Speculations What Oda has in mind with Buggy ?

[nik87]

In the same phrase that Buggy is called the second son, Shanks is called the first son. Care to contextualise?

Nothing rings a bell regarding Shanks.

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Nothing rings a bell regarding Shanks.

In the same panel mate, or the previous to the one you just quoted

Post automatically merged: Wednesday at 2:35 PM

The Iron/Empty throne.

Iz this game of thrones

 

[nik87]

In the same panel mate, or the previous to the one you just quoted

I know but nothing rings a bell why he was called 1st son.

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

I know but nothing rings a bell why he was called 1st son.

For the same reason Buggy is called 2nd?
Because they are Roger's "sons"?

 

[nik87]

For the same reason Buggy is called 2nd?
Because they are Roger's "sons"?

Shanks' wanted poster isnt identical to Rocks' poster.

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Shanks' wanted poster isnt identical to Rocks' poster.

That's another topic entirely, nik. Why change the topic?

 

[nik87]

That's another topic entirely, nik. Why change the topic?

Because it ties into what I was saying to begin with - Buggy being related to Rocks.
Couldnt figure it out on your own?

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Because it ties into what I was saying to begin with - Buggy being related to Rocks.
Couldnt figure it out on your own?

No, because the word second son you extrapolated out of context, as in the same phrase/scene Shanks is called first son, as such buggy is considered the "second son" of the crew, and shanks the "first".
I know for you reading english is hard.

 

[soupongo]

In the end, Buggy has been called the 2nd son by Oden and that is obviously going to end up somewhere.
I say it ends up with him being the 2nd son of the guy with an identical wanted poster and LinLin has nearly the same.

He was the only other known apprentice on the ship

Regarding the D, he probably has no clue that he belongs to that clan.

But he should.... Would the Roger pirates just never tell him about his heritage? That's borderline cruel......

Oh and he's also white....

 

[kumae]

Loda's top 5 favourite characters
He will find the op but he won't know what it is

 

[nik87]

No, because the word second son you extrapolated out of context, as in the same phrase/scene Shanks is called first son, as such buggy is considered the "second son" of the crew, and shanks the "first".
I know for you reading english is hard.

And I say Buggy is 2nd son of Rocks and has nothing to do with Shanks.
Watch me end up right, again.

But he should.... Would the Roger pirates just never tell him about his heritage? That's borderline cruel......

Oh and he's also white....

How would they tell him he is a D if they didnt know either?
So is Big Mom.

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

And I say Buggy is 2nd son of Rocks and has nothing to do with Shanks.
Watch me end up right, again.

How would they tell him he is a D if they didnt know either?
So is Big Mom.

Care to tell me once that you were right in a debate with me?

Also, you can speculate as much as you want, but when proven wrong it's good manners to acknowledge that.

 

[nik87]

Care to tell me once that you were right in a debate with me?

Also, you can speculate as much as you want, but when proven wrong it's good manners to acknowledge that.

I am always right, because you fail at reading comprehension each time.
Already forgot? When was I wrong and did not acknowledge it?

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

I am always right, because you fail at reading comprehension each time.
Already forgot? When was I wrong and did not acknowledge it?

I know but nothing rings a bell why he was called 1st son.

Literally one post ago.

 

[nik87]

Literally one post ago.

What was I wrong about in that post?

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

What was I wrong about in that post?

I dont concern myself with the details or rather the path, I am focused on the end goal/result.
Oda will whip up any explanation he deems fit for those questions you asked.

In the end, Buggy has been called the 2nd son by Oden and that is obviously going to end up somewhere.
I say it ends up with him being the 2nd son of the guy with an identical wanted poster and LinLin has nearly the same.

Regarding the D, he probably has no clue that he belongs to that clan.

Here.
You says he's called second son because he's the second of Xebec.
Then Why is Shanks called first in the same dialog?

Please take the L this is just silly.

 

[nik87]

Here.
You says he's called second son because he's the second of Xebec.
Then Why is Shanks called first in the same dialog?

Please take the L this is just silly.

As I said, I dont concern myself with why Shanks was called the 1st son.
Where was I wrong about saying Buggy is 2nd son of Rocks?
You do know the result of this claim has yet to be determined?
Or you just want me to be wrong that bad?

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

As I said, I dont concern myself with why Shanks was called the 1st son.
Where was I wrong about saying Buggy is 2nd son of Rocks?
You do know the result of this claim has yet to be determined?
Or you just want me to be wrong that bad?

Come on you're being thick on purpose.
Buggy gets called second son, you say there is an hidden meaning.
In the same phrase, Shanks gets called first son, but now there is no hidden meaning.
So the same description (first son, second son) is given to two people in the same role (apprentice) in the same discussion in the same context but one has a hidden meaning.
The only explanation is that Shanks is the secret first son of somebody, but it's already been refuted last chapter.
Please acknowledge that this is your line of thought and realise how contradictory you're being.

 

[nik87]

Come on you're being thick on purpose.
Buggy gets called second son, you say there is an hidden meaning.
In the same phrase, Shanks gets called first son, but now there is no hidden meaning.
So the same description (first son, second son) is given to two people in the same role (apprentice) in the same discussion in the same context but one has a hidden meaning.
The only explanation is that Shanks is the secret first son of somebody, but it's already been refuted last chapter.
Please acknowledge that this is your line of thought and realise how contradictory you're being.

I didnt say there is no hidden meaning regarding Shanks, I said I dont know what it means.
Get your facts straight instead of wishing so hard that I end up wrong.
Once again, I dont care what it means in case of Shanks, I am only interested in Buggy being Rocks' 2nd son.

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

I didnt say there is no hidden meaning regarding Shanks, I said I dont know what it means.
Get your facts straight instead of wishing so hard that I end up wrong.
Once again, I dont care what it means in case of Shanks, I am only interested in Buggy being Rocks' 2nd son.

But there is no hidden meaning for Shanks.
It was shown last week him being born.
Please take the L.