General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Logiko]

Her having a good lifestyle and having major event that we don’t know the history between two characters doesn’t make her a strawhat at all. She didn’t even experience hardship several years desperately looking for friends to accept her and she didn’t even struggle. She had wonderful and peaceful life in zou and she was well respect individual until jack arrived.
But all of carrot personal trauma has already been dealt by with other characters. So, there isn't really any motivation for her to continue on further with the strawhats Not to mention that since the strawhats are taking their first yonko it wouldn’t feel rewarded because she hadn’t done anything to earn it. Plus, she doesn't talk about anything regarding her own backstory that could lead to other arc or the dawn pedro spoke of. Ussop when we are entering ongishima took over her role being look out. Her fight was completely skip over handed it over by someone else. IF you took carrot out of arc it wouldn't change anything at all. Robin might be side character in that arc she at least in important character later in the story. Without her involvement we wouldn't finding clues for laughtale and in alabasta vivi might be dead. The bomb would explode kill everyone including the strawhats.



(6) Usopp Attack the Onigashima's Guard | Usopp's Sniper Skill | One Piece Episode 983 - YouTube

A strawhat is only a strawhat when they are officialized not before. Carrot personnal trauma has yet to be dealt with. Carrot got slapped in the face by reality who basically said to her : "you are not worthy if you think you have nothing to lose"

The logical following will be to assess this reality slap in any fashion whatoweher.

And wrong, it would change a lot.

As for a motivation, I'll repeat that here :

If you say to a kid, 15 minutes in at a funfair, that he has to "go back home".. what do you think the kid will do if he has the choice to go for another ride ?

And to remind you who the kid is:

 

[BOCCHI]

Let’s be honest mate, the SHs doesn’t need another member joining the weak trio. Especially one with a PU that depends on circumstances and we are near the end there isn’t enough time to have her much powerful in a short period… But Yamato by far is more suitable when it comes to power level within the crew.

 

[Staticshadic]

A strawhat is only a strawhat when they are officialized not before. Carrot personnal trauma has yet to be dealt with. Carrot got slapped in the face by reality who basically said to her : "you are not worthy if you think you have nothing to lose"

The logical following will be to assess this reality slap in any fashion whatoweher.

And wrong, it would change a lot.

As for a motivation, I'll repeat that here :

If you say to a kid, 15 minutes in at a funfair, that he has to "go back home".. what do you think the kid will do if he has the choice to go for another ride ?

Who are the 3 characters who had personally effect carrot? Jack,Perospero, and Kanjoura . Who back her up against the person who said to her "go back home"?. None of the strawhat came to her in that situation. It was kinemon, Cat viper and dog storm that dealt with carrot personal trauma. If carrot wasn't involved it wouldn't change anything. Carrot4nakama it seems like you would rather want paulie or Rebecca join the crew.

 

[Uncle Van]

I’d be surprised if Devon vs Yamato doesn’t happen.

Mythical Dog Zoan vs Mythical Dog Zoan
Girl with identity issues vs girl who can transform into anyone
Fire vs ice potentially

Nami will fight Lafitte because they’re both navigators, and he was a corrupt cop while she was a noble burglar. Robin will fight San Juan Wolf, who I think will have a connection to Tequila Wolf

A Sheriff to be specific. Laiffte was exiled for being too cruel. He also has wings, likes to tap dance and uses hypnosis, giving him a Siren vibe. Brooke seems like a more fitting opponent to me.

Don't know about Robin vs San Juan either. San is known as the "Great Battleship."

 

[BOCCHI]

Sheriff to be specific. Laiffte was exiled for being too cruel. He also has wings, likes to tap dance and uses hypnosis, giving him a Siren vibe. Brooke seems like a more fitting opponent to me.

I have always being on board of this match up since the beginning yet see people annoyingly claim Laiffte to high regard and match him up with Sanji lol.

 

[Uncle Van]

I have always being on board of this match up since the beginning yet see people annoyingly claim Laiffte to high regard and match him up with Sanji lol.

Honestly never seen anyone pit Sanji against Lafitte lol. They probably push Lafiite so high he one of the original 4 BB members. I've said it earlier, but recruitment order isnt based on power levels just like SHs.

 

[Adamxero]

Daily reminder people Larrot got her ass handed to her by the eldest son of the Big Mom pirates Werospero the mink slayer

Larrot at this stage will be glad to watch Ussops feats during Wano

 

[Finalbeta]

Daily reminder people Larrot got her ass handed to her by the eldest son of the Big Mom pirates Werospero the mink slayer

Larrot at this stage will be glad to watch Ussops feats during Wano

That picture is a bit cringy.

