General & Others What are your biggest regrets when it comes to the One Piece story?

#21
Time Line .

Until the PS , strew hat spent 3 month together.
After PS , fırst day fishman second day punk hazar third day dressrosa , and one month wcı wano.
Luffy will be made King of Pirates in just 1 year.
How did the crew become so interconnected in 4 months?
“As Luffy left training, I learned the basics of all haki,” he said. He can learn basics in two years, but he can open all advanced modes in 1 month.

I'm not even touching the powerscalling thing.
Post automatically merged:

Think about Marineford. Luffy used CoC and made lots of marine unconscious.

So, if it is like easy. Why did not WB use CoC which more more more more stronger than Luffys CoC at that time.

Sabo is shown as a Dragon commanders and he can give a fight to admiral wıth neg dif . Ivankov right hand of a DRAGON. How cannot he do anything to Admiral. Sabo directly suprassed Zoro and Sanji. Ace contiune where he left.
 
Last edited:
#23
Big regrets? Nothing for most part......post skip should focus more on straw hats than secondary characters like scabbards/tama......fights shouldn't be off screened so much........PIS.........
 
#30
samurai stealing the spotlight of wano from strawhats
Oda always hype the samurai by made akainu even wary of them but after reading so far we think he failed to even made samurai characters interesting .... even the scabbies n kouzuki clan feel bland n uninteresting
they just go for simple revenge n open the border n maybe helping wano citizen but even that wano citizen is not a good people they CREATE Orochi n start the cycle of revenge so we hardly sympatize with them ...
plus the slow arc n padding about the sccabies why .... i mean they got what they want fight with kaido they lose why revive them n made them back again in story ??? who will they fight? kaido again? king n queen ? BMP? Orochi + CP0 ? let them get a honorable death Oda
 
#31
My biggest regret is how Oda treats Luffy. He has an opportunity to develop the character, not just being a chosen one with infinity luck.
Honestly, I like the chosen one route... you know why?
Cause it’s bullshit if you guys think Luffy will not eventually be PK regardless hhhh

He’s Shonen MC, he’s destined to become one regardless if story said he’s chosen one or not hhhhh

It’s like Zoro and WSS or Nami and drawing world map or Sanji and finding all blue...etc!

They are “in story” not chosen ones... but let’s all be real... those dreams are gonna happen regardless hahaha... one way or another, they will do it... just cause in the story it said “it was achieved by effort and not fate” doesn’t mean they were not fated hhhhh... we already know it will happen
 
#32
Honestly, I like the chosen one route... you know why?
Cause it’s bullshit if you guys think Luffy will not eventually be PK regardless hhhh

He’s Shonen MC, he’s destined to become one regardless if story said he’s chosen one or not hhhhh

It’s like Zoro and WSS or Nami and drawing world map or Sanji and finding all blue...etc!

They are “in story” not chosen ones... but let’s all be real... those dreams are gonna happen regardless hahaha... one way or another, they will do it... just cause in the story it said “it was achieved by effort and not fate” doesn’t mean they were not fated hhhhh... we already know it will happen
Everybody know Luffy will become PK, but I think the execution is extremely poor. Great story makes readers feel characters' emotions, make character relatable in some way. This is the opposite to what Oda has done for Luffy. People perceive that Luffy will become PK because of the plot, his unlimited willpower, or his infinity luck. This make this character look so bland.
 
#33
Everybody know Luffy will become PK, but I think the execution is extremely poor. Great story makes readers feel characters' emotions, make character relatable in some way. This is the opposite to what Oda has done for Luffy. People perceive that Luffy will become PK because of the plot, his unlimited willpower, or his infinity luck. This make this character look so bland.
I think this can only be solved IFFF some members in the crew already died without achieving their dreams... and they got replaced with new ones... that’s when you start feeling threat and Luffy is underdog again

other than that... everything seems paved and ready honestly
 
#39
for two, can you open ?
1. Skipped fight - not showing character strugling, fighting for his/her dreams, while instead showing character as old furniture ruined One Piece. SH was always about crew, team as whole, it was never DBZ style;
2. Wano arc - starting from villains that showed as clowns: farmers, Queen who do nothing against Luffy inside of his own prison, Kaido - main Villain, was beaten by scrubs like Kiku(how the guy who falled from 10.000 was pirced by scrub and scream?), O-Lin, Big Mom as clown as whole, BMP pirates, raid from the begining etc
3. Yamato could be much much better character with different personality, even if she would be loyal to Kaido. There was way to made her potentially join crew for other reasons, she would be great if she was fighting against Luffy from the begining. Or anything else, except that Oden shit, and her calling Momo her son...
4. WCI ending - no fights between SH and BMP, everything was rushes and skipped except Luffy. Katakuri who changed personality 10 times, BM who was stopped by weakest SH etc, no danger. WCI was perfect till cake explode;
5. Fanservice before ts was fun and maybe enjoyable, while after ts its just disgusting in many terms. Like Robin and Nami going bathing in public bath, Momo thing and much more.
 
Top