Character Discussion We are at Chapter 1086 in One Piece and "NOTHING HAPPENED" after 2 Decades still didnt managed to get surpassed as a Moment. By far too good...

#68
Going Merry's funeral, Skypiea's bell ring, Skypiea arc closing curtain is clearly better.

Luffy' "say you wanna live"
Strawhat lining up at Enies Lobby
Luffy saying to Arlong "use?"
Luffy saying to Nami "you're my nakama!"

Are also better.
 
#72
I don't want to say this is TOP 1 moment but gawd damn is it hard to find something that beats it.

To touch base on the contenders I feel that;
Whitebeards death panel was damn great

I want to live was honestly ass, the anime went hard tho.. Sogeking burning the flag trumps I want to live by a fucking mile unless you want to count those as the same thing, you just might be cooking there

Blackbeard's dream speech in context of and relevance to the story is absolutely amazing but the actual delivery doesn't hit as anywhere near as hard

Gear 5 was a ride, the hype was definitely there but it was a bittersweet experience

I'm not even going to bother with Luffy X Sanjino piece bullshit.

Idk but I think another viable contender may be zoro unlocking breath of all things against Mr. 1. and Sanji chuffing a phattie and talking shit while burnt like a KFC tendie just before closing on a Friday night.
 
#73
I don't want to say this is TOP 1 moment but gawd damn is it hard to find something that beats it.

To touch base on the contenders I feel that;
Whitebeards death panel was damn great

I want to live was honestly ass, the anime went hard tho.. Sogeking burning the flag trumps I want to live by a fucking mile unless you want to count those as the same thing, you just might be cooking there

Blackbeard's dream speech in context of and relevance to the story is absolutely amazing but the actual delivery doesn't hit as anywhere near as hard

Gear 5 was a ride, the hype was definitely there but it was a bittersweet experience

I'm not even going to bother with Luffy X Sanjino piece bullshit.

Idk but I think another viable contender may be zoro unlocking breath of all things against Mr. 1. and Sanji chuffing a phattie and talking shit while burnt like a KFC tendie just before closing on a Friday night.
You missed Law's speech about breaking the cogs, after splitting a mountain.

Was a top tier moment, best in post TS IMO


@park_min young
 
#74
You missed Law's speech about breaking the cogs, after splitting a mountain.

Was a top tier moment, best in post TS IMO


@park_min young
Yeah there was a few I missed, it was already a wall of ramble. :josad: I kinda just went with the ones I loved or hated and went spastic with the talk jutsu

Tbh as much as I liked that scene it never really stuck with me, I don't even really know why.
comparing it to a lot of Post TS scenes this is definitely a stand out.

I'm very interested to see how this arc goes, its already lining up itself up to have some of the most relevant and impactful scenes since the timeskip, hell I wouldn't be surprised if we get a new GOAT scene this arc.
 
#75
- Arlong park walk
- Robin's " I want to live"
- Zoro's "Nothing happened"
- WB's death

Nothing comes close to these 4 scenes and even tho i hope some scene in the future will surpass them i seriously doubt it.

p.s Rayleigh's introduction was also a top scene but the anime handled it much much better.
Good list. I'd say those 4 moments and "He laughed" are OP's top 5 greatest moments.

Although, to be clear, I think these 5 moments are OP's anime greatest moments.

If we're talking about OP's manga 5 greatest moments, I'd replace the "Arlong Park Walk" (since it's an anime original scene) with the entirety of Nami asking Luffy for help and Luffy lending her the straw hat, before he says of course and we got the reveal that the other 3 SHs are there already.

Basically, the walk makes it for the anime, but the Straw Hat lending made it for the manga. :steef:
 
#76
Good list. I'd say those 4 moments and "He laughed" are OP's top 5 greatest moments.

Although, to be clear, I think these 5 moments are OP's anime greatest moments.

If we're talking about OP's manga 5 greatest moments, I'd replace the "Arlong Park Walk" (since it's an anime original scene) with the entirety of Nami asking Luffy for help and Luffy lending her the straw hat, before he says of course and we got the reveal that the other 3 SHs are there already.

Basically, the walk makes it for the anime, but the Straw Hat lending made it for the manga. :steef:
Oh yeah Smoker's "he laughed" is another little gem, totally forgot about it.

Damn OP used to be so fucking good back in the day.
 
Top