Speculations Pound is still dead

#1


So in this chapter, it appears as if Pound might actually be alive and that he some how escaped WCI. This just doesn't sit well with me for several reasons.



Pound had a really good death. It was one of the highlights of WCI. Making pound alive would ruin what he did in WCI. While Oda did revive Pell, I don't think most of the fans liked that. I think Oda learned from his mistakes as he's killed many characters post-skip, whereas literally only Ace and Whitebeard died pre-skip.

Furthermore, it just seems implausible for Pound to be alive. Oven had a clean shot at his head. Oven was also on Cacao island for several hours, meaning that even if Pound survived the initial blow, Oven had ample time to kill him. Cacao island was literally surrounded by beast pirates and ultimately, big mom herself even came to the island. How did Pound escape all of that?

I feel like making Pound alive would ruin a genuinely good moment in WCI as well as needing a large amount of plot armor to be believable. What I think is more likely is this.

After pound died, Oven put his body on a ship and cast him off to sea. Cacao island is made of chocolate after all, and what's the point of creating islands made of food if you bury corpses inside of them. Pound's corpse just happened to find its way to dressrosa where it will then by taken by the tontattas. The tontattas being good hearted people, will naturally want to hold a funeral if they find a dead corpse.

Capone, Chiffon, Lola, and Pez will attend the funeral for whatever reason. None of them will find out the true identity of Pound, however Pound will ultimately get a happy ending as he will be laid to rest with his daughters and grandson by his side.

I think this would be so much better and would carry so much more emotional weight than if they just retconned Pound's death
 

Garp the Fist

Bwahahahaha
#6
Anybody who actually thought that Pound had been killed off before meeting any of his family needs their heads checked.

Is it good writing that Oda continually puts characters in seemingly fatal positions only to survive? No, of course not. Is it something he's done time and time and time again, since Alabasta? Yes. And I'm not talking about Pell here, I'm talking about Igaram.

Pound was never shown to have died and we never even saw Oven go through with hitting him. One Piece has been going on a long time people, if it's the present day and there's no corpse, expect the character to come back.
 
#7
Anybody who actually thought that Pound had been killed off before meeting any of his family needs their heads checked.

Is it good writing that Oda continually puts characters in seemingly fatal positions only to survive? No, of course not. Is it something he's done time and time and time again, since Alabasta? Yes. And I'm not talking about Pell here, I'm talking about Igaram.

Pound was never shown to have died and we never even saw Oven go through with hitting him. One Piece has been going on a long time people, if it's the present day and there's no corpse, expect the character to come back.
Either way its bad writing. He shouldve never put Pound in that situation.
 

RayanOO

Lazy is the way
#9
Anybody who actually thought that Pound had been killed off before meeting any of his family needs their heads checked.

Is it good writing that Oda continually puts characters in seemingly fatal positions only to survive? No, of course not. Is it something he's done time and time and time again, since Alabasta? Yes. And I'm not talking about Pell here, I'm talking about Igaram.

Pound was never shown to have died and we never even saw Oven go through with hitting him. One Piece has been going on a long time people, if it's the present day and there's no corpse, expect the character to come back.
I know but since Ingaram or Pell I am 10 years older so I am less forgiving. You are right Oda didn't change so I shouldn't really blame him but I have changed.
 

Garp the Fist

Bwahahahaha
#10
Either way its bad writing. He shouldve never put Pound in that situation.
It's a mix of both bad writing and poor reading comprehension. I'd say anyone who actually thought Pound was dead is just as much as fault as a reader as Oda is a writer for doing another fakeout.

And tbh, even saying it's a fakeout isn't really right. Oda at no point had anyone say that Pound was dead. He never showed a body. He just showed Oven's attack about to land on him. Why were people expecting that to be a fatal attack when throughout OP we've seen people getting slashed and surviving?
 

Uncle Van

Monké Don't Do Taxes
#11
Anybody who actually thought that Pound had been killed off before meeting any of his family needs their heads checked.

Is it good writing that Oda continually puts characters in seemingly fatal positions only to survive? No, of course not. Is it something he's done time and time and time again, since Alabasta? Yes. And I'm not talking about Pell here, I'm talking about Igaram.

Pound was never shown to have died and we never even saw Oven go through with hitting him. One Piece has been going on a long time people, if it's the present day and there's no corpse, expect the character to come back.
Main reason people still make theories about Monet, Vergo and Pedro returning. Can have characters get cut into itty bitty pieces and they'll still survive cause Oda said so.
 
#12
It's a mix of both bad writing and poor reading comprehension. I'd say anyone who actually thought Pound was dead is just as much as fault as a reader as Oda is a writer for doing another fakeout.

And tbh, even saying it's a fakeout isn't really right. Oda at no point had anyone say that Pound was dead. He never showed a body. He just showed Oven's attack about to land on him. Why were people expecting that to be a fatal attack when throughout OP we've seen people getting slashed and surviving?
You cant really blame the reader. Oda set it up as Pound getting decapitated. Theres literally no reasonable explanation to show how a fodder like Pound could survive a flaming sword attack to the neck. The only thing left to think is....Pound is dead. Which is bad writing in itself. Killing him before meeting his daughter and grandchild....is pretty stupid.

If Pound died, it wouldve been bad writing. But the fact that hes alive kills the realism within this show. Like if your gonna fake kill someone off panel. Then atleast show some plausible way that they might survive. Its horrendous.
 

Rosella.Fiamingo

Peerless In History
#15
Anybody who actually thought that Pound had been killed off before meeting any of his family needs their heads checked.

Is it good writing that Oda continually puts characters in seemingly fatal positions only to survive? No, of course not. Is it something he's done time and time and time again, since Alabasta? Yes. And I'm not talking about Pell here, I'm talking about Igaram.

Pound was never shown to have died and we never even saw Oven go through with hitting him. One Piece has been going on a long time people, if it's the present day and there's no corpse, expect the character to come back.
Does that mean Monet is coming back?:neesama:
 
#16
Furthermore, it just seems implausible for Pound to be alive. Oven had a clean shot at his head. Oven was also on Cacao island for several hours, meaning that even if Pound survived the initial blow, Oven had ample time to kill him. Cacao island was literally surrounded by beast pirates and ultimately, big mom herself even came to the island. How did Pound escape all of that?
The only way how I can see him beeing survive it:
Oven don´t give him the finisher blow and Pound was almost dead, probably had a fatal wound.
Then Oven led him lying because knowing he would die soon and leave the place.
Then Pudding come into the game, she was on the island and could save pound via the help of someone else, then going to whole cake island and save his life, Pound recover and one week later he travel away.

That is the only way how Pound could survive, only with a help of someone else...
 
Top