 

[Sigran101]

Your answer to every point you can't refute against Carrot is "misdirection". Why is Yamato the one getting flashbacks and focus instead of Carrot? "Misdirection". Why did Oda have Yamato ask to join the crew? "Misdirection". Why did Oda highlight Ussop as the lookout if that's Carrot's role? "Misdirection".

At a certain point "misdirection" stops being a legitimate argument because you can say it about anything that doesn't support your agenda. If you have to resort to "misdirection" for this many things, you're just being intellectually dishonest to claim that Carrot has the better case.

Post automatically merged: Oct 14, 2021

Missdirection

Post automatically merged: Oct 13, 2021

Of course it's strange, but I guess, he had the choice between showing Carrot with the group and outside of the group. We must also notice how Usopp has hard time going to the post, that, just behind Carrot who has no problem..

in any way.. wether it be Yamato or Carrot. Oda made odd choices to missdirect the fans.

 

[Karma]

Honestly never seen anyone pit Sanji against Lafitte lol. They probably push Lafiite so high he one of the original 4 BB members. I've said it earlier, but recruitment order isnt based on power levels just like SHs.

Hes the chef of staff, which is a similar position to FM/VC. Sabo also holds this position.

Tho i agree it doesnt mean much lol. The ppl who push this argument also believe Shiryu is gonna be Zoro's opponent.

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

Why are you guys debating with @CarrotForNakama

For them to feel what I felt back then lmao. Even Arlong Park forum banned him not even a week after his joining, and he became a laughing stock for the rest of people there after he got banned.


Anyway I don’t know why “look-out” is an extremely important & interesting job, that it keeps being pushed as the argument as Carrot’s strongest possibility to join. 5-6 years since her debut, CMIIW I don’t remember Oda mentioned anything about her role being specifically as a look-out in any Vivre Card Book.

and I’m also here laughing my ass off that “Robin is a side character”. Dunno, but for someone who said multiple times that he’s an analyst, maybe he should open a youtube channel like Yuderon, Ohara, JoyBoy, etc. but specially for Carrot. I’m honestly curious to see other people’s reaction

 

[thedarkdragon11]

Of course it's strange, but I guess, he had the choice between showing Carrot with the group and outside of the group. We must also notice how Usopp has hard time going to the post, that, just behind Carrot who has no problem..

Usopp having a hard time? Carrot has no problem? Seriously?

Let’s be honest mate, the SHs doesn’t need another member joining the weak trio. Especially one with a PU that depends on circumstances and we are near the end there isn’t enough time to have her much powerful in a short period… But Yamato by far is more suitable when it comes to power level within the crew.

Exactly this... Like Jinbe, Yamato doesn't need an insane PU in order to keep up and not make the narrative sh*tty... And since the crew entered the Grand Line, it has been very consistent with the quality of the recruits being on the same level or better (never got worse or downgraded) as the level of villains also gets better...

Who are the 3 characters who had personal effect carrot? Jack,Perospero, and Kanjoura . Who back her up against the person who said to her "go back home"?. None of the strawhat came to her in that situation. It was kinemon, Cat viper and dog storm that dealt with carrot personal trauma. If carrot wasn't involved it wouldn't change anything. Carrot4nakama it seems like you would rather paulie or Rebecca join the crew.

Imagine someone abandoning/not returning the favor to those who directly helped you on your revenge course in favor of those who doesn't even care...

 

[KINGKONGGUN15]

Yamato vs san juan is more likely I think

 

[vikas]

Carrot joins BBPs, and we see Carrot vs Yamato

 

[thedarkdragon11]

Carrot joins BBPs, and we see Carrot vs Yamato

Carrot fits BBP since she's corrupt (bribed Bariete) and selfish...

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

Carrot fits BBP since she's corrupt (bribed Bariete) and selfish...

this could fit with the theme “don’t judge a book by its cover.” WG should be the good guys, yet they’re corrupted & dark. Straw Hats should be the bad guys, but what they’ve done so far are being the good guys.

Yamato is an oni race, and daughter of Kaido. She should be bad, but turns out she’s good and trying to prove that she can do good. Carrot is a rabbit mink, she looks good & should be good, only to be corrupted when she finally realizes that the seas & outer world are not as wonderful as she thought they would.

there is also no mink representative within BBP.

 

[thedarkdragon11]

Carrot and Stronger would be great friends... They can eat grass together...

 

[Logiko]

Let’s be honest mate, the SHs doesn’t