[FNZ] Role Madness Valentine's Mafia Game: Be My Valentine

[Charlie]

i mean, sure

let's assume it's George and one of his parents survived - which one? it's basically flip of the coin

George has better motive than Maria, but this goes down to guess between 2 tbh, which is why i'm leaning more towards rosa-maria

 

[Charlie]

I mean, what if killer killed 4 people in the dinning room and Kinzo?

nah, Kinzo isn't part of the story

nvm

 

[DoflaMihawk]

i mean, sure

let's assume it's George and one of his parents survived - which one? it's basically flip of the coin

George has better motive than Maria, but this goes down to guess between 2 tbh, which is why i'm leaning more towards rosa-maria

Why not both parents? There are 2 mystery people alive at the end

 

[Charlie]

I'm thinking now it's either Battler + his parents or George + his parents. If it were Maria and Rosa, then Rosa would be trapped in the T2 room, and Maria couldn't have done T7 and T8 killings by herself.

Because at least 5 people were killed T1.

 

[Charlie]

5 or 6 people died T1, period

there's no way that both parents of either george or battler survived

 

[Indigo]

Guys, the murder mystery just gives a prize for the actual mafia game...

are we gonna play Mafia or no?

are we lynching somebody?

 

[Reborn]

Because at least 5 people were killed T1.

5 or 6 people died T1, period

there's no way that both parents of either george or battler survived

Nah that statement is wrong

 

[DoflaMihawk]

@Charlie































Ratch clarified that, he said the t1 killer killed five across the whole story. So they could've killed 4 in t1, faked their death with their partner, then krauss and natsuhi in t2







Mentioning cuz my quote button is glicthy

 

[Charlie]

Nah that statement is wrong

wdym?

Guys, the murder mystery just gives a prize for the actual mafia game...

are we gonna play Mafia or no?

are we lynching somebody?

i mean, ngl, i wanna see what i could get for that

i'm lowkey surprised you haven't even commented on the whole mystery thing tbh given you had your own mystery game

are you solving it in scum chat or what? xd

 

[Indigo]

wdym?



i mean, ngl, i wanna see what i could get for that

i'm lowkey surprised you haven't even commented on the whole mystery thing tbh given you had your own mystery game

are you solving it in scum chat or what? xd

I just don't have a lot of time for this murder mystery thing

and it's way too complex to do it quickly

you have to put a bunch of statements together in a single file and then compare stataments

it's way too time consuming for solving something that can only give an advantage for the actual mafia game we're playing

 

[Indigo]

If solving the Murder Mystery was my wincon, then yeah, i would focus on it

like Prof should be doing

but right now, i really can't put that much time into it

i'm still thinking a little about it though

 

[Reborn]

wdym?



i mean, ngl, i wanna see what i could get for that

i'm lowkey surprised you haven't even commented on the whole mystery thing tbh given you had your own mystery game

are you solving it in scum chat or what? xd

I meant what dofla said.

Ratchet made a post here clarifying what he meant by atleast 5 dead.


And, it's not restricted to T1.

So we may have two people faking death on T1 itself

 

[Charlie]

If solving the Murder Mystery was my wincon, then yeah, i would focus on it

like Prof should be doing

but right now, i really can't put that much time into it

i'm still thinking a little about it though

ngl, i find it bit weird that you're not even trying

you're saying it's time consuming, but it's not like you're spending time you saved on ignoring the game on scum hunting or anything .-.

 

[Indigo]

ngl, i find it bit weird that you're not even trying

you're saying it's time consuming, but it's not like you're spending time you saved on ignoring the game on scum hunting or anything .-.

How can i scum hunt, when the entire thread is just people talking about the case?

and Alwaysmind, the main wagon, doesn't show up to claim or defend himself?

 

[xenos5]

Guys, the murder mystery just gives a prize for the actual mafia game...

are we gonna play Mafia or no?

are we lynching somebody?

Two main wagons are Alwaysmind and DrProfessor with Alwaysmind being in the lead between the two.

Nothing much has really changed on that front.

If you’ve got a new counter wagon to push or something to say about the existing wagons, you should probably say so soon before the phase ends later today.

 

[Indigo]

Two main wagons are Alwaysmind and DrProfessor with Alwaysmind being in the lead between the two.

Nothing much has really changed on that front.

If you’ve got a new counter wagon to push or something to say about the existing wagons, you should probably say so soon before the phase ends later today.

I already vouched for Prof's claim

i have mech info to believe he is saying the truth

i don't know about Alwaysmind, no information about him, no defense or claim yet, dude has 8 posts

and the case on him by hime seems to be based on him showing up, voting, and then leaving

and saying he is still reading / liking the posts, but not interacting

not much to go forward here

 

[Charlie]

I wanted to check for George thing, but there's literally noone he could kill.

Look at that though. They're contradicting each other, but we know that Jessica can't be lying.

Maria: Once again, none of us has an alibi.

Jessica: All of us... in other words, the four cousins and Doctor Nanjo couldn't have killed Gohda-san and Kumasawa-san.

 

[DoflaMihawk]

Is there a good reason to believe its either Geroge and co. or Battler and co.? Stuck on those two

 

[Charlie]

How can i scum hunt, when the entire thread is just people talking about the case?

and Alwaysmind, the main wagon, doesn't show up to claim or defend himself?

i mean, for all we know, even if AM was picked as low hanging fruit by scum, he might very well be part of 2nd scum team (look at ways to gather coins, one of them implies there're multiple factions)

but sure, who would you want question more?

 

[Charlie]

Is there a good reason to believe its either Geroge and co. or Battler and co.? Stuck on those two

George would have to kill Shannon, but everyone and their mother say he couldn't do it.