I don't understand the Mama hate TBH. It took 4 Supernova working together to BFR her. Kaido wouldn't have done any better if he had her powers. She was removed because they neutralised her three homies and she can't fly. There's no shame getting beaten like that.
Hold back an Emperor? Where do you place Base Kaido? I have him as a mid top tier.
A fresh Rooftop Zoro can probably contend with Base Kaido for a while.
He's just sexist.
It's by design a ranged attack. This would be like talking about wanking a direct hit from 1080 Pound Cannon, when the attack is intrinsically a flying slash.
There's no such thing as a direct hit from Hakai, as the attack itself is the flying slash it creates.
Zoro has:
- The offensive prowess to damage top tiers
- Hiryuu Kaen terrified the Yonkou and compelled Mama to warn Kaido to dodge.
- Zoro can severely injure the most durable top tier.
- Kokujo Ou Tatsumaki completely overwhelmed Kaido's Tatsumaki and cut him up.
- Zoro can overwhelm a named attack from a top tier
- This was Dragon Kaido's most potent attack
- The defensive prowess to block top tier attacks
- Blocking Hakai however momentarily
- The endurance to withstand attacks from top tiers
- Indra
- God of Lightning: Tenjin
- Several off panel attacks from Kaido and Meme
- He endured Hakai for a bit
- The reactions to engage top tiers in CQC.
- Intercepted Heavenly Fire
- Deflected Demolition Gust
- Intercepted Boro Breath
- Dodge Motherly Fire while carrying Luffy
- Dodged Tatsumaki: Gale of Destruction while carrying Luffy
- Intercepted Hakai
The only reason Zoro can't beat an Admiral/Yonkou by himself is that his stamina doesn't last long enough (he's pretty winded after fighting for at most a few hours, compared to top tiers who can go for 10 days).
Again, I don't see how Zoro is not a low top tier at this point. Especially if you consider Luffy one.