Speculations Strawhats vs Blackbeard pirates matchups

[Lunaria]

If some of the level 6 prisoners are among the strongest crew members :

- Luffy vs BB (Captains)
- Zoro vs Shiryu (Swordsmen)
- Sanji vs Pizarro (Royalties)
- Jinbe vs Vasco Shot (Humanoid Creatures)
- Usopp vs Van Augur (Snipers)
- Franky vs Burgess (Wrestlers)
- Robin vs Doc Q (Macabre Tendencies)
- Brook vs Lafitte (Gentlemen)
- Chopper vs Sanjuan Wolf (Giants)
- Nami vs Devon (Women)

If the 5 level 6 prisoners are the strongest crew members :

- Luffy vs Blackbeard (Captains)
- Zoro vs Shiryu (Swordsmen)
- Sanji vs Pizarro (Royalties)
- Jinbe vs Vasco Shot (Humanoids)
- Usopp vs Van Augur (Snipers)
- Franky vs Sanjuan Wolf (Ship Builder vs Battleship)
- Robin vs Devon (Strongest Women)
- Brook vs Doc Q (Death Theme)
- Chopper vs Burgess (Brawlers)
- Nami vs Lafitte (Navigators)

 

[Levi_Ackerman]

Shiryu vs Zoro is going to be one heck of a boring matchup if Shiryu's awakening lets him be intangible.

The Match will involve Shiryu being invisible most of the fight where Zoro can't cut him in that state.
Zoro will take a lot of injuries and then learns how to cut nothing and will one shot him/few shot him later.

 

[Sadistic Senpai]

Honestly, Usopp and Van Auger

that is a match I'm excited about, specially if Van Auger won against Yassop in a "red hair vs BBP"

 

[Finalbeta]

Honestly, Usopp and Van Auger

that is a match I'm excited about, specially if Van Auger won against Yassop in a "red hair vs BBP"

I think Auger will surely have the better rifle during this fight haha

Usopp will have to outmatch his skill consistently

Unless PIS will come into action and I would be so disappointed in such eventuality

 

[Lionheart]

I think it will be based in the crew-roles.
So far, the only crew-roles confirmed in BB crew are those of the first members (before Impel Down arc). And probably we can say that Shiryu is the combatent/swordsman. So:

Luffy vs Blackbeard (Captains)
Zoro vs Shiryu (Swordsmen)
Nami vs Laffite (Navigators)
Ussop vs Van Auger (Snipers)
Chopper vs Doc Q (Doctors)
Jinbe vs Burgess (Helmsmen)

I will have to wait until Oda reveals the roles of the other members, but I would like to see these fights:
Sanji vs Avalo Pizarro
Robin vs Devon
Franky vs San Juan Wolf
Brook vs Vasco

 

[Lunaria]

I think it will be based in the crew-roles.
So far, the only crew-roles confirmed in BB crew are those of the first members (before Impel Down arc). And probably we can say that Shiryu is the combatent/swordsman. So:

Luffy vs Blackbeard (Captains)
Zoro vs Shiryu (Swordsmen)
Nami vs Laffite (Navigators)
Ussop vs Van Auger (Snipers)
Chopper vs Doc Q (Doctors)
Jinbe vs Burgess (Helmsmen)

I will have to wait until Oda reveals the roles of the other members, but I would like to see these fights:
Sanji vs Avalo Pizarro
Robin vs Devon
Franky vs San Juan Wolf
Brook vs Vasco

I've always wondered which role each one of them fills in the crew but I'm not sure they all have a specific one. It's probably true for the original crew members, but it would be a hell of a coincidence if Shiryu, Pizarro, Wolf, Shot and Devon all had a different and useful role, considering BB's recruitment method for these ones was entirely based on a single criteria : their strength. That being said, Devon gives me musician vibes because of her post timeskip design. Pizarro might be a cook because of his name and the fact he was eating a chicken leg the last time we saw him (it's a weak reasoning, to be honest).

 

[pedxi]

Sanji vs Lafitte
Nami vs Devon
Franky vs Pizarro
Jinbe vs Vasco
Luffy vs Burgess ( Blueno)
Chopper vs wolf
Brook vs DocQ

 

[Lionheart]

I've always wondered which role each one of them fills in the crew but I'm not sure they all have a specific one. It's probably true for the original crew members, but it would be a hell of a coincidence if Shiryu, Pizarro, Wolf, Shot and Devon all had a different and useful role, considering BB's recruitment method for these ones was entirely based on a single criteria : their strength. That being said, Devon gives me musician vibes because of her post timeskip design. Pizarro might be a cook because of his name and the fact he was eating a chicken leg the last time we saw him (it's a weak reasoning, to be honest).

Yeah, I understand your point. But I don't know. For me it's easy to see some of them with a role. Vasco being a musician or a cook, Wolf being a ship builder. And as you said, Pizarro being a cook it's possible too. But I agree that for this last one we have weak tips.
About Devon, she is the only one I can't predict a role in the crew. She doesn't fit being an archeologyst so far. But considering we may have more straw hats until these fights, a New straw hat could fight Devon and Robin could fight the tenth member of BB crew.

