[FNZ] Salem of Lies Return of the Throne (Unofficial)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, that is possible. But this scenario would be better than lynching him now because:

He flips town and takes another BD out. The assassin kills someone tonight (=3 BD dead)
He flips scum = (yay, we got the assassin)

A townie dies anyways (=1 BD dead, Zara isn't scum)

No deaths because assassin abstained, we lynch Zara and he flips town (=2 BD dead)
Zara is assassin, no one dies since he was roleblocked, we lynch him tomorrow (= 0 BD dead)

Either way, second option looks better to me. The only issue is if RB failed.


Chill sis, I understand your frustration. I was really frustrated in the beginning of this game too for being sussed for dumb reasons.
This seems to be a common theme this game.


Nope, per wiki (and I confirmed with Drago last game)


I think it also says in sign up thread.
I believe a zara lynch is a bad idea right now to be honest. I don't think its a good push and other things can be done to confirm him. The risk of hitting 2 BD's in a lynch is a killer thing.
 
understood


@Queen I have to say your behavior is weird. First this "out-of-character", which I pointed out here:


And now this quick unvote, when you have a reputation in this game of looking things up in the wiki, so you should know you are not in danger if you are the 5th vote. Why the panic?
:pepecorn:
Post automatically merged:


why are you unvoting? He will only shoot the last person that votes for him.
earlier convo points to initially having problems with unvoting but I more or less get your point.
:endthis:
 

Melontonin

Blood Manipulation
Yes, that is possible. But this scenario would be better than lynching him now because:

He flips town and takes another BD out. The assassin kills someone tonight (=3 BD dead)
He flips scum = (yay, we got the assassin)

A townie dies anyways (=1 BD dead, Zara isn't scum)

No deaths because assassin abstained, we lynch Zara and he flips town (=2 BD dead)
Zara is assassin, no one dies since he was roleblocked, we lynch him tomorrow (= 0 BD dead)

Either way, second option looks better to me. The only issue is if RB failed.


Chill sis, I understand your frustration. I was really frustrated in the beginning of this game too for being sussed for dumb reasons.
This seems to be a common theme this game.


Nope, per wiki (and I confirmed with Drago last game)


I think it also says in sign up thread.
Damn I really like this logical reasoning, maybe it's cause I have taken algorithm classes lmao.

Ok I see where you are coming from.
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
In what way is it weird? If I was a host I would chose to do it that way to. Please explain how you would operate whispers in the most logical way possible for this game?
Point is you are first time player....


Point is you haven't played ToL earlier and this game is damn complex...



But somehow you know how host would operate scum abilties....

There is only two way out of this...


1) either you already know how abilties work as you are scum. Because only scum would know how their abilties would work exactly


2)or you are really good at deducing things...
 
N

NeutralWatcher

@Melontonin Would you claim?

I played Throne of Lies before but even then I don't know how Little Bird ability work. How do you know?
Post automatically merged:

For this game
 

Melontonin

Blood Manipulation
Point is you are first time player....


Point is you haven't played ToL earlier and this game is damn complex...



But somehow you know how host would operate scum abilties....

There is only two way out of this...


1) either you already know how abilties work as you are scum. Because only scum would know how their abilties would work exactly


2)or you are really good at deducing things...
Well there is the wiki available to us. Can you tell me which role knows the mechanics of whispers, on which Dragomir would base this game on?
Post automatically merged:

How did u know :cheers:
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Well there is the wiki available to us. Can you tell me which role knows the mechanics of whispers, on which Dragomir would base this game on?
Post automatically merged:


How did u know :cheers:
Can you tell me from where on wiki you read how scum abilties worke
 

Kiwipom

Ghost Princess
I believe a zara lynch is a bad idea right now to be honest. I don't think its a good push and other things can be done to confirm him. The risk of hitting 2 BD's in a lynch is a killer thing.
Yeah, I really am not totally down for this lynch either.

My reasons to read her as scum:
> there is the possible slip --> calling BD two times
> hunter is a convenient claim
> bad reads
> "accidentally" angleshooting

Reservations:
> her defense seems genuine and organic
> if she really is hunter, it would fuck us over real bad


My only question is who to lynch next. I don't have anyone that seems more suspicious than her other than AL. Maybe I should just stay with my D1 vote and lynch him again.
Also, he did claim physician and I don't want to be that doofus who led the lynch on physician if he flips town. But the claim is sketchy as well as his previous actions so I'm a bit lost.
 
She knows how Little Bird ability works. Do you even know how that ability works and you have played this game before. What's your thought about this?
Post automatically merged:

I mean for this game only.
I didnt know till she mentioned this
only played this with cult
and we didnt have that ability
Post automatically merged:

Yeah, I really am not totally down for this lynch either.

My reasons to read her as scum:
> there is the possible slip --> calling BD two times
> hunter is a convenient claim
> bad reads
> "accidentally" angleshooting

Reservations:
> her defense seems genuine and organic
> if she really is hunter, it would fuck us over real bad


My only question is who to lynch next. I don't have anyone that seems more suspicious than her other than AL. Maybe I should just stay with my D1 vote and lynch him again.
Also, he did claim physician and I don't want to be that doofus who led the lynch on physician if he flips town. But the claim is sketchy as well as his previous actions so I'm a bit lost.
zara is a he.
 
My mind keep thinking of the name Zara as a "she"

:risitasad:

I've been going back and editing them out every time I proofread before sending but I forgot to do that this post
Post automatically merged:


also, wdym by claim?
you not the only one, my inbox a mess

tried naming myself after one of my favourite historical battles and it backfired

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Zara
 
My mind keep thinking of the name Zara as a "she"

:risitasad:

I've been going back and editing them out every time I proofread before sending but I forgot to do that this post
Post automatically merged:


also, wdym by claim?
neutral asked melon
Post automatically merged:

My mind keep thinking of the name Zara as a "she"

:risitasad:

I've been going back and editing them out every time I proofread before sending but I forgot to do that this post
Post automatically merged:


also, wdym by claim?
did you just misgender him kiwi
apologize
:myman:
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
How many of you who played ToL earlier or have more than few games experience are capable of deducing how scum abilties work exactly????


Because I can't.... Am I the only one who feels that if melon legitimately deduced how host operates scum abilties during her first game itself then I feel bad for having low iq and poor logical deduction skills as even after playing 12-13 games I still can't:josad:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top