You minimised Zoro's accomplishments, I didn't say you lied. You can downplay while being factual (as I have just been doing for Luffy).
I don't think Luffy would have gotten KOed, but he was clearly unable to react and would have taken heavy damage in all 5 of those scenarios.
I agree that Luffy has had more aggro, but I'm not sure it's as big as you make it seem.
Attacks directed at the Supernova (from memory)
- Luffy
- Kaido
- Basic Club Swing
- Dodged and countered by Red Roc
- Thunder Bagua
- Partially dodged
- Basic Club Swing
- Rescued by Law
- Demolition Gust
- Dodged and countered with Kong Rifle
- Boro Breath
- Rescued by Zoro
- Boro Breath
- Withstood
- Dragon Chomp
- Large Area Attack (???)
- ???
- Mama
- Heavenly Fire
- Rescued by Zoro
- God of Lightning: Tenjin
- Immune by virtue of Devil Fruit
- Cognac
- Rescued by Zoro
- Zoro
- Kaido
- Basic Club Swing
- Countered with Rengoku Oni Giri
- Demolition Gust
- Deflected
- Large Area Attack (???)
- ???
- Mama
- God of Lightning: Tenjin
- Withstood
- Kidd
- Kaido
- Demolition Gust
- Withstood
- Vortex Wind
- ???
- Large Area Attack (???)
- ???
- Mama
- God of Lightning: Tenjin
- Withstood
- Law
- Kaido
- Demolition Gust
- Dodged
- Chomp
- Dodged
- Large Area Attack (???)
- ???
- Mama
- God of Lightning: Tenjin
- Withstood
- Killer
- Kaido
- Basic Club Swing
- Countered with Beheading Claw
- Demolition Gust
- Dodged
- Dragon Chomp
- Rescued by Luffy
- Vortex Wind
- ???
- Large Area Attack (???)
- ???
- Mama
- Indra
- Withstood
- God of Lightning: Tenjin
- Withstood
Excluding God of Lightning: Tenjin (immune due to DF ability), Luffy needed to be rescued from Mama's other attacks by Zoro. Against Kaido, he cleanly dodged two attacks, partially dodged one, was rescued for three and withstood one.
Luffy's total confirmed attacks were 10. He was rescued for half of them.
The total confirmed attacks on all Supernova (some double counting due to multi target attacks) is 25.
Luffy has taken around 40% of Yonkou attacks; a plurality, but not the majority I've seen others claiming (
@WesMidnight). And he was rescued for half of those attacks.
It's a great attack potency feat, but not a feat relevant to this battle.
Spoilers for all previous attacks (1001 & 1002) did not mention that they damaged Kaido. This may be because this attack did more damage than the others (e.g. drew significant amounts of blood), or the spoiler provider being a Zoro fan.