[FNZ] Salem of Lies Round 5 : Town of Salem

[Dragomir]

TAC is correct as well. Mafia could have hit the witch. If nobody comes out and says that they were attacked then it's likely that mafia did hit the Witch. I am 99% certain that TAC is town.

 

[Dragomir]

My only question is, what is Neutral's role? I must have missed that reveal.

I have nothing on those four, apart from Homelander's very sketch claim last day phase.

Sheriff. If Homelander is the janitor then it explains his sheriff claim.

 

[Dragomir]

That being said, I don't think we should lynch Cel but instead Homelander.

 

[Kiwipom]

TAC is correct as well. Mafia could have hit the witch. If nobody comes out and says that they were attacked then it's likely that mafia did hit the Witch. I am 99% certain that TAC is town.

But why would mafia choose to hit the witch? From the conclusion we made, it’s either:

All red
Celestia
Moe
Homelander

Why would mafia choose to hit them instead of more powerful roles that were revealed like doctor, lookout, psychic etc.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Ok, the scum are...Celestia, Moe, Red, and Homelander.

If we want to act on this then;

We lynch Homelander for being the most suspicious person.
@Rej RB's Red.
Jailer jails Celestia.

That'll leave Moe alone. Jailer can either kill Celestia or see if there's any cleanings. Try to narrow it down further? Keep Moe around in case we have a vigilante to shoot them, since Moe likely isn't GF or Witch with immunity.

 

[Dragomir]

But why would mafia choose to hit the witch? From the conclusion we made, it’s either:

All red
Celestia
Moe
Homelander

Why would mafia choose to hit them instead of more powerful roles that were revealed like doctor, lookout, psychic etc.

Idk, maybe mafia is not that bright.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

But why would mafia choose to hit the witch? From the conclusion we made, it’s either:

All red
Celestia
Moe
Homelander

Why would mafia choose to hit them instead of more powerful roles that were revealed like doctor, lookout, psychic etc.

They don't know who the witch is. There's the RNG possibility for another TP to be on Doc, they could feel it's all around unsafe or want to cast suspicion on the doctor. We have no confirmed LO's and the many TI claims itself just... Isn't smart to hit? I guess.

If I was mafia and my teammates claimed TI, I'd want to keep the town in the dark on who actually is reliable.

 

[Dragomir]

If we want to act on this then;

We lynch Homelander for being the most suspicious person.
@Rej RB's Red.
Jailer jails Celestia.

That'll leave Moe alone. Jailer can either kill Celestia or see if there's any cleanings. Try to narrow it down further? Keep Moe around in case we have a vigilante to shoot them, since Moe likely isn't GF or Witch with immunity.

Holy shit, that was my entire plan bro. About Moe, our 2nd escort can RB him to stop all kills from occurring.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Sheriff. If Homelander is the janitor then it explains his sheriff claim.

I'm not sure I like NW's claim either. That would put us at 4 TI. But, if you're confident, let's lynch Homelander, have @Rej Roleblock All Red, Jailer takes Celestia, and Moe is left for tomorrow.

It's important we all take our roles seriously. If the Jailer jails the wrong person, the RB is pointless.

 

[Reborn]

Wait.....

Potential sus include - ces, moe, red, Homelander, tac

With slight chance of flower being one

We are lynching Celestia

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Holy shit, that was my entire plan bro. About Moe, our 2nd escort can RB him to stop all kills from occurring.

I think our second escort is dead. No one claimed a double RB this day phase. If we still have them, they can be on Moe. But I'm not counting on it.

 

[Dragomir]

They don't know who the witch is. There's the RNG possibility for another TP to be on Doc, they could feel it's all around unsafe or want to cast suspicion on the doctor. We have no confirmed LO's and the many TI claims itself just... Isn't smart to hit? I guess.

If I was mafia and my teammates claimed TI, I'd want to keep the town in the dark on who actually is reliable.

Nah, you gotta at least kill one. Probably the confirmed psychic or invest. At least one has got to go down. You got LO, Doc, Psychic, and Invest. How do you not kill one of them? Either they tried and the target was protected or they attacked the witch.

 

[Dragomir]

Wait.....

Potential sus include - ces, moe, red, Homelander, tac

With slight chance of flower being one

We are lynching Celestia

Why Celestia? Homelander is much better.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Nah, you gotta at least kill one. Probably the confirmed psychic or invest. At least one has got to go down. You got LO, Doc, Psychic, and Invest. How do you not kill one of them? Either they tried and the target was protected or they attacked the witch.

I think the witch is most logical. Queen was here to say whether or not someone was attacked (thus clearing them as town).

 

[Reborn]

Why Celestia? Homelander is much better.

Nah..... I need to see whether tac is really townie or not

 

[Dragomir]

Nah..... I need to see whether tac is really townie or not

How does lynching Cel achieve that?

 

[Dragomir]

Tell us your plan Reborn.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

In the meantime, let's get some initiative here.

Vote Lynch @Homelander @AL sama

 

[Kiwipom]

so the only explanations for no kill is:
a) doctor saved the target
b) the target was a witch
c) TAC is mafia and he is in jail

I don’t know if I buy the witch argument. To me, that feels off because again, why would mafia choose to target the witch instead of the powerful townie roles?

 

[Reborn]

How does lynching Cel achieve that?

We lynch ces

You and Jailor can be protected.

Jailor jails moe or red

Vig shoots Homelander

Rej role block red/moe

Poison invest flower