Status
Not open for further replies.

Lindltaylor

There's no "Tina!"
What do you think of Juliet so far?
Isoing Juliet, she seems town for now just going off of tone. I mean this is a very slight lean, but her take on Mango's tunnel of Zara comes from another game where Mango tunneled on Juliet as well. It's a reasonable suspicion imo.

Wait so I'm slow, do we think there's a cult + mafia or is it more likely to be an either or situation given there's only twenty players?
Not really sure, but from Fuji's recent post and my wiki skim, I think there's a cultafia + indie serial here.
 
Wait so I'm slow, do we think there's a cult + mafia or is it more likely to be an either or situation given there's only twenty players?
I feel like this is going in circles, all we know is that there is a culting mechanic and thats that.

20 players should have 5 scum in it and thats pretty much it.

Id like to move on from mechanical talk to be fair.

Mango imo is acting in too much of an insane way for me to think hes scum atm. Every game he was scum he would he more cautious. But i dont know , i didnt like his blatant role fishing for @Juliet ’s role and the same can be said about Light who seemed to be trying to know if @Zara knows Mangos role and how he does it.


Moving on to the miller claims, i say the best way to deal with them is have them checked at night(not copped) and to focus on the people that just wanted to keep the conversation stuck on those claims.

Off the top of my head i remember @krogothwolf doing that.

Oh i forgot @Lindltaylor I saw you mention that i had no reason to speak of my PR but tbh i did have a good reason and its a really imporant one to me :
I was bummed out :josad:
, seriously tho its because at some point during the day i would stop posting or you guys would notice i was posting less so its best to just tell it to y’all.

I feel trolled by the hosts rn :catcry:
 

Lindltaylor

There's no "Tina!"
What do you guys think of the newbies so far, i.e: Dr and Conquistador?
Conquistador seems goo from his posts. I would lean town on him for now. His post about Rej reading him guilty looked too genuine imo.

Dr_Prof - His questions and posts so far seem similar to the last game he played. So he could be town, but still too soon to judge. I'm null on him.
 

Lindltaylor

There's no "Tina!"
I feel like this is going in circles, all we know is that there is a culting mechanic and thats that.

20 players should have 5 scum in it and thats pretty much it.

Id like to move on from mechanical talk to be fair.

Mango imo is acting in too much of an insane way for me to think hes scum atm. Every game he was scum he would he more cautious. But i dont know , i didnt like his blatant role fishing for @Juliet ’s role and the same can be said about Light who seemed to be trying to know if @Zara knows Mangos role and how he does it.


Moving on to the miller claims, i say the best way to deal with them is have them checked at night(not copped) and to focus on the people that just wanted to keep the conversation stuck on those claims.

Off the top of my head i remember @krogothwolf doing that.

Oh i forgot @Lindltaylor I saw you mention that i had no reason to speak of my PR but tbh i did have a good reason and its a really imporant one to me :
I was bummed out :josad:
, seriously tho its because at some point during the day i would stop posting or you guys would notice i was posting less so its best to just tell it to y’all.

I feel trolled by the hosts rn :catcry:
To everyone else who can't focus on the game 24/7, you being limited to 50 posts is a blessing :finally:

Don't worry, Oni, we will have fun in your place for you :endthis:
 
Null on Doc.

Actually think Conq handled the fake guilty result well enough, and he seemed to be genuine when he answered that hes Town Miller then. Though you would think he read his role lmao.

So townie points for that.
For sure. I purposely didn't point out the fact that it was fake to see how he would react, and he passed with flying colors, especially for someone who's brand new if I take his word for it. Seemed like he genuinely thought he could be miller lol.
 
[QUOTE="Fruitji, post: 1709165, member: 1331"Yes and The 6 he made are entirely useless.
1 of which he asked someone else to sheep him and just somehow trusts Conquistador.

I think it warrants a push for a reaction at the very least.

I asked because i was wondering if anybody saw what i saw, and im sorry but at this point in the game you gotta start somewhere and pressure somebody.

But oh please guide “misguided” Ol me![/QUOTE]
That's fine if you want to do that, but I think this early in the game, with a 48-hour day phase, we need to either assess people that have been a bit more present, or be a bit more patient and wait for others to post more. I think we've gotten a good look at what Town Cal looks like, so I'm willing to give him some time here considering what happened to him last game.

I wasn't really calling you misguided, unless you're sussing Cal because he asked Conquist to sheep him. I think the idea of sussing Cal for that is misguided.
 
Oh my god! I sent by mistake.. well this was a waste of a post.

@Melontonin can we claim actions or is that not recommended either?

Yes and The 6 he made are entirely useless.
1 of which he asked someone else to sheep him and just somehow trusts Conquistador.

I think it warrants a push for a reaction at the very least.

I can attest, but i know you cant lie to me so are you town ? :catblush:



If Cal is scum then he would want people to sheep him either way, i dont know what Conquistador is and neither should he. But the way he talked to him pinged me a bit, it felt like maybe he knew Conq was town isomething.

Thats the point for me.



I asked because i was wondering if anybody saw what i saw, and im sorry but at this point in the game you gotta start somewhere and pressure somebody.

But oh please guide “misguided” Ol me!
That's fine if you want to do that, but I think this early in the game, with a 48-hour day phase, we need to either assess people that have been a bit more present, or be a bit more patient and wait for others to post more. I think we've gotten a good look at what Town Cal looks like, so I'm willing to give him some time here considering what happened to him last game.

I wasn't really calling you misguided, unless you're sussing Cal because he asked Conquist to sheep him. I think the idea of sussing Cal for that is misguided.

TRY #2
 
What do you guys think of the newbies so far, i.e: Dr and Conquistador?
Prof is a bit laid back compared to his roaring debut. I'll wait for him to start posting a bit more before I rush to any decisions.

Conquist I think is obvious Town by the way he legitimately thought Rej has a guilty check on him and how he thought that meant he was a Miller.
 
Conquistador seems goo from his posts. I would lean town on him for now. His post about Rej reading him guilty looked too genuine imo.

Dr_Prof - His questions and posts so far seem similar to the last game he played. So he could be town, but still too soon to judge. I'm null on him.
This was too mind meldy of an answer for me.
 
Prof is a bit laid back compared to his roaring debut. I'll wait for him to start posting a bit more before I rush to any decisions.
I’ll be posting a lot more actively as these phases progress. I don’t really love this 48 hour D1 stuff tbh, I feel like there’s barely anything to go on before we start seeing WU’s and flips so we can analyze pushes and defenses people make. Makes it pretty hard to scum hunt for me.

I’m already miles ahead of where I was on last games D1 though.
 
D1 really feels like a taking in minor information phase so that we can see if any of it looks bigger on D2 in hindsight. Is there a benefit to it lasting 48 hours?
 
I’ll be posting a lot more actively as these phases progress. I don’t really love this 48 hour D1 stuff tbh, I feel like there’s barely anything to go on before we start seeing WU’s and flips so we can analyze pushes and defenses people make. Makes it pretty hard to scum hunt for me.

I’m already miles ahead of where I was on last games D1 though.
Whoah chile. Are you sure you're new? LOL.

D1 really feels like a taking in minor information phase so that we can see if any of it looks bigger on D2 in hindsight. Is there a benefit to it lasting 48 hours?
It gives more time for anyone who may be busy to have a chance to participate, giving equal ground and time to post/contribute for all involved. That's how I think of it benefit-wise anyways.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top