 

[Lunaria]

Just a personal fantasy of mine : Black Maria works for Blackbeard and she’s the tenth Titanic Captain. She’s the mother of Yamato and they will fight each other in Laugh Tale.

Of course, this has like 0.01% chance of happening.

 

[Buusatan94]

Sanji against either Laffite due to them being the smart men of their respective crew or Avalo Pizarro who was a corrupt king who got overthrown because of him being such a tyrant in contrast to Sanji's modest attitude despite being a prince and who's from North Blue too.

I would also prefer to see Robin fight Catarina Devon than Nami since she's stronger than Nami.

 

[Shiroyru]

Luffy vs BB. Captain vs captain and Luffy will avenge Shanks
Zoro vs Shiryu. Swordsman vs swordsman, and Zoro will avenge Mihawk
Usopp vs Van Auger. Sniper vs sniper and Usopp will avenge Yasopp

Idk about the rest

 

[Tobra]

sanji vs avalo
jinbei vs vasco shot
franky vs burgess
nami vs devon
brook vs laffite
robin sanjuan wolf

Post automatically merged: Jul 25, 2020

franky vs burgess american vs mexican

 

[LadyVados]

This is one possible way I could see the match-ups turning out

Luffy vs BB

Zoro vs Aokiji

Sanji vs Shilliew

Yamato vs 10th titanic captain

Jinbei vs Burgess

Robin vs Catarina Devon

Carrot vs Pizzaro

Franky vs Sanjuan Wolf

Brook vs Vasco Shot

Nami vs Laffitte

Chopper vs Doc Q

Usopp vs Van Augur

Post automatically merged: Aug 21, 2020

I’ve edited and improved it slightly.

Post automatically merged: Sep 1, 2020

New one-

Luffy vs BB

Zoro Vs Burgess

Sanji vs Shilliew

Jinbei vs 10th captain

Robin vs Devon

Nami vs Laffite

Carrot vs Pizzaro

Franky vs Sanjuan wolf

Brook vs Vasco Shot

Chopper vs Doc Q

Usopp vs van augur

Yamato vs Weevil

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Luffy vs Teach
Zoro vs Shiryu
Sanji vs Avalo Pizarro
Usopp vs Van Augur
Jinbei vs Sanjuan Wolf
Nami vs Devon (this might switched with Robin)
Robin vs Lafitte (this might switched with Nami)
Franky vs Burgess
Brook vs Vasco Shot
Chopper vs Doc Q
The tenth Strawhat vs the tenth Titanic captain

 

[King7]

Luffy vs Teach
Zoro vs Shiryuu
Sanji vs Burgess ( ? )

Jinbe vs Vasco Shot
Franky vs Avalo Pizarro
Robin vs Tenth Titanic Captain ( who is a Woman , i guess )

Nami vs Devon ( Nami often fights Women )
Usopp vs Van Augur ( Sniper vs Sniper )
Chopper vs San Juan Wolf ( Giant vs Giant )

Doc Q left , but i don't know who suits him , whatever lol .

 

[Konstantis]

Usopp fight ofc

 

[KiriNigiri]

The ones I'm most confident on.

1. Luffy vs Teach
2. Zoro vs Shiryu
3. Nami vs Devon
4. Usopp vs Augur
5. Chopper vs Doc Q
6. Franky vs Sanjuan Wolf

 

[Luffy bin Dragon]

Laffitte vs Sanji

 

[Sir Yasheen]

I think BB is going to have some new crewmates next we meet

1. Luffy vs Blackbeard

2. Sanji vs Burgess

3. Zoro vs Shiryu

4. Usopp vs Van Augur

5. Unknown vs Pizarro

6. Brook vs Lafitte

7. Robin vs Catarina Devon

8. Franky vs SanJuan Wolf

9. Nami vs Vasco Shot

10. Chopper vs Doc Q and Stronger

Possible based on new characters:

Carrot vs Tenth Captain

Jinbe vs Edward Weevil

Yamato vs Moriah

These are mostly what I think and has a possibility and I’ll explain if anyone has any questions about them.

 

[Luffy bin Dragon]

I think BB is going to have some new crewmates next we meet

1. Luffy vs Blackbeard

2. Sanji vs Burgess

3. Zoro vs Shiryu

4. Usopp vs Van Augur

5. Unknown vs Pizarro

6. Brook vs Lafitte

7. Robin vs Catarina Devon

8. Franky vs SanJuan Wolf

9. Nami vs Vasco Shot

10. Chopper vs Doc Q and Stronger

Possible based on new characters:

Carrot vs Tenth Captain

Jinbe vs Edward Weevil

Yamato vs Moriah

These are mostly what I think and has a possibility and I’ll explain if anyone has any questions about them.

Burgess is too weak for Sanji he should fight Jinbe or Franky
Pizarro will fight brook (Soul king vs Corrupt King) and Sanji vs Laffitte (Aerial Battle, Demon sherriff vs Devil’s Leg)