Current Events The roof battle is absolutely garbage so far

Is Roof Piece trash so far?


  • Total voters
    0
#84
Stop it, it has absolutely nothing to do with "reread" or it being "weekly released". People were saying the same crap regarding Dressrosa and WCI, "it's better when you reread". No! The writing itself is garbage. Rereading Dressrosa or WCI was even worse because you learn more on how bad it is after the reread it.
Most of the people who didn’t have to read Dressrosa and WCI weekly loved them exactly like most of the people here loved the pre TS arcs when they had to read them in one go.
 
Last edited:
#85
I hate the roff battle
First of all how did luffy grew that much stronger in durability in just a couple if days fighting fodders ???? He went from getting one shot by base kaido , to pretty much tanking multiple hits from hybrid kaido

you need advanced haki to hurt kaido then how could killer and zoro hurt him exactly????

kidd with all the hype that he got since his introduction is still completely useless

why are kaido and big mom standing there grinning like idiots when they could easily end the fight ?
 
#86
I mean I don’t hate this fight, it’s just kinda boring right now. It kinda reminds me of Katakuri vs Luffy. Yeah it looks amazing, but once you realize it’s just Katakuri hitting Luffy and Luffy just tanks everything I lose interest. That’s all this fight’s been, just Kaido tanking attacks over and over. Sure he screams and we see a little blood, but it doesn’t feel like any of it matters. Big Mom is also just kinda there.
 
#89
Because they cannot do that. Why it is so hard to accept?
The gap between the 2 Yonko and the 5 supernovas is not big enough for the Yonko to easily end the fight. The supernovas are that strong.

O.T: No it is not. You are just assuming how things should go and are whinnying because they do not go as you please.
LOGICALLY
I repeat LOGICALLy
They should be able to end the fight easily and quickly

again just couple of days ago g4 luffy got one shotted by base kaido

unless you think kidd law zoro killer >>>>>>>>>g4 in durability

then hybrid kaido should have zero problems one shotting everyone
And when you add big mom it should be even easier

again logically they should have no problem one shotting everyone

but luffy magically got 100 times stronger from fighting fodders and the 4 supernovas magically got stronger as well

I mean I shouldn’t be surprised
If fucking chopper damaged yc2 in his toughest forum then anything is possible

oda is losing it
 
#90
Because they cannot do that. Why it is so hard to accept?
The gap between the 2 Yonko and the 5 supernovas is not big enough for the Yonko to easily end the fight. The supernovas are that strong.

O.T: No it is not. You are just assuming how things should go and are whinnying because they do not go as you please.
Bro watch these fools go all "maaaybe Luffy is a Low Low Low top Tier BUT he needs to fight Blackbeard and Shanks simultaneously and with his hands Tied behind his back" After Oda makes everyone call Luffy a yonko.
 
#91
Bro watch these fools go all "maaaybe Luffy is a Low Low Low top Tier BUT he needs to fight Blackbeard and Shanks simultaneously and with his hands Tied behind his back" After Oda makes everyone call Luffy a yonko.
You’re the only fool here if you think luffy goes from getting one shotted by base kaido to taking multiple hits from hybrid kaido and still standing after training for a couple of days with fodders is a natural progression
 
#93
LOGICALLY
I repeat LOGICALLy
They should be able to end the fight easily and quickly

again just couple of days ago g4 luffy got one shotted by base kaido

unless you think kidd law zoro killer >>>>>>>>>g4 in durability

then hybrid kaido should have zero problems one shotting everyone
And when you add big mom it should be even easier

again logically they should have no problem one shotting everyone

but luffy magically got 100 times stronger from fighting fodders and the 4 supernovas magically got stronger as well

I mean I shouldn’t be surprised
If fucking chopper damaged yc2 in his toughest forum then anything is possible

oda is losing it
It is not « LOGICALLY » it is YOUR logic. Proof is that me and others never shared this so called « Logic ».

The whole idea that the other supernovas were vastly inferior to Luffy pre-Udon was never canon to begin with. There is no indication in the manga that people like Zoro/Kidd/Law/Killer can not block/dodge/endure a « Thunder Bagua ».

But you guys arbitrarily decided that :

-No one can grow on Luffy’s level without fighting exactly the same fights as Luffy
-Luffy is stronger than anyone, in his generation, in every stat no matter what.

Now that those were proven wrong, like many people were saying way before the beginning of the roof battle, you guys are whining that your so-called logic was, in fact, bullshit.


It is not Oda who is losing it, it is just you who were wrong. As simple as that
 
#94
The whole idea that the other supernovas were vastly inferior to Luffy pre-Udon was never canon to begin with.
Luffy (arguably the strongest supernova even in Sabaody, certainly stronger than Zoro) fought Magellan, took part in the MF war, trained with Rayleigh and defeated Doflamingo, Cracker and Katakuri, developing FS, just for fun.

Defeating Pica with Orlumbus' help and training with Mihawk or taking the hearts of 100 pirates and defeating Vergo was more than enough :usoprice:
 
#95
Luffy (arguably the strongest supernova even in Sabaody, certainly stronger than Zoro) fought Magellan, took part in the MF war, trained with Rayleigh and defeated Doflamingo, Cracker and Katakuri, developing FS, just for fun.

Defeating Pica with Orlumbus' help and training with Mihawk or taking the hearts of 100 pirates and defeating Vergo was more than enough :usoprice:
not everyone has to do the same shit ass luffy to grow stronger u candyboy
some get stronger by training like zoro :kayneshrug: apparently 2 years with mihawk was enough for zoro to be a monster he didn t need all those fights luffy had :milaugh:
 
#98
I would not say it is garbage but the subplot pacing of that battle is really atrocious which makes it look like nothing significant is happening.
The supernova are on the roof since chapter 1000 and yet no side has taken any critical hit,injuries etc..
Instead we get the emperors not attacking with all their might,just taking hits left and right and smiling like retards.

All of the above leads to lack of tension and a feeling that the battle is boring as many things there look like filler.

In conclusion,this battle looks more like a sparring match than a death battle.
 
Last edited:
#99
It is not « LOGICALLY » it is YOUR logic. Proof is that me and others never shared this so called « Logic ».

The whole idea that the other supernovas were vastly inferior to Luffy pre-Udon was never canon to begin with. There is no indication in the manga that people like Zoro/Kidd/Law/Killer can not block/dodge/endure a « Thunder Bagua ».

But you guys arbitrarily decided that :

-No one can grow on Luffy’s level without fighting exactly the same fights as Luffy
-Luffy is stronger than anyone, in his generation, in every stat no matter what.

Now that those were proven wrong, like many people were saying way before the beginning of the roof battle, you guys are whining that your so-called logic was, in fact, bullshit.


It is not Oda who is losing it, it is just you who were wrong. As simple as that
The only thing you proved is that you’re into oda’s ass too deep you can’t even see clearly anymore
 
Top