Yeah arrow not being used makes me think there may have been no convert. It’s possible that it supports what Dyna said, but that would also go against Dyna saying the arrow isn’t the conversion. Dyna speculated that the arrow did something else.
Also considering my own actions last night I have to wonder if I may have played a part in the arrow not being used. But I can’t be sure on that.
This is the one thing throwing me off with Light.
Oh god, what did
@DynaMight say the arrow did? I recall he said the name of the alledged culting ability he got,wait I found it here:
No arrow. I was wrong
Ability is Stand Creator, 3 shot
So you're right, i totally missed that. Because i remember Dyna saying that Arrow being used meant people gaining stands and getting culted which i kinda agreed with it,
@Lindltaylor brought up the theory first if i recall.
I already explained how it's practically impossible for me to be scum in these posts as well as how me faking being silenced makes no sense.
Oh god, yes this is the one murky part about this, i already talked about it.
Of course I voted Cal when we had a mechanical check on him, plus his wonky behaviour D1. I still pushed Zara though, but Cal was the better option since he had incriminating results on him.
This only works if you don't take hindsight and new info into account, this entire premise falls flat because of course you would wanna go for the ''better'' option in Cal. Hence the problem here, its basically you saying but im town and here is why i went for the safe option back then but thats not how it works, every sensible townie went for the confirmed results of
@ConquistadoR since it would be suicide from him to lie about his results over Dynas case on Zara, especially since at the time the going theory was that Zara was culted that night if i recall,oonce the game progresses and flips/results happen we can go back to earlier interractions with a newer perspective.
So this point is pretty moot in making you look good.
Don't try to pin this on me. The lynch on Rhea made sense. Ratchet had 2 entire days to say something and he never did. That was by no means a townie play. And after Dest's claim and people with flavour knowledge backing it up, Rhea looked worse.
The thing is while Ratchets play was very anti town and most people talked about it, its always best to take your time with stuff like this especially after so many people already died, and so you didn't even try to wait for Rhea to explain herself more or ask her to claim her abilities and see if they matched or not, you rushed the decision and voted her then dipped. That's my problem mate, you didn't take the time to carefully analyse things it feels and decided to ignore the bd question that was still hanging about who possibly fucked with
@ConquistadoR 's results and jumped on the Rhea Lynch.
@Destroya wasn't even denying being scum, he was questioning why Ratchet didn't come with that info and thus was accusing him of being SK or scum himself.
Im gonna see what Dest flips then decide what to do next, but for now i do believe you might be scum yes, despite the weird silencing shit.
@Dr_Professor83 I might've missed it but where did Light hint or claim a cultable character?