Questions & Mysteries Who else can survive the Oden-boil execution?

[Finalbeta]

Good explaination. Never thought like that

It's wrong.

Akainu did not simply smother Ace's fire putting it out (basically it's a phenomenon by which magma is preventing oxygen to reach fire in order to have it burning) , he literally burned it. This is what canon tells us. It tells us that magma literally burns fire. It does not put it out.

You can't simply nullify another element differently in OP. Ace would have still been capable to protect himself with fire without letting himself be burnt differently, overwhelmed or not, that's a different matter.

So this is just an attempt to make things fit. But OP is plenty of disastrous physics. I particularly know it since I particularly care about that field.

 

[Cross_Marian]

Can Survive without help of a DF Power:
Roger - WB - Rayleigh - Shanks - Mihawk - Kaido - BM - Teach - Garp - EOS Luffy - EOS Zoro - Kuma - Weevil (Just a guess)

Basically Non-DF Top Tiers + Yonko due to their Bodies + Kuma due to his Modified Body + Weevil if he is have WB's Physical Stats

Can survive thanks to DF Power:
Brook - Oven - Logia Admirals - Ace - Sabo - Enel - Marco

Most Logia Users are Self Explanatory + Oven who can handle Heat + Marco who counters Fire/Heat & can Heal + Brook's Soul

You’re right with everything but you forgot to add Dragon.

 

[Veljko]

Wouldnt it be fairer that charachters that have devil fruits be counted without them as its feat of durability so strip Akainu of his df and others,..

 

[MonsterZoro]

sanji

Post automatically merged: Feb 16, 2021

sanji lite himself on fire easy tank this

Post automatically merged: Feb 16, 2021

sanji take bath in water hoter then this

 

[Finalbeta]

Fire cannot be burnt in real life by the way, since practically it's the heat and light from the oxidation of fuel and there's nothing to oxidize. This is the technical explanation.

So you understand OP is flawed since it canonically states that magma can burn fire. But as I said IRL it can be smothered yet not burnt.

 

[stairs-kun]

The Grandmaster

 

[Raughtale]

Traumatized Orochi

 

[Celestial D. Dragon]

It's wrong.

Akainu did not simply smother Ace's fire putting it out (basically it's a phenomenon by which magma is preventing oxygen to reach fire in order to have it burning) , he literally burned it. This is what canon tells us. It tells us that magma literally burns fire. It does not put it out.

You can't simply nullify another element differently in OP. Ace would have still been capable to protect himself with fire without letting himself be burnt differently, overwhelmed or not, that's a different matter.

So this is just an attempt to make things fit. But OP is plenty of disastrous physics. I particularly know it since I particularly care about that field.

It's not wrong. You can literally see the magma engulf Ace's flames and arm prior to him getting burnt. It's not a matter of "His magma touched Ace's flames, and Ace got burnt", as it completely snuffed out the flames, and engulfed his arm.

Akainu saying "My magma can burn even fire" is nothing more than bravado. You can either accept an actual real world explanation, which is indicated by how the scene was drawn, or say fuck logic, Magma somehow burns intangible matter, which then transfer's to only Ace's arm (where the magma actually connected and engulfed), but not the rest of his body for some odd reason.

 

[Screws Loose242]

Sanji for sure
Zoro
Franky
Brook
Usopp bc he complains so much the oil wont touch him etc.
Katakuri
Oven and so many more

 

[MD25]

Without DF ? The Yonko. Luffy. Sanji and some.

 

[Konstantis]

San Huan Wolf - it was showed in manga...

 

[Ballel]

Akainu (should be pretty obvious because of his elemental advantage)

I disagree on Akainu.
Akainu is magma, not boiling oil.
If there were this kind of elemental advantage then Ace would have survived due to his elemental advantage

 

[Kromage911]

I disagree on Akainu.
Akainu is magma, not boiling oil.
If there were this kind of elemental advantage then Ace would have survived due to his elemental advantage

I wrote it below. Ace and Sabo should also survive it. Along with many other characters like Oven. The right thing would be exclude their devil fruit powers as they also have sea stone chains on at the time of execution. Then, I can only see Kaido, BM and WB surviving it.

 

[K!NG HARA$H!MA]

Caesar

 

[Ballel]

I wrote it below. Ace and Sabo should also survive it. Along with many other characters like Oven. The right thing would be exclude their devil fruit powers as they also have sea stone chains on at the time of execution. Then, I can only see Kaido, BM and WB surviving it.

No, I mean if there was heat resistance only bc if heat related devil fruit, Ace would have survived Akainu

 

[Afroking]

I wrote it below. Ace and Sabo should also survive it. Along with many other characters like Oven. The right thing would be exclude their devil fruit powers as they also have sea stone chains on at the time of execution. Then, I can only see Kaido, BM and WB surviving it.

I get Big Mom and Wb . The former has tough skin from birth and the other is endurance monster . Kaidou however is just a bi-product of his fruit •you take it away,you take away His toughness,recovery rate etc. Not mention he basically admitted he becomes light headed with normal bathwater in the same time span

He doesn't survive this .

 

[MonsterKaido]

I get Big Mom and Wb . The former has tough skin from birth and the other is endurance monster . Kaidou however is just a bi-product of his fruit •you take it away,you take away His toughness,recovery rate etc. Not mention he basically admitted he becomes light headed with normal bathwater in the same time span

He doesn't survive this .

Why would his base durability be related with devil fruit

 

[Afroking]

Why would his base durability be related with devil fruit

Why exactly do you think his Durability isn't gained from his fruit? Clearly that is the case from Luffy's remarks back in udon .Do you think he gains nothing from his fruit when he is in his "human" form??

C'mon now

 

[MonsterKaido]

Why exactly do you think his Durability isn't gained from his fruit? Clearly that is the case from Luffy's remarks back in udon .Do you think he gains nothing from his fruit when he is in his "human" form??

C'mon now

Where it is stated that his base(human form) dura comes from fruit...are you saying lucci can use claws in his base form...obivously he becomes more durable/healing in his dragon form...but in his base he is using his own natural dura....his race most likely...

 

[Afroking]

Where it is stated that his base(human form) dura comes from fruit...are you saying lucci can use claws in his base form...obivously he becomes more durable/healing in his dragon form...but in his base he is using his own natural dura....his race most likely...

What argument is this ....Just because he doesn't get everything from his beast form,doesn't mean he gets nothing ... Did chopper have the ability to talk before his fruit as well or got it thanks to his fruit ???
Does Marco needs to be in his Zoan form to heal?
Does Devon need tobe in her Zoan form to imitate somebody?