Shoumou vs Chou Ga Ryu

[Lee Ba Shou]

I’m sorry but your delusions aren’t convincing anyone with a smidge of common sense.

So your “common sense” overrides the exact statements the manga has provided us?

Oh hell, who am I kidding, the entire Garyuu hate squad has ignored all evidence that contradicts their weird ass opinions lol

 

[FutureWarrior123]

Gokei would destroy Shoumou

Aside from this being wrong regardless, where did I mention anything about Shoumou? I was referring to Rinko.

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

Aside from this being wrong regardless, where did I mention anything about Shoumou?

Oh I misread your post

Gokei does beat Rinko but it's closer than Gokei vs Shoumou

 

[FutureWarrior123]

Oh I misread your post

Gokei does beat Rinko but it's closer than Gokei vs Shoumou

Even if I disagree I’m not super against this. Gokei > CGR imo.

 

[Bepo]

How is this even a discussion? Shoumou is relative to someone like Gaku'Ei, a capable general that could serve as the backbone to a much larger army but that's it.

In the midst of powerhouses like Ouki/Shin they'd get one-shotted. Chou garyuu by comparison is much more impressive.

 

[Cichy]

Literally Shukai Shin is relative to Renpa

You think Renpa or Ouki would fail to hit Gaku Haku Kou with their glaive, because quote "the weapon is to heavy for them"?

 

[Lee Ba Shou]

You think Renpa or Ouki would fail to hit Gaku Haku Kou with their glaive, because quote "the weapon is to heavy for them"?

No. Doesn’t change the fact that Shin was relative to them. Shin killed Houken and fought Gyou’Un somewhat equally, at Shukai Plains he was already pushing Renpa and Ouki to high diff.

 

[God Buggy]

How did this thread reach four pages

 

[Cichy]

No. Doesn’t change the fact that Shin was relative to them. Shin killed Houken and fight Gyou’Un somewhat equally, at Shukai Plains he was already pushing Renpa and Ouki to high diff.

Shin's performance against Houken wasn't his regular, because he had the revenge weight. He was fighting the man who killed his two mentors and nearly killed the love of his life Kyoukai. Even then this fight ended in him loosing his life. It's a similar situation as with Mougou vs Renpa where one was far below other, but could still fight back due to their common past.

Even when we take all that into account Shin still didn't perform against Houken as well as Ouki.

 

[FutureWarrior123]

He likes to talk about overriding manga statements when he's literally ignoring chapter 3 of the fucking story lol.

Spoiler

 

[Bullet]

Instead of arguing let's just all agree that they both beat Earl Shi.

 

[Lee Ba Shou]

Shin's performance against Houken wasn't his regular, because he had the revenge weight

So did Ouki, he had his revenge weight for Kyou. Which Duke Hyou did not have when he fought Houken.

Ouki’s performance against Houken was a tier above what he was otherwise capable of. Comparing the Ouki who fought Houken to a theoretical Ouki who would face Gakuhaku Kou or Gyou’Un is wrong because Ouki wouldn’t have revenge weight against them.

He likes to talk about overriding manga statements when he's literally ignoring chapter 3 of the fucking story lol.

Spoiler

In what way am I ignoring this page? What does this have to do with Shoumou or Renpa or Rinko? Or Chougaryuu?

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

This thread is worthy of being in top 3 Kingdom Great Debates along with Bananji vs Earl Shi and Rinko vs Chougaryuu.