How were the stories in the write-up?

  • They were meh. I didn't like them

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    16
Status
Not open for further replies.

EkkoLoJinx

How far I'll go...
Not sure until I hear more from him.

Points which I found scummy:

Wanted to shift focus on the king who cannot be investigated and there is a 50-50 chance of rolling evil or good.

When asked if he was joking he confirmed that he was pretty serious.

When asked about reasons, he didn’t mention any other than the fact that Kawaii rolls scum too often in the games they have played together

Points against why he could be scummy:

Might be his new way of contributing as town to challenge the affiliation of king.

Might has forgot that King lynch can add to complications in the game so it’s best to leave it for butler or later part of game.

It’s his second TOL game IIRC, so he’s not so experienced about the setup. Isn’t it @Enryu

So I’m having bad vibes from him but at the same time I’m not finding him lynch worthy. My stance is 60-40 I’m regards to scum or town.
beautiful, that was very much the correct answer

ur being consistent with this

Yeah it’s obvious scum trick or a slip. I’m not sure what it is. Would like to hear more from him and his reads about other people. Apart from Kawaii.
looks good on you

would love to give you a town lock license but this is a game with cult mechanics so tough time
 

EkkoLoJinx

How far I'll go...
actually a point against the possibility of both cult and unseen existing in the game is that what happens if one of them tries to cult the other?

its possible cult is just cult and unseen is transformed to a fully unseen mafia faction right from the get go?
 

EkkoLoJinx

How far I'll go...
regardless if this is a stretched version of the standard ToL setup, day 1 is mostly gna be hunting for indies cuz even the mafia/cult faction start with rly few numbers its almost indie-like

so look for players that are individually scummy, more so than interactions that give distancing/teammates vibes

players like .. cough .. alibaba .. cough.. for example..

its possible to have scum/scum interactions, but those will likely be from different teams/indies this early on
 
did you read my post on enryu?

im interested to see why u think flower/enryu r scum here
they very well could be
id like to hear ur proposition
I didnt like how flower tried to push zemm vs mid as a thing very early on, there was no real reason to suspect any of them imo not anything seriousbat least. I thought it was a very scummy thing to do.
I said i will give enryu the benifit of the doubt. But hes talking like he knows the game mechanics and from what others said its not a good thing to push for the king early on. I am a new player mind yoh he is too.
How ever after reading your post that its actually a town thing i am unsure anymore.
Either way i will keep my eye on him.
 

EkkoLoJinx

How far I'll go...
I didnt like how flower tried to push zemm vs mid as a thing very early on, there was no real reason to suspect any of them imo not anything seriousbat least. I thought it was a very scummy thing to do.
I said i will give enryu the benifit of the doubt. But hes talking like he knows the game mechanics and from what others said its not a good thing to push for the king early on. I am a new player mind yoh he is too.
How ever after reading your post that its actually a town thing i am unsure anymore.
Either way i will keep my eye on him.
how hard do u think she tried to push mid vs zem? i thought it was fuji pushing that angle, or atleast pushing mid/zem to claim or clarify their hints (by claiming essentially..)

tbh in a normal ToL, both cult and unseen cannot be in the game so its fair for a towny minded player to try and obtain more info regarding the game if 2 other players have conflicting info regarding the presence of unseen or cult in the game

i honestly have no idea what midnight is doing with that early hint he gave. i hope he was not being serious about it. regardless hes gna be a magnet to scum actions, unless hes scum himself

i would imagine scum flower to just note that down in her scum chat and not bother with midnight here, but just quietly kill him at night instead of discussing it hard on the thread letting all town watchets/doctors know hey midnight might be a person that needs to be protected

feels counter productive for scum to discuss that early on
 
how hard do u think she tried to push mid vs zem? i thought it was fuji pushing that angle, or atleast pushing mid/zem to claim or clarify their hints (by claiming essentially..)

tbh in a normal ToL, both cult and unseen cannot be in the game so its fair for a towny minded player to try and obtain more info regarding the game if 2 other players have conflicting info regarding the presence of unseen or cult in the game

i honestly have no idea what midnight is doing with that early hint he gave. i hope he was not being serious about it. regardless hes gna be a magnet to scum actions, unless hes scum himself

i would imagine scum flower to just note that down in her scum chat and not bother with midnight here, but just quietly kill him at night instead of discussing it hard on the thread letting all town watchets/doctors know hey midnight might be a person that needs to be protected

feels counter productive for scum to discuss that early on
So…basically we have Zem vs Midnight here given their statements.
 

