[FNZ] Salem of Lies Round 5 : Town of Salem

Status
Not open for further replies.
Who confirmed me as scum?


I don’t understand the logic here. Why can’t we have a mayor and a Bodyguard? Why are these mutually exclusive roles? And then you are trying to say that there is an arsonist too. It almost feels like you are trying to manipulate the town into suspicioning ourselves further.

Rej did roleblock me. And you know what’s funny? All Red targeted me with her last note. Then Rej roleblocked me (maybe to make sure that mafia will be able to kill off the doctor). Then you accused me because I was in your results. Suddenly everyone is trying to frame me.

moreover, yesterday you said I was in your town list so you think it’s most likely I’m town. Then today I’m in your list again and you think I’m scum. Flip flopping a bit, did you perhaps have a chat with your scum buddies to decide to target me?


why shouldn’t you? Because from what I understand, your reasons are:
A) Results show that there is 1/3 chances that I am scum. But there is also 1/2 chances that I’m not
B) All Red’s sketchy last note, which is just her framing me
C) You dont believe that Rej roleblocked me. Why would you put in more trust in Rej when I mentioned earlier that he slipped Day 1 and he roleblocked the bodyguard twice in a row now

Something else that is interesting, now that Homelander flipped town:
What am I to believe when Rej, you and TAC were in my results this NP? TAC is confirmed Vig since Homelander indeed got shot as was the plan. So this just makes the scums either you or Rej or you AND Rej. And you already said you got blocked, but why should Rej block you instead of his designated target? There is no sense in any of this. Unless you both are scum and failed hard at bussing each other.
 

Kiwipom

Ghost Princess
What am I to believe when Rej, you and TAC were in my results this NP? TAC is confirmed Vig since Homelander indeed got shot as was the plan. So this just makes the scums either you or Rej or you AND Rej. And you already said you got blocked, but why should Rej block you instead of his designated target? There is no sense in any of this. Unless you both are scum and failed hard at bussing each other.
Rej would block me because I am bodyguard. I am a town protective role along with the doctor. To ensure that their kills go through, it would make sense for mafia to block the bodyguard from protecting.

answer my questions flower.

Why can't we have a mayor and a bodyguard?
Why do you think there is an arsonist?
Why couldn't Rej have roleblocked me today? In fact, if we really are scum buddies as you said, why would he have roleblocked me yesterday?
What did Rej mean by this?
:cheers: seems SK was on towns side that night! well played!
I have been targetted by a Consort or Escort!

most importantly, why did Poison's results say you were bodyguard?
If anything, her results are more telling that you are not who you say you are. Moreover, it is not hard for mafia to impersonate psychic because they know who is scum and who isn't.

~~~~
On a different note......when I was in jail night 1, I was told by jailor-san that he jailed another person who also claimed bodyguard.....I'm not sure if this was a mind game he was playing or if this was legit....
 
D

Dragomir

Rej would block me because I am bodyguard. I am a town protective role along with the doctor. To ensure that their kills go through, it would make sense for mafia to block the bodyguard from protecting.

answer my questions flower.

Why can't we have a mayor and a bodyguard?
Why do you think there is an arsonist?
Why couldn't Rej have roleblocked me today? In fact, if we really are scum buddies as you said, why would he have roleblocked me yesterday?
What did Rej mean by this?
most importantly, why did Poison's results say you were bodyguard?
If anything, her results are more telling that you are not who you say you are. Moreover, it is not hard for mafia to impersonate psychic because they know who is scum and who isn't.

~~~~
On a different note......when I was in jail night 1, I was told by jailor-san that he jailed another person who also claimed bodyguard.....I'm not sure if this was a mind game he was playing or if this was legit....
:pepecafe:

You're arguing for no reason lol. You don't need to pointlessly argue with someone who you think is scum. And yes, Reborn was playing mind games on you.
 
Rej would block me because I am bodyguard. I am a town protective role along with the doctor. To ensure that their kills go through, it would make sense for mafia to block the bodyguard from protecting.

answer my questions flower.

Why can't we have a mayor and a bodyguard?
Why do you think there is an arsonist?
Why couldn't Rej have roleblocked me today? In fact, if we really are scum buddies as you said, why would he have roleblocked me yesterday?
What did Rej mean by this?
most importantly, why did Poison's results say you were bodyguard?
If anything, her results are more telling that you are not who you say you are. Moreover, it is not hard for mafia to impersonate psychic because they know who is scum and who isn't.

~~~~
On a different note......when I was in jail night 1, I was told by jailor-san that he jailed another person who also claimed bodyguard.....I'm not sure if this was a mind game he was playing or if this was legit....
So if you are BG and were supposed to be on Drago, why is Drago still alive when apparently Rej and me are scum and Rej is a blocker in your book and I knew you would be on Drago and this would have been the perfect chance for scum to get rid of Drago?

But instead Queen got killed and you are still around. Probably because you didn't want to get outed as not BG.

That is the biggest evidence you are scum buddies. You are busted.
 

Kiwipom

Ghost Princess
So if you are BG and were supposed to be on Drago, why is Drago still alive when apparently Rej and me are scum and Rej is a blocker in your book and I knew you would be on Drago and this would have been the perfect chance for scum to get rid of Drago?

But instead Queen got killed and you are still around. Probably because you didn't want to get outed as not BG.

That is the biggest evidence you are scum buddies. You are busted.
oh yeah, just keep avoiding my questions :seriously:
 

Kiwipom

Ghost Princess
:pepecafe:

You're arguing for no reason lol. You don't need to pointlessly argue with someone who you think is scum. And yes, Reborn was playing mind games on you.
cuz I'm on quarantine and I've got nothing better to do.

Why should I answer questions from scum?
Look babe, I answered your points already. But you can't do the same. If you're town you shouldn't be afraid of answering but clearly...you're avoiding my questions.

So moving on, what are the night plans?
jail rej
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
ok first, I was roleblocked again last night.
Let's assume rej is sus....

You were given task to protect dragomir. So if rej is sus then wouldn't it will make more sense to role block you to carry out NK on dragomir???

But kill happen on queen... which is possible even without role blocking you.

So what you said here doesn't make sense
 

Kiwipom

Ghost Princess
Let's assume rej is sus....

You were given task to protect dragomir. So if rej is sus then wouldn't it will make more sense to role block you to carry out NK on dragomir???

But kill happen on queen... which is possible even without role blocking you.

So what you said here doesn't make sense
Here is the thing, for the plan to work, we needed to make sure that:
a) there is trust that everyone does exactly what they should be doing
b) there is no special instructions that were given through whispers etc

Mafia wants to confirm a kill. The Doctor is protecting the jailor, but who could potentially protect the doctor? The bodyguard. And the fact that we gave away all of our roles yesterday gives them the ability to tread carefully and why should they believe that clause a and b would be met? Especially now that the town is all allied together and making plans to survive the night, the most important thing for them is to get confirmed kills. So even if the plan for me is to protect Drago, there is no way to confirm for mafia that this is how it will pan out.

tldr: mafia can't confirm who I am going to protect. They can't afford a failed killing attempt. The only way to get a confirm kill, 100% certainty is to block me.
 

Rej

Year of the black beard!
I would have towncleared Kiwi this DP without her claiming.
Flower is paranoid scum. Nothing more to add.

Vote lynch Flower
Vote end phase
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top