Yes, you are. I told him his observations about activity and passion look generic (and yes, they are) as anyone can throw those out there to CWAC. Then he basically replies with, he‘s too noob to do more in depth thinking. Which is straight up playing the newbie card. If you ISO his posts in Fuji‘s game you can see him arrive at the Polar scum read first by hunch, then going further and utilizing deduction. He‘s still new, but he‘s clearly capable of more as well.