Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1005 Spoilers Discussion

[draganax]

He was using his flames to heal on that island he was chilling.

the he adviced the owner to make it rest for like a day.
that's not useful in a war when every second is critical.

 

[Weeman]

he didn't heal anyone, his fire just raises the body temperature enough to halt the virus spread.

His flames can help people heal wounds too, remember he was the doctor on WB's home village when Neko went to get him.

 

[Jailer]

Franky/Jinbei will establish their own tier in the crew

 

[draganax]

His flames can help people heal wounds too, remember he was the doctor on WB's home village when Neko went to get him.

it's a slow process. and requires a long resting period.

 

[Weeman]

the he adviced the owner to make it rest for like a day.
that's not useful in a war when every second is critical.

We don't know the full extent of his abilities on this regard.
He could easily have some kind of AoE healing that heavily affects his stamina or even his lifespan.

 

[Midnight Delight]

The Scabbards better die soon before Marco heals them.

Because if he does then the tensions would die even worse

 

[RayanOO]

He could easily have some kind of AoE healing that heavily affects his stamina or even his lifespan.

yeah maybe he can sacrifice himself to heal a lot of people or someone completly

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

yeah idk if nami vs ulti
franky sasaki
but robin and brook teaming up against black maria makes sense
robin should be able to handle that on her own
unless black maria is just that strong
doubtful however.

 

[draganax]

We don't know the full extent of his abilities on this regard.
He could easily have some kind of AoE healing that heavily affects his stamina or even his lifespan.

that won't be necessary, he just have to heal specific strong individuals, but it will take time.

 

[Chaves]

WW's opponent is Jinbe, Sasaki's opponent is Franky. That + Who's Who being in front of everyone else when we see them walking in chapter 977 suggests WW is stronger than Sasaki, I think.

I think that might mean that WW is slightly superior to Sasaki, but they are still at the same level, there are several times that they are put together.

But, on Fishman Island, Brook's opponent had a better portrait than Franky's opponent, so Brook facing WW is still extremely possible.

All of this can be true while still having Brook support Robin.
There aren't enough notable enemies for every SH to get a 1v1 fight. Chopper will probably play support down there against Ulti and P1, the only serious fighting i could see him doing would be something like going Monster Form against the Numbers or something.

Jinbe is already taking care of W'sW, and you have Sanji, Yamato, Drake, Hawkins, maybe Apoo and potentially Zoro all within the possibility of fighting the calamities.
So yeah Brook will probably support Robin against BM and her crew.

I completely disagree, Brook is not a support, and Oda thinks fights 2vs1 is unfair.
Sanji called for help from Robin, not Brook.
Robin is the one who attacks Black Maria, Brook only helps Sanji.
The chapter's name is the demon's daughter.
Robin vs Black Maria is as clear as day, and Brook is not interfering with that

 

[Seth]

The Scabbards better die soon before Marco heals them.

Because if he does then the tensions would die even worse

What?

Dude there is a kid running around onigashima giving plot armor candies to Gifters.

Do you actually believe Oda is a serious writer at this point?

 

[Ace]

“Don’t underestimate Nico Robin! and Brook”

Still hope Brook fights someone else

 

[Paperchampion23]

I know chopper will fight
in other words marco will be less useful if his role is simply healing everyone.

this isnt a set formula guys
the sh grand fleet members before they were grandfleet members also took down some of doffy's executives.
the strawhats dont have to be the only ones responsible.

Yes but there wasn't a set precedent for it there.

In Dressrosa:

- There was a tournament centered on gaining allies
- Half the Strawhat was split, leaving only 5 actual strawhats to fight like 10 Doflamingo Executives (4 were defeated prior of the total 14 not including Doffy (Vergo, Monet, Baby 5, Buffalo))
- Not only that, but Kyros had a dedicated plotline to eliminate one of them (he eliminated 2)
- Robin was shafted out of a fight for that reason

Wano has been very clear cut:

- Only 8 Available executives vs Doffy's 10
- The entire Strawhat crew is present
- So far, 5 of the 8 executives have exclusive Strawhat fights, even Oda is doubling up on some.
- Only Drake, Apoo and Hawkins are available outside of those tied up that aren't strawhats. If none of these 3 fight executives, then its literally up to the strawhats.
- Finally, the arc has specified the old gen being taken out by the new, which makes Marco narratively not selected to fight these characters and win, unless Oda decides to make an exception.

 

[Yere93]

Finally this pointless plot ends, we knew since the beginning that this will end like Kalifa situation thats why its bad writing from Oda, now Marco will heald Sanji and he can move to is real story in Onigashima .
Sucks not being excited for a One Piece chapter, I've been like this for weeks

 

[Paperchampion23]

is queen also too big of a fish to be taken down by a non sh?
what about jack.

marco is far too strong to not contribute in a fight.

Thats only if he's not distracted by some unknown plotline yet. We have to account for that because it can happen. Marco's role is to give the alliance a nudge, but its their battle, not his.

 

[draganax]

The Scabbards better die soon before Marco heals them.

Because if he does then the tensions would die even worse

they need to die, it's a perfect opportunity to test luffy's convictions like that moment in alabasta when he told vivi: it's a war, people die.
but i doubt that, after all he failed to take he's own advice in marine ford.

 

[Paperchampion23]

Finally this pointless plot ends, we knew since the beginning that this will end like Kalifa situation thats why its bad writing from Oda, now Marco will heald Sanji and he can move to is real story in Onigashima .
Sucks not being excited for a One Piece chapter, I've been like this for weeks

Being predictable isn't bad writing lol. Its been deathly obvious for months that Robin and/Brook were going to fight Black Maria. The moment Sanji got caught people were calling it. Thats not bad writing at all though. Go watch GoT. That has horrible writing and it was entirely unpredictable in many cases to "subvert expectations".

 

[draganax]

marco's role is to buy time and watch the skies.

 

[KiriNigiri]

Those animals with the paper mask that are cyborgs must be Queen’s creations. If so, he’s provided the Beast Pirates with a lot of resources and utility. For often he’s called the clown, the guy is brilliant. His weakness is that he plays with his food.

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

Yes but there wasn't a set precedent for it there.

In Dressrosa:

- There was a tournament centered on gaining allies
- Half the Strawhat was split, leaving only 5 actual strawhats to fight like 10 Doflamingo Executives (4 were defeated prior of the total 14 not including Doffy (Vergo, Monet, Baby 5, Buffalo))
- Not only that, but Kyros had a dedicated plotline to eliminate one of them (he eliminated 2)
- Robin was shafted out of a fight for that reason

Wano has been very clear cut:

- Only 8 Available executives vs Doffy's 10
- The entire Strawhat crew is present
- So far, 5 of the 8 executives have exclusive Strawhat fights, even Oda is doubling up on some.
- Only Drake, Apoo and Hawkins are available outside of those tied up that aren't strawhats. If none of these 3 fight executives, then its literally up to the strawhats.
- Finally, the arc has specified the old gen being taken out by the new, which makes Marco narratively not selected to fight these characters and win, unless Oda decides to make an exception.

yamato as well isnt a strawhat
in addition to Drake, Apoo and Hawkins .

"Finally, the arc has specified the old gen being taken out by the new, which makes Marco narratively not selected to fight these characters and win, unless Oda decides to make an exception"

the reason why he didnt go to the roof
lets see if that stops him from king or queen.