General & Others What was the Worst Plot Point in One Piece?

#41
The statement of once means that only one other.
Only one other time. Yes. Meaning that they only encountered someone replying to them (and therefore understanding them) only once in the past after the hidden century : When Roger replied to them.

And no point it rules out Oden. Which was most likely created FAR before this point. Because something you absolutely do not take into consideration is that in the next 10 chapters Punk Hazard begins. And with Punk Hazard it's also the entire YONKO SAga that begins and with that it's the introduction of MOMO and with that it's the setup for the reveal of Oden in Zou and Momo's path.

In other words, you are completely ignoring the fact that when Oda drew this :



He would have had the MAJOR plot points of Wano and therefore the flashback of Oden already planned out for a LONG TIME before chapter 648.

Looking at the structure of the Saga, it can't be done otherwise.

So Oda knew that Oden was present on the boat already when drawing this chapter. (and he surely also knew that someone like Oden was present on the boat already back while writing the end Skypiea.)

Dude stop trying to defend a clear retcon. Oda doesn’t write a perfect story
1. I don't think you know what a retcon is. A retcon is not necessarily a negative things, in some case it's actually a positive thing.
2. There is no retcon here. Again, you are missremembering and missunderstanding CLEAR statements in the story, and riling up a criticizing for absolutely no reason.

And the problem is that it's the same thing for 99 % of the critic against One Piece on this forum.
 
#42
Only one other time. Yes. Meaning that they only encountered someone replying to them (and therefore understanding them) only once in the past after the hidden century : When Roger replied to them.

And no point it rules out Oden. Which was most likely created FAR before this point. Because something you absolutely do not take into consideration is that in the next 10 chapters Punk Hazard begins. And with Punk Hazard it's also the entire YONKO SAga that begins and with that it's the introduction of MOMO and with that it's the setup for the reveal of Oden in Zou and Momo's path.

In other words, you are completely ignoring the fact that when Oda drew this :



He would have had the MAJOR plot points of Wano and therefore the flashback of Oden already planned out for a LONG TIME before chapter 648.

Looking at the structure of the Saga, it can't be done otherwise.

So Oda knew that Oden was present on the boat already when drawing this chapter. (and he surely also knew that someone like Oden was present on the boat already back while writing the end Skypiea.)


1. I don't think you know what a retcon is. A retcon is not necessarily a negative things, in some case it's actually a positive thing.
2. There is no retcon here. Again, you are missremembering and missunderstanding CLEAR statements in the story, and riling up a criticizing for absolutely no reason.

And the problem is that it's the same thing for 99 % of the critic against One Piece on this forum.
Brah but you too are the same... Right like two opposing points exist but you choose to believe the one which fits your agenda.... Everything is for agenda :BigW:
 
Last edited:
#44
Oh boy where do i start..

FI nosebleeds
Shinokuni
Birdcage
Wedding cake
I'm Oden
BM amnesia
Oni virus
Zillion new characters for no purpose at all
Oh my god, how could I forget Meme's amnesia? Definitely top 3 worst for me.
:shame:
Post automatically merged:

Brah but you to are the same... Right like two opposing points exist but you choose to believe the one which fits your agenda.... Everything is from agenda :BigW:
Don't bother, you're talking to literal "Story Jesus" himself, our peasant opinions can't comprehend the sheer genius of Oda's writing. Logiko is the One True Reader (unless you agree with him, then you're a normal and nice person).
 
#45
Lolden

Everything tying to this clown has been a disaster. Wano was a dumpster fire because of this clown. Even after he was dead, his fucking scabbards made to sure to drag out an already bloated arc. And a potentially cool character, a child of a yonko, was completely and utterly ruined by the delusions of her to become lolden. Kaido, the arc and saga villain, was ruined and didn't even get a proper flashback or explanations of his motives because the arc was way too fucking long due to all the lolden wank.

Fuck lolden.
 
#52
I didn't like the key plotline in Enies Lobby.
CP9 was supposed to be full of professional assassins, why are they playing around games with the Straw Hats? Why did each of them have keys with them, and why would they even have the real key with one of them? And why even tell the Straw Hats?
This whole thing annoyed me a bit.
To split them up and take them one by one?
They already invaded the island of justice at that point, nd only cp9 could stop them?
Not convincing but could at least be something. And chapapa tells them because it is canon he is retardef
 
#55
Tamatebakko was waaaaay worse than the bird cage. Nit only did it serve no narrative purpose, it literally started the downfall of post TS. Wci went completely went to shit after it and then the Wano disaster happened, then the crowded clusterfuck that was Egghead.
I don't think the Tamatebakko box was a bad plot point per se, I actually like the idea Oda had there.

It was just that the execution was so bad, that many people (understandably) hate it now.
 
#57
Only one other time. Yes. Meaning that they only encountered someone replying to them (and therefore understanding them) only once in the past after the hidden century : When Roger replied to them.

And no point it rules out Oden. Which was most likely created FAR before this point. Because something you absolutely do not take into consideration is that in the next 10 chapters Punk Hazard begins. And with Punk Hazard it's also the entire YONKO SAga that begins and with that it's the introduction of MOMO and with that it's the setup for the reveal of Oden in Zou and Momo's path.

In other words, you are completely ignoring the fact that when Oda drew this :



He would have had the MAJOR plot points of Wano and therefore the flashback of Oden already planned out for a LONG TIME before chapter 648.

Looking at the structure of the Saga, it can't be done otherwise.

So Oda knew that Oden was present on the boat already when drawing this chapter. (and he surely also knew that someone like Oden was present on the boat already back while writing the end Skypiea.)


1. I don't think you know what a retcon is. A retcon is not necessarily a negative things, in some case it's actually a positive thing.
2. There is no retcon here. Again, you are missremembering and missunderstanding CLEAR statements in the story, and riling up a criticizing for absolutely no reason.

And the problem is that it's the same thing for 99 % of the critic against One Piece on this forum.
Dude believes Oda had planned Shitno since ch. 648 lmao

logiko
There’s no retcon
Even if there was a retcon it was good
 
Top