Controversial The Next Great Female Pirate... will be?

[BoaHancocksHusband]

With the fall of Big Mom, I think there are two candidates who will eventually replace her, well technically 3... but.... I don't see 1 of the three even being relevant with how much Oda has neglected her. So we'll stick to the two relevant ones.

1st. Yamato, at the age of 28. Still a solid decade away from entering the "prime ages" of 40s. With plenty of potential to grow with her insane natural body and haki potential. I think he's the clear opponent for Blackbeard's female pirate, Catarina Devon. With it being the clash of mythological DFs. Yamato will also serve as the "Oden" equivalent, joining up with Luffy right before the clash against Blackbeard (hence we're seeing her whole "oden" journey happen in the cover story).

2nd. Boa Hancock, at the age of 31. Still a decade away from entering the "prime ages" of 40s. Her DF has insane potential without even being awakened. She's a confirmed CoC user of an island that's hyped for it's haki, yet Oda has chosen to keep her haki hidden for now. Thus we don't know her full capabilities as a fighter at all. Ironically, Yamato the newer character has displayed more of her prowess than Boa Hancock has.


So the inevitable clash to be the top female pirate on the seas is between these two. Who will be the strongest at their peak? In my opinion, it'll be Boa Hancock.​

​

My Waifu obviously

Boa Hancock>>>>>>>>

 

[park_min young]

Yamato has top-tier potential
Boa is just extremely hax but lacks a lot of raw power to contend with actual threats (top-tiers).

Yamato will most likely beat a holy knight and maybe even more come the final war.

 

[Heart pirate]

Yamato the safest bet already having ACoC+ low top tier combat abilities. She got a direct line to great pirate.

Hancock arguably could have the highest potential. She has CoC, plus advance CoA so her haki potential solid. With the potential to go higher. while her DF top tier with crazy hax. Has the potential but needs a haki or Cqc upgrade.

smoothie fodder at the moment

 

[Welkin]

It can't really be Yamato as she'll never lead her own Pirate group

Boa has the best shot

 

[Xione]

It can't really be Yamato as she'll never lead her own Pirate group

Boa has the best shot

You don't think there's any chance she breaks away from the SHP after Luffy becomes PK. Like Whitey Bay did with Newgate.

 

[MonsterKaido]

Yamato has top-tier potential
Boa is just extremely hax but lacks a lot of raw power to contend with actual threats (top-tiers).

Yamato will most likely beat a holy knight and maybe even more come the final war.

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

i'm not sure Yamato counts as a pirate, if she doesn't join the SHPs she might never be one.

 

[Welkin]

You don't think there's any chance she breaks away from the SHP after Luffy becomes PK. Like Whitey Bay did with Newgate.

Idk she seems like too big of a fanboy for that to be possible

 

[vikas]

Oda's an ass man now, get with the times you coot

He can't draw good asses, they always seem flat without any volume..

 

[Yoho]

One day it'll be Nami

But for now Boa holds that title

Yamato technically isn't a pirate at least not until she officially joins strawhats or some other crew

Bonney isn't strong or experienced enough to hold that title

Smoothie is weaker than both Yamato and Boa

Boa has the strength, the experience, and the crew

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

He can't draw good asses, they always seem flat without any volume..

He's a work in progress with the asses.

 

[Moegara]

The four of them have a solid chance if Oda feels like it.

Given the former condition, Smoothie doesn't have a chance. The other three are alright:
- Yamato has the power and potential.
- Hancock, albeit mostly thanks to her fruit, also has the potential and is still a CoC user.
- Bonney is like, what, 12? She will be huge come the day.

 

[Kung-Fu Dugong]

i like that hancock had a disappointing scuffle with blackbeard by neg diffing half of his commanders and being such a threat to blackbeard himself he would rather kill her and lose his crew than risk letting her go to start fighting him, but Law was a yonko-tier fighter with yonko-tier haki for getting low-diffed by the same commanders, losing his entire crew except Bepo, and almost dying if it weren't for Chopper drugs

Well, she managed to do that just due to her hax DF powers and Teach was just with two of his Titanic Captains (actually the worst ones he could bring against Hancock... lol). Yamato managed to hold her own against Kaido much better IMO (she even showed actual haki feats, which Hancock was supposed to be able too in my view). As for Law, I think that he did better than Hancock against BB too.

I don't think that Law is Yonko tier btw (and I don't even think that all Yonko crews are equal in strength, there might be a big difference still, especially regarding the new Yonko crews).