Controversial Pirate King title doesn't means shit

[HerreraIsBack]

Whitebeard was much more of a king. Much more realized as both man and pirate than Roger could ever be.

Roger was a failure as a pirate. Too soon to do the quest of his dream. Got sick and wouldn't live long. Plus couldn't raise his own kid and watch it grow. Not only that but his own name, famous and past put a curse on Ace that made him end up killed. So yea he did a bunch of things but his main goal in life wasn't concluded.

Whitebeard by the other side is way different. He wanted a family he got one. And he made sure to protect it. And he did it. No one mess around with Whitebeard or anyone related to him.

So people try to say Roger was greater for being Pirate King when Whitebeard never wanted any of that shit. Is like saying Rodrigo Hernandez is a greater athlete than Michael Jordan just because he won Ballon d'Or. Which is ridiculous.

 

[NikaInParis]

Stop spamming threads ffs

 

[Godhawk]

Loser of bygone era.

 

[Loki D. Terror]

PK in case of roger was not a power based title but a exploration based title.

Imo oda changed roger's characterization. He was initially meant to be more brutal like rocks and dominating.

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

Nah, Lolda ruined Whitebeard's character in Oden and Rocks' flashback, everything about him was a lie

 

[nik87]

Pirate king was always a title for Robin+Nami.
A scholar to decipher RPGs and a navigator to sail where RPGs point.
But sibce this is a story about pirates, only the one who goes to Raftel is hailed as the greatest.

 

[HerreraIsBack]

Loser of bygone era.

Oden made his choice.

 

[HerreraIsBack]

Nah, Lolda ruined Whitebeard's character in Oden and Rocks' flashback, everything about him was a lie

Low bait