EkkoLoJinx

How far I'll go...
@ZoroSlaysDragonTuna

if someone tells you there is unseen in the game, then someone tells you there is cult in the game, but the game mechanic itself normally says ONLY one of them can be in the game, its definitely worth to question it

i like that she took the initiative to ask drago about it as well, tho thats easy to fake as scum tbh

the post i dont like from flower are these:

I‘m the Towniest Town lately. Or in this case, the greatest Dragon to ever Dragon.
why did she have the need to specify shes blue dragon here? felt unnecessary and worried that she gets asked that town is blue dragon here

GTH everyone is Blue Dragon and Drago went crazy since it‘s a special game supposed to give us a Horror feeling and the biggest Horror is killing your own allies.
here and in 2 other posts she keeps calling town by dragons instead, and this post itself is weird af. i cant even explain it

but other than these 2 and i guess mild zem vs mid push i dont see bad vibes from flower
 
@ZoroSlaysDragonTuna

if someone tells you there is unseen in the game, then someone tells you there is cult in the game, but the game mechanic itself normally says ONLY one of them can be in the game, its definitely worth to question it

i like that she took the initiative to ask drago about it as well, tho thats easy to fake as scum tbh

the post i dont like from flower are these:


why did she have the need to specify shes blue dragon here? felt unnecessary and worried that she gets asked that town is blue dragon here


here and in 2 other posts she keeps calling town by dragons instead, and this post itself is weird af. i cant even explain it

but other than these 2 and i guess mild zem vs mid push i dont see bad vibes from flower
I will still want to hear more from her when she comes back.
 
S

Sallucion

Aplogies, I won't be that active. Still moving from one place to another and it's eating my time. Should be done by Friday evening.

Anyway, this is my first ToL games. Reading the first few pages I see people discussing if we either have unseen or cult. Not sure how much of a priority it is to know D1 which one of them you are dealing with?


im so far liking fuji/flower/zem/midnight
Mind explaining me why Midnight is in your list? I haven't played any games with Midnight, or I forgot lol. But it looks more to me that his post are empty. Once asked a questions his replies are.. empty. Also the rude answer he did give to Zem once asked a question is strange to me. But again, I have no clue how midnight plays, so thus why my questions why he's in your list.
 

Worst

Custom title
Not sure until I hear more from him.

Points which I found scummy:

Wanted to shift focus on the king who cannot be investigated and there is a 50-50 chance of rolling evil or good.
I didn't wanted to shift focus..as i said i didn't really tried to push anything I just answered to Flower and agreed that i would be ok voting for Kawai, it was what ? the 2nd page ? we had 0 infos so far so i'd take the 50% chance (+ the chances of her rolling scum often) of beign right....

When asked about reasons, he didn’t mention any other than the fact that Kawaii rolls scum too often in the games they have played together
(Not the games with Played together i was just told she rolls scum often :kayneshrug:) and again read above

Might has forgot that King lynch can add to complications in the game so it’s best to leave it for butler or later part of game.
Yea i didn't knew we could have had complications......

It’s his second TOL game IIRC, so he’s not so experienced about the setup. Isn’t it @Enryu
Yea i don't know what i'm doing xD
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Not a fan of Ekko or Ultra so far. Ekko feels like he's trying to make a mountain out of a molehill and nitpick players rather than figure them out. Ultra is much the same but leaning into it subtley.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top