Chapter Discussion So who is the guy at Elbaf waiting for them?

#21
Probably the guy who was sitting with Crocus.
But the most important question is whether or not he is the man with the burn scar.
If anything, I doubt this specifically cause its way too convenient for Luffy. That person has been elusive roaming the seas and sinking ships that near them. I feel like their first introduction should be on the sea with their jet black ship.

I would argue that if this person is Scopper though, he might know who the Burned Scar Man is.
 
#24
Dont think it is, but it would be funny if Oda just randomly decided to canonize movie villains now beyond Shiki.

If that is a redesigned Shiki, it would be funny if he knew who the Burned Scar Man is, being Douglas Bullet, considering his burn scar lol.
 
#29
If anything, I doubt this specifically cause its way too convenient for Luffy. That person has been elusive roaming the seas and sinking ships that near them. I feel like their first introduction should be on the sea with their jet black ship.

I would argue that if this person is Scopper though, he might know who the Burned Scar Man is.
I think that the Burned Scar Man, that silhouetted Rocks Pirate during Kuma’s flashback, and the silhouetted guy in chapter 1121 are the same person
 
#31
If anything, I doubt this specifically cause its way too convenient for Luffy. That person has been elusive roaming the seas and sinking ships that near them. I feel like their first introduction should be on the sea with their jet black ship.

I would argue that if this person is Scopper though, he might know who the Burned Scar Man is.
Tbh convenient is pretty par for the course for Luffys journey.
 
#32
Honestly the amount of hypothetical characters these people could be is ridiculous lorewise between any of the Sillhouettes seen with Crocus, God Valley FB, God Knights, this Burned Scar Man, and the one in 1121 lol:

- Scopper is an obvious one for obvious reasons
- Sure, Yorki could be the person with Crocus
- Shiki is canon and shares a similar design
- Rocks himself has a hidden design, as does Silver Axe
- Stussy being a clone opens the door of other Rocks pirates sharing the same fate....except Whitebeard since theres Weevil.
- Any missing Level 6 impel down pirate
- A random WG employee we dont know about (Remember Shiryu speculates the Burned Scar Man might work for the WG)
- Someone from the Underworld


And the list goes on. Scary
[automerge]1724431577[/automerge]
Tbh convenient is pretty par for the course for Luffys journey.
He's already been handed one, then stole and fought for the last 2. imo the last one will just something everyone fights over.
 
#33
Honestly the amount of hypothetical characters these people could be is ridiculous lorewise between any of the Sillhouettes seen with Crocus, God Valley FB, God Knights, this Burned Scar Man, and the one in 1121 lol:

- Scopper is an obvious one for obvious reasons
- Sure, Yorki could be the peroson with Crocus
- Shiki is canon and shares a similar design
- Rocks himself has a hidden design, as does Silver Axe
- Stussy being a clone opens the door of other Rocks pirates sharing the same fate....except Whitebeard since theres Weevil.
- Any missing Level 6 impel down pirate
- A random WG employee we dont know about (Remember Shiryu speculates the Burned Scar Man might work for the WG)
- Someone from the Underworld


And the list goes on. Scary
[automerge]1724431577[/automerge]

He's already been handed one, then stole and fought for the last 2. imo the last one will just something everyone fights over.
I still think it’ll be a one v one only between Luffy and Blackbeard and Luffy will get the location here and Blackbeard will get it from shanks.
 
#34
Honestly the amount of hypothetical characters these people could be is ridiculous lorewise between any of the Sillhouettes seen with Crocus, God Valley FB, God Knights, this Burned Scar Man, and the one in 1121 lol:

- Scopper is an obvious one for obvious reasons
- Sure, Yorki could be the peroson with Crocus
- Shiki is canon and shares a similar design
- Rocks himself has a hidden design, as does Silver Axe
- Stussy being a clone opens the door of other Rocks pirates sharing the same fate....except Whitebeard since theres Weevil.
- Any missing Level 6 impel down pirate
- A random WG employee we dont know about (Remember Shiryu speculates the Burned Scar Man might work for the WG)
- Someone from the Underworld


And the list goes on. Scary
The fact that this dude says "Come then" drastically shortens the possible options imo.

That line is very obviously aimed at the shp. So this person either personally knows them, or has some connection to them.
 
#36
The fact that this dude says "Come then" drastically shortens the possible options imo.

That line is very obviously aimed at the shp. So this person either personally knows them, or has some connection to them.
Well yeah thats why I think thats Scopper. Im just talking about the sheer number of sillhouettes in general, the person in 1121 on the roster people going after One Piece, the Sillhouette in the Rocks Flashback (either Rocks or Silver Axe), etc.

Scopper knowing Luffy could be very easily explained because if it is the person who visited Crocus, they could have met Rayleigh at some point and Oda just didnt show it (outside of a Flashback).
 
#37
Could be the one sitting with Crocus at the cover story. So what are your thoughts on it?



If it is the one meeting Crocus, I say it is Yorki most likely or with a 10 % chance Scopper Gaban.
Probably no one’s that will have a real big impact on the story. It is most likely another fake hype cliffhanger :kayneshrug:

I obviously hope that I’m wrong but…
 
Top