[FNZ] Role Madness [Season 2] Round 13 - Harry Potter

[Nick]

Fine, I see your point. Bad townie game should be punished as well.

By the way, in Genshin game when we were scum we received several safe fake claims (for example Amber I used). Since this game is also hosted by Flower, I would expect scum to have fake claims as well, especially since there is no restriction against flavour claiming.

Yea fake claims are assumed. But honestly roles can’t be as much. But still claiming gives better intel as well. Especially with roles

 

[ConquistadoR]

These are not good reasons.

This is atleast better than voting Sera because he's a Shanks fan

 

[Nick]

I can tel you what’s gonna happen though. Don gonna come claim and we are gonna switch to sera and he will be lynched.

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Let me know when you’re caught up then.

But first give me your strongest gut feeling.

Rej and YTW are two that I wanna look at more closely; the former has been more active than some of the games I’ve played with him, and the latter is back after a lengthy absence. Don’t have a lean on either one, just naming some folks who pique my interest.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Or much answer is that whenever he is attacked/rolecrushed/lynched he loses a horcrux. That's how i would do


Snape at best is Miller but no one claimed miller at this point


Don seems like easy picking since he gives newbie vibes, is he a newbie?

On to page 23

No idea about Don, it is third game I play on WG so do not know all the people. Still newbie or not, we should push people we find suss.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

For those who have played with Sera is refusing to claim in this situation and getting himself killed something he’d do as scum?

 

[Nick]

For those who have played with Sera is refusing to claim in this situation and getting himself killed something he’d do as scum?

Someone said he is always scum so far lol

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

@Don DaSlayer
If you don't claim, Town has decided to either lynch you or off you at Night.

 

[Don DaSlayer]

I can tel you what’s gonna happen though. Don gonna come claim and we are gonna switch to sera and he will be lynched.

I thought of doing that but i aint gonna do it.

 

[ConquistadoR]

I'm surprised there are no miller claims yet.

 

[Jew D. Boy]

For those who have played with Sera is refusing to claim in this situation and getting himself killed something he’d do as scum?

Like I said earlier, Sera is always a target because he plays on the edge. I’ve been scum with him before, and he laid low just like he did when he was town, so while it’s hard to read him, I’m inclined to say that more activity is a point in his favor.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Someone said he is always scum so far lol

That is not true.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

This is atleast better than voting Sera because he's a Shanks fan

His best reason for voting is by far T-Pein’s summary. Which is troubling lol. Especially if he’s Town.

 

[Don DaSlayer]

Till now has anyone claimed?

 

[Grammaton]

No half baked CFDs then?

Preferably not

Just lynch one of don or sera and we’ll work from that

 

[Lord Melkor]

Yea fake claims are assumed. But honestly roles can’t be as much. But still claiming gives better intel as well. Especially with roles

But people as a rule should not claim unless in extreme situations such as to avoid an almost certain lynch. If the game is well designed, it should have ways to punish mass claiming by town.

In Genshin game we received only names of fake claims, abilities etc. we had to come up with ourselves.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Like I said earlier, Sera is always a target because he plays on the edge. I’ve been scum with him before, and he laid low just like he did when he was town, so while it’s hard to read him, I’m inclined to say that more activity is a point in his favor.

He’s got a real good chance at being the lynch and he won’t claim lol.

Is that something he’d do with teammates counting on him?

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Someone said he is always scum so far lol

Lol yeah Don.

 

[Grammaton]

But people as a rule should not claim unless in extreme situations such as to avoid an almost certain lynch. If the game is well designed, it should have ways to punish mass claiming by town.

In Genshin game we received only names of fake claims, abilities etc. we had to come up with ourselves.

You need to balance that against the need for town to make informed lynching decisions tho

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Till now has anyone claimed?

They have not. But most of us aren’t staring down a rope.