Who is the best live-action Spiderman?
- Thread starter Light D Lamperouge
- Start date
Tobey > Andrew > @Lance_Dragonite
I watched all of them except The Amazing Spider-Man 2
Tobey’s was unintentionally funny. First movie was great and it was all downhill from there on out. His Spider-Man’s personality was pretty inconsistent especially movie 3. But it’s so bad that it’s good, I found it entertaining. He also played the part of Peter Parker, a socially awkward dork pretty well but was lacking in terms of Spider-Man.
Only seen the first movie of Andrew’s but wasn’t a fan. His character was boring, the fact that he is supposed to be a nerd just seemed unnatural. He came off more like emo rebel than nerdy social outcast. Even in fights especially when encountering the police, he seemed more like the arrogant aggressor especially with the sarcastic commentaries. But with that said, I think the problem was more of a bad script and not so much on Andrew because I liked Andrew’s Spider-Man in No Way Home. He was fun and none of the issues I stated above was apparent. So I’d say the problem is the script which unfortunately in his OG movies, made him lack charisma
I really like Tom Holland’s Spider-Man. I’d say his is the most well rounded. Tom really makes you realize that Spider-Man is just a nerdy high school kid trying to do some good with his powers. He makes mistakes sometimes but he is learning and trying his best. We also get to see him interact with his friends, other heroes, mundane struggles. While Tobey seemed too socially awkward and rigid while Andrew’s was too aggressive, Tom’s is a pretty good balance in between. He plays both Peter Parker and Spider-Man well. This makes his Spider-Man feel like the most developed and 3 dimensional.
Tom > Tobey > Andrew
Tobey’s was unintentionally funny. First movie was great and it was all downhill from there on out. His Spider-Man’s personality was pretty inconsistent especially movie 3. But it’s so bad that it’s good, I found it entertaining. He also played the part of Peter Parker, a socially awkward dork pretty well but was lacking in terms of Spider-Man.
Only seen the first movie of Andrew’s but wasn’t a fan. His character was boring, the fact that he is supposed to be a nerd just seemed unnatural. He came off more like emo rebel than nerdy social outcast. Even in fights especially when encountering the police, he seemed more like the arrogant aggressor especially with the sarcastic commentaries. But with that said, I think the problem was more of a bad script and not so much on Andrew because I liked Andrew’s Spider-Man in No Way Home. He was fun and none of the issues I stated above was apparent. So I’d say the problem is the script which unfortunately in his OG movies, made him lack charisma
I really like Tom Holland’s Spider-Man. I’d say his is the most well rounded. Tom really makes you realize that Spider-Man is just a nerdy high school kid trying to do some good with his powers. He makes mistakes sometimes but he is learning and trying his best. We also get to see him interact with his friends, other heroes, mundane struggles. While Tobey seemed too socially awkward and rigid while Andrew’s was too aggressive, Tom’s is a pretty good balance in between. He plays both Peter Parker and Spider-Man well. This makes his Spider-Man feel like the most developed and 3 dimensional.
Tom > Tobey > Andrew
