General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
Pretty sweet of Yamato to be challenging an Emperor for Luffy’s sake in light of Luffy giving her freedom. Even several of Big Mom’s children were intimidated by Big Mom, but Yamato doesn’t seem to be intimidated by Kaido at all here. It definitely has the makings of a strong friendship that could potentially develop between her and Luffy if it isn’t developing already.
Maybe I was late, but how is Luffy going to deal with the fact that Yamato read Oden's diary and everything that was written about the secret of the one piece, the secret of the D's and lost century?
Yamato even knows that Luffy is the man who would arrive 20 years later to take down Kaido. Yamato in the crew is like a dull shortcut, in which Luffy has already shown immense disinterest, to the point of saying that he would give up being a pirate if anyone in the crew knew anything
Yamato joining seems like a reasonable end to her plotline with her father, with her leaving with the Straw Hats. Perhaps after her clash with her father and after Luffy's taken over that fight, she'll get a chance to interact with the other Straw Hats.
As irrelevant as Carrot has been in Wano, I don't think she's done. Unless Pedro comes back from the dead, Carrot's probably gonna get up since she talked about how his sacrifice will be significant in this war and I don't see her actually giving up after contemplating on Pedro's advice even after Perospero's harsh criticism of her immature mindset, not fitting of a pirate. We'll see, her joining might not happen even if she gets back up but I like her sulong form and her interaction with some of the crew, notably Sanji (that time regarding Pedro and his sacrifice) so I'd enjoy seeing her join the crew.
Vivi's the character I'd love to see join the most. She was more interesting to me and her interactions with the crew were really enjoyable but even if she doesn't join, it's fine.
As irrelevant as Carrot has been in Wano, I don't think she's done. Unless Pedro comes back from the dead, Carrot's probably gonna get up since she talked about how his sacrifice will be significant in this war and I don't see her actually giving up after contemplating on Pedro's advice even after Perospero's harsh criticism of her immature mindset, not fitting of a pirate. We'll see, her joining might not happen even if she gets back up but I like her sulong form and her interaction with some of the crew, notably Sanji (that time regarding Pedro and his sacrifice) so I'd enjoy seeing her join the crew.
Vivi's the character I'd love to see join the most. She was more interesting to me and her interactions with the crew were really enjoyable but even if she doesn't join, it's fine.
Last edited:
Lookout is a valid duty on ship
Theyre the eye of the crew. They understand the general situation around the ship
There a 2 mast on sunny. Surely usopp can be on one of them, aiming, concentrating, and sniping when the situation demand him to be marksman. while lookout should deliver the information to the navigator, helmsman, marksman, combatant, or maybe cannoner/artilleryman if we have one
a good lookout can go scouting or stealthing when not on the ship. On the ship, he/she could cover more hour for the night watch than other crew
Theyre the eye of the crew. They understand the general situation around the ship
There a 2 mast on sunny. Surely usopp can be on one of them, aiming, concentrating, and sniping when the situation demand him to be marksman. while lookout should deliver the information to the navigator, helmsman, marksman, combatant, or maybe cannoner/artilleryman if we have one
a good lookout can go scouting or stealthing when not on the ship. On the ship, he/she could cover more hour for the night watch than other crew
According to all Yamato fans, she didn't read the most important parts. She just skipped them for the purpose of joining Luffy.
it’s illogical for Oden, a Poneglyph writer & reader, to put many very important informations in just scrap of papers (ie: One Piece, Laugh Tale, will of D, void century, etc) with normal language (I suggest normal language since Yamato & Momo can read it; unless Yamato & Momo are poneglyph readers too) where everybody will be looking for it for their own personal purpose.
The reasons it’s impossible to write things like Will of D, Laugh Tale, Void Century, etc. are:
1. it can be destroyed easily. CP0 would have chased Yamato, probably ambush her & take the journal to destroy it / to take it to World Govt for their own purpose. It’s good if it’s destroyed, hence further makes Yamato’s chance to be on crew pretty much higher. Luffy could’ve just asked Yamato not to mention anything about Laugh Tale, etc. although I highly doubt if it ever mentioned anything about Laugh Tale, etc. but if it does and it’s being taken to World Govt, that’s very dangerous. World Govt could take it, get the information about Laugh Tale, and destroy it.
2. It does include information like Joy Boy; hence suggesting why Kaido & Yamato knows about Luffy being a Joy Boy while so far, only Robin knows about Joy Boy. Kaido may have already read that journal also; hence his knowledge of Joy Boy. But I think the important message is only that (or maybe more), but would NEVER include other very important informations, as if it would, Kaido would have been aiming for Laugh Tale ages ago. It would also destroy the purpose of Kaido having Road Poneglyph. He would have just taken Oden’s journal and go straight to Laugh Tale. And thus this point emphasizes point 3.
3. If it did contain Laugh Tale, One Piece, etc. it would have destroyed the purpose of Poneglyph. Back again; Oden is a Poneglyph writer & reader. Robin is currently the only person who can read & translate Poneglyph; hence great pirates are all looking for her.
so the biggest question is: why Oden, a Poneglyph writer & reader, would want to put very important things like Laugh Tale, One Piece, etc. in scrap of papers with normal language where it can be destroyed / it can fall into wrong hands?
hope my explanation helps
Last edited:
It's so funny how people are so convinced to death that Oden's diary/journal is equivalent to reaching One Piece... 
Since Yamato read it, she's the Pirate King now, eh?
As if...
Since Yamato read it, she's the Pirate King now, eh?
As if...
Post automatically merged:
Just had a thought that the journal might have been brought in to make people second guess if Yamato will really join. I suppose it’s similar to Luffy a whole bunch of the zombies to join he crew at Thriller Bark to make people second guess if Brook would join by the end.
Last edited:
- Status