General & Others Would've Rooftop 5 vs 2 been better story-wise, with this certain change?

#1
Just a lil change...what if Sanji joined and made it 6 vs 2?

So maybe first off there would be scrambles and ganging and switching up the opponents randomly, and then it changed to (for example):

Zoro - Law - Kidd vs Kaidou
Luffy - Sanji - Killer vs Big Mom

And finally it switched again to become

Luffy - Sanji - Law vs Kaidou
Zoro - Kidd - Killer vs Big Mom

And at some point King, Queen and Hawkins interfere with Zoro, Sanji, and Killer

While

Luffy vs Kaidou

Kidd vs Big Mom

Law vs Greenbull (arrived at Wano to capture Law for Ope2) or something


---

Will 6 vs 2 be better story-wise and felt more fitting as the struggle against 2 Emperors? Compared to 5 vs 2?
 

Reborn

~~Surpass Your Limits, Right here, Right now~~
#7
I always said that Oda messed up with this.



Wano arc was set as rise of Worstgen. It was meant as new era taking over the old.



But worst gen members were portrayed far weaker than yonkous. So a team fight would be perfect


Rooftop was the right step.


A team fight


Luffy and Zoro vs Kaido (both Luffy and Zoro are linked with taking kaido down)

Law/Kidd/Killer vs BM


All of them getting their Pus but in combination


Luffy - Haki + Awakening(more awakening focus like right now)
Zoro - AdCoC/AdCoA


Kidd - Haki upgrade like AdCoC with Law getting awakening.



King vs Sanji


Queen vs Jinbei



This team fight would be something new for all the readers and won't even upset the power dynamics much.

It would have been breathe of fresh air


Luffy vs Yonkou solo should have been reserved for future.
 
#8
Considering that most of the Rooftop were fanservice (no Adv CoC from Big Mom or Kaido, Kaido jerking off in Dragon form standing giving out free feats to even Killer, No future sight) I'm not do sure the other characters would have been nearly as effective

Literally what or who on the rooftop is stopping Big Mom and Kaido from performing another hakai or an Hakai infused with Adv CoC?
 
#11
Sanji being there would be pointless... Those 5 are the leading figures of the upcoming era (post Worstgen/BB/current era) taking on the leading figures of 2 past era (Roger's era and WB's era)... That, aside of the fact that he's not yet on the level of those 5...
Him not being there is becasue hes not a worstgen memeber, but u cannot compare killer to sanji, so power wise rn yes he could be there with them
 

Finalbeta

Science Nerd 🌌 🌍 🧬 ⚛️
#12
Luffy Vs Big Mom would have had Luffy still losing at first and maybe Big Mom would not have spared his life over and over unlike Kaido kinda did :josad:

Well plot armor could have changed that if forcing it

I guess it's still a shame all that L vs BM hype was built up over the years and not quite personally addressed and resolved
 
#13
Considering that most of the Rooftop were fanservice (no Adv CoC from Big Mom or Kaido, Kaido jerking off in Dragon form standing giving out free feats to even Killer, No future sight) I'm not do sure the other characters would have been nearly as effective

Literally what or who on the rooftop is stopping Big Mom and Kaido from performing another hakai or an Hakai infused with Adv CoC?
THANK YOU. Look at what a serious kaido is doing at the moment then add a bm thats semi compitent and the 5v2 is looking like a massacre for the SN. You would need some insane mix of CIS and plot armor for the SN to pull a W.
 
#16
to those people saying that it should have been a 1v2, 1v3, or even 1v5 against kaido should note that they would be the same people that would complain if luffy is fighting blackbeard who is stronger than primebeard solo saying that it is asspull and it should have been sh vs blackbeard, at least oda is making luffy a top 5 fighter right now and his last to fight would be against the top 2
 
#20
The rooftop was an absolute garbage fight. It was a 5v1 and yet for some reason, every character attacked 1 at a time instead of ganging up on kaido and linlin, like you would expect from a tag team.

Also, Luffy had beef with Linlin, but never did anything to her. Kid had beef with Kaido, but never did anything to him.

feels like Oda did the bare minimum to give payoff for the hundreds of chapters he spent building up supernova vs kaido,
 
Top