epic speech about captain's respect. Those small interactions between the crewmates always lead to greater things pre-ts.

Btw I think Zoro's plot will get more focus in the future as we have got nothing about his parents in Wano. Its also suspicious how Mihawk got no mentions either.
 

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
Duh, its the story of strawhat crew. Oda should have created a Law spin off for you guys who cheers his stupid tsundere shit. I can guarantee you the story will get better now that Kidd and Law (and Big Mom) are out.
Yea your anger is misplaced 😂, the story will get better now hopefully because Oda won't waste time on meaningless/boring characters.


People are mad at Oda for not fleshing out Kidd, and you are hating on Law for being fleshed out dkm.
 
Yea your anger is misplaced 😂, the story will get better now hopefully because Oda won't waste time on meaningless/boring characters.


People are mad at Oda for not fleshing out Kidd, and you are hating on Law for being fleshed out dkm.
I am tryna think who is left.
Are all the shit characters out of the way?

We have players like Admirals, Shanks, Dragon, Sabo, Mihawk, Gorosei, Imu etc left and if Oda is going to expand upon these characters then there is only so bad the story can be.

Among the top tiers the least interesting and the most boring ones were Kaido and Big Mom and they are out of the way.

We have Blackbeard Pirates, Cross Guild, Marines, World Government, Will of D, Joy Boy etc left to explore.

So the potential is pretty high.
But its Oda so who knows.
We might get some Wano level garbage in Elbaf tho
 

Dickie D. Dick

SII - Sakazuki Incinerate Imu
Yea your anger is misplaced 😂, the story will get better now hopefully because Oda won't waste time on meaningless/boring characters.


People are mad at Oda for not fleshing out Kidd, and you are hating on Law for being fleshed out dkm.
> meaningless/boring characters.

Like Midd and Low?
Post automatically merged:

Duh, its the story of strawhat crew. Oda should have created a Law spin off for you guys who cheers his stupid tsundere shit. I can guarantee you the story will get better now that Kidd and Law (and Big Mom) are out.
Low is tsun-tsun not tsundere; are you even a proper weeb?
 
People are mad at Oda for not fleshing out Kidd
Not true, People dislike Kidd because his achievement to ego ratio is small. I can bet if Kidd soloed Big Mom, his popularity would have shot up.

I think Oda should make Law an official strawhat or the first division captain of the Grandfleet or something. Now his relevance to the plot is not organic. Did you honestly like his "we are enemy" bs or him jumping off the waterfall?

Low is tsun-tsun not tsundere; are you even a proper weeb?
tsun tsun sounds terrible. Guess I am not a proper weeb.
 

Dickie D. Dick

SII - Sakazuki Incinerate Imu
Not true, People dislike Kidd because his achievement to ego ratio is small. I can bet if Kidd soloed Big Mom, his popularity would have shot up.

I think Oda should make Law an official strawhat or the first division captain of the Grandfleet or something. Now his relevance to the plot is not organic. Did you honestly like his "we are enemy" bs or him jumping off the waterfall?


tsun tsun sounds terrible. Guess I am not a proper weeb.
Fake weeb smh
 

TheAncientCenturion

I will never forgive Oda
‎‎‎
Used to be real hyped for Kidd going into Wano. Pre timeskip he seemed like a ruthless Luffy with a cooler devil fruit but lamer crew (give and take, can't have it all). The fact he had his own Supernova alliance was pretty neat, even if it was filled with the rejects of that generation. He was basically matching Luffy every step of his way until post-Dressrosa.

But in Wano he barely got any panel time, his character wasn't explored after Queen almost murked him in Udon, we know nearly as much about Kidd now as we did in our first sojourn into Sabaody. That really bothers me because he's now a wasted concept.

What really annoys me is how Oda leans heavily into statements instead of actions to bump Kidd up. In combat he does nothing visually interesting or technically cool but is grouped alongside Law and his monster attacks against Linlin, even given equal credit for taking her down when we all know it was far from 50/50 there.

Then he gets a totally undeserved bounty of 3B, matching Luffy's to keep this ridiculous idea that they're rivals despite Oda not having shown that Kidd is beyond Luffy two power ups ago.

So his character is irritating and uninteresting because Oda's consistently decided to verbalize accomplishments for him instead of doing the footwork like he did with Law. Killer's worse but in all honesty, I don't care about Killer, no one else does either. He was always a cheap copy of Zoro so Killer being a nothing character doesn't impact me as much. Kidd not living up to his hype but being given greater hype is a certified buggy moment for him.
I did just insult Law in this thread but was reminded of his great speech when he fucked up Vergo and a mountain at the same time.

What does Kid have? Like, I really liked this pre-skip



But since then? Nada.
Man Kidd's design pre timeskip was pretty cool. The more slender build and less awkwardly shaped head goes a long way.
 

Dickie D. Dick

SII - Sakazuki Incinerate Imu
Used to be real hyped for Kidd going into Wano. Pre timeskip he seemed like a ruthless Luffy with a cooler devil fruit but lamer crew (give and take, can't have it all). The fact he had his own Supernova alliance was pretty neat, even if it was filled with the rejects of that generation. He was basically matching Luffy every step of his way until post-Dressrosa.

But in Wano he barely got any panel time, his character wasn't explored after Queen almost murked him in Udon, we know nearly as much about Kidd now as we did in our first sojourn into Sabaody. That really bothers me because he's now a wasted concept.

What really annoys me is how Oda leans heavily into statements instead of actions to bump Kidd up. In combat he does nothing visually interesting or technically cool but is grouped alongside Law and his monster attacks against Linlin, even given equal credit for taking her down when we all know it was far from 50/50 there.

Then he gets a totally undeserved bounty of 3B, matching Luffy's to keep this ridiculous idea that they're rivals despite Oda not having shown that Kidd is beyond Luffy two power ups ago.

So his character is irritating and uninteresting because Oda's consistently decided to verbalize accomplishments for him instead of doing the footwork like he did with Law. Killer's worse but in all honesty, I don't care about Killer, no one else does either. He was always a cheap copy of Zoro so Killer being a nothing character doesn't impact me as much. Kidd not living up to his hype but being given greater hype is a certified buggy moment for him.

Man Kidd's design pre timeskip was pretty cool. The more slender build and less awkwardly shaped head goes a long way.
Look on the bright side! It's fun to mock Midd fans :wellwell:
 
I don't hate him, I really like him but yeah.... Kidd.

Law put in most of the work against Big Mom and Luffy, Law and Zoro put in most of the work @ the rooftop.

Also he's not too bright. Killer is the brains of that crew. At least Luffy is charmingly dense. Kidd's just dense.

I do like him though and hope Oda gives him a moment to truly show he's a badass on his own.
 
Are the Kidd fans actually serious when saying Kidd is Luffy's equal or anywhere in power? I think the arc made it quite clear that Luffy is leagues ahead.
Filler just because i need to choose one, but i did like everybody on the rooftop.
 

Dickie D. Dick

SII - Sakazuki Incinerate Imu
Are the Kidd fans actually serious when saying Kidd is Luffy's equal or anywhere in power? I think the arc made it quite clear that Luffy is leagues ahead.
Filler just because i need to choose one, but i did like everybody on the rooftop.
They believe Midd is Magneto while in reality he just magnet human not master of magnetism
 
Top