Powers & Abilities Roger isn’t a swordsman

[zorovsanji]

More than Luffy? Zoro gets nowhere the wank Luffy gets.
Hell, Zoro past was done in SBS.

Luffy is just the mc but seeing all of the top tiers are swordsmen then Zoro being as strong as Luffy tells me that Zoro is his fav.

 

[JoNdule]

No. They have a rivalry. They're portrayed to be nigh equals in strength because of their past fights, nowhere was it ever stated that they fought for the title of WSS.

That Mihawk ~ Shanks is clear. The question is whether Mihawk holding the title puts him clean above Shanks.

They had rivalry
They don't anymore
With Shanks growing to be Yonko level while Mihawk became just an oordinary top tier

Anyway,
Back to Roger talks please

 

[HA001]

They had rivalry
They don't anymore
With Shanks growing to be Yonko level while Mihawk became just an oordinary top tier

Anyway,
Back to Roger talks please

 

[JoNdule]

Then you underestimate how much oda loves shanks and luffy

They never learn

They think Oda loves Zoro more than Shanks and Luffy
Even Oden is getting more wanked than zoro ever would be

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Loves shanks so much he brings him up inferior to mihawk in mihawks bounty

What do you mean?
Mihakw bounty is lower..
[automerge]1690034433[/automerge]

Luffy is just the mc but seeing all of the top tiers are swordsmen then Zoro being as strong as Luffy tells me that Zoro is his fav.

Zoro parents were relegated to an SBS.
Compare that to Luffy.
Or even Sanjino.
[automerge]1690034498[/automerge]

Luffy is just the mc but seeing all of the top tiers are swordsmen then Zoro being as strong as Luffy tells me that Zoro is his fav.

Yeah, the top tier Akainu the swordsman, or the top tier Kaido the swordsman, or the top tier Dragon the swordsman.

 

[Rootbeer]

You make a good point here.. But in the end it just means that they have renown Blades..

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

You make a good point here.. But in the end it just means that they have renown Blades..

Only one is a real panel on the Manga my friend in christ.

 

[HA001]

You make a good point here.. But in the end it just means that they have renown Blades..

No it doesn't. Meito isn't beloved blade.

 

[zorovsanji]

What do you mean?
Mihakw bounty is lower..
[automerge]1690034433[/automerge]

Zoro parents were relegated to an SBS.
Compare that to Luffy.
Or even Sanjino.
[automerge]1690034498[/automerge]

Yeah, the top tier Akainu the swordsman, or the top tier Kaido the swordsman, or the top tier Dragon the swordsman.

Ryuma, joyboy, xebec and Roger are all swordsmen. And yeah even a one armed swordsman is a yonko.

 

[Albino 👑]

Loves shanks so much he brings him up inferior to mihawk in mihawks bounty

Yeah mihawk the wss has greater sword skill than shanks. Nobody is arguing against that but yourself

The point is it wouldn’t be 100% surprising if oda made shanks an exception as to what it means to be a swordsman. Whether you think it’s good or bad writing doesn’t matter but acting like it’s impossible is delusional whether or not it becomes the case

Also thinking oda cares about mihawk anywhere close to how much he loves shanks is straight up crazy

 

[HA001]

Yeah mihawk the wss has greater sword skill than shanks. Nobody is arguing against that but yourself

The point is it would be 100% surprising if oda made shanks an exception as to what it means to be a swordsman. Whether you think it’s good or bad writing doesn’t matter but acting like it’s impossible is delusional whether or not it becomes the case

Also thinking oda cares about mihawk anywhere close to how much he loves shanks is straight up crazy

Of course it does. That statement only means anything if Shanks is a swordsman.

 

[JoNdule]

You make a good point here.. But in the end it just means that they have renown Blades..

Imagine posting "beloved swords" as argument that Roger is a swordsman

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Ryuma, joyboy, xebec and Roger are all swordsmen. And yeah even a one armed swordsman is a yonko.

Joyboy is a swordsman now?
And they are all dead.
How can a dead body be a top tier.
I will stop answering.

 

[Reborn]

Imagine posting "beloved swords" as argument that Roger is a swordsman

Imagine posting nothing but your opinions against manga info/panels to say "Roger isn't a swordsman"

 

[zorovsanji]

Joyboy is a swordsman now?
And they are all dead.
How can a dead body be a top tier.
I will stop answering.

Original joyboy was a swordsman. and lol at not being a top tier for being dead. Ill stop too. Lol

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Imagine posting nothing but your opinions against manga info/panels to say "Roger isn't a swordsman"

You know what.
I just tought the ultimate shitpost.
Roger was the WSS of his time.
And he got his head cut by what? A sword.
So that marine became the new WSS, and since it's a nobody, his title cannot be stolen since nobody knows him.
Which means Mihawk title is fraudolent.

 

[Rootbeer]

No it doesn't. Meito isn't beloved blade.

Why not, you're just assuming that beloved Blades doesn't mean Meitos..

 

[Shimotsuki Fenaker]

these jobbers's only argument is Oda likes Shanks more in comparison with Mihawk , but u jobbers forget that Oda likes Zoro more than That mofo that's why Zoro is / was getting feats that only that mofo dreamed of getting them recently like paralyzing a Logia which Zoro did it back then in PH when he was a YC , Overpowered a Yonko in 1 v 1 clash and scarred him with 30 broken bones ; Mf like shanks never did , Shanks's only hype is his CoC which funnily enough Zoro got and in a Hakified Mode at that KoH Mode with adv CoC and overflowing Haki .

 

[HA001]

Why not, you're just assuming that beloved Blades doesn't mean Meitos..

No assumption about it dumbass. It literally doesn't

 

[Rootbeer]

No assumption about it dumbass. It literally doesn't

It's just another way to call renowned Blades..