General & Others So Kidd DID defeat a Sweet Commander

Mugiwara56

Mugiwara56

‎
#63
#63
Jinjoo said:
He beat up a sweet comander after invading big mom territory and made him/her hand over poneglyph. Its either snack or smoothie. Smoothie does have an injury in her eye. Might be kid's gift
Click to expand...
Kid didn't defeat a Big Mom commander he only hurt him, he says so himself he just wanted to pick up a few chosen ones and now we know it was a poneglyph copy.

It was Urouge who beat Snack If Kid would have beaten a commander, Oda would have said it very clearly like Urouge I think. And then whether Kid beat a commander or not, he doesn't care he succeeded in his objective in any case.
 
K!NG HARA$H!MA

K!NG HARA$H!MA

Hustlerversity Graduate
‎
#64
#64
Don't like how the narrative is going,

Apparently Urouge defeated a commander that was already wounded by Kid,

Just wanna discredit Urouge's W I see :seriously:
 
CoC: Color of Clowns

CoC: Color of Clowns

Remove the Rich
‎
#67
#67
Desolate Smaug said:
Oda is just a bad writer. If kid actually defeated a sweet commander someone would mention it before and his bounty wouldn't be a lowly 470m. This is just a lame retcon on Oda's part to make Kid look good tbh.

The supernova narrative was explored in WCI. Why would any of big mom kids/commanders be walking around with a rubbing of a lode/red/road poneglyph even!?
Click to expand...
Did you see what Green Bull did to King and Queen? The Marines don't have respect for most Commanders, especially the lower ones.
[automerge]1659705154[/automerge]
Roo said:
It’s pathetic how people are trying to make a distinction between being defeated and getting hurt and giving up your treasure

its the same shit
Click to expand...
Hey, he didn't win the fight: he just beat me up and stole my lunch money. Kid's weak, I wouldn't have lost if Mama was there /s
 
Jinjoo

Jinjoo

‎
#68
#68
If I beat you up and take your lunch money, you lost simple as that. Wtf is kid didn't defeat a sweet commander bullshit ? He not only injured a sweet commander but also TOOK A PONEGLYPH. THATS DEFEAT OF HIGHEST ORDER.
[automerge]1659706584[/automerge]
Mugiwara56 said:
Kid didn't defeat a Big Mom commander he only hurt him, he says so himself he just wanted to pick up a few chosen ones and now we know it was a poneglyph copy.

It was Urouge who beat Snack If Kid would have beaten a commander, Oda would have said it very clearly like Urouge I think. And then whether Kid beat a commander or not, he doesn't care he succeeded in his objective in any case.
Click to expand...
Why do you think it was snack ? For all we know it might have been smoothie or cracker. He roughed them up and got a poneglyph and escaped, thats Victory.
 
J

JoNdule

‎
#69
#69
Jinjoo said:
If I beat you up and take your lunch money, you lost simple as that. Wtf is kid didn't defeat a sweet commander bullshit ? He not only injured a sweet commander but also TOOK A PONEGLYPH. THATS DEFEAT OF HIGHEST ORDER.
[automerge]1659706584[/automerge]

Why do you think it was snack ? For all we know it might have been smoothie or cracker. He roughed them up and got a poneglyph and escaped, thats Victory.
Click to expand...
Kid himself never said he beat any SC
Stop being like zoro fans
 
H

Herrera95

#71
#71
Forced can be K.O it can be blackmail...

Oda is desperately trying to hype Kid for whatever reason.

Good enough he stopped doing that with Law.
 
Fn Lucci

Fn Lucci

‎
#79
#79
I guess snack is one of those dudes who brags about what he has in the bar, then gets mugged outside of his home.

Which means that Kid didn't win a fight but managed to pull off a secret upset. Doesn't contradict anything else (Brulee or Caribou) so I don't see the problem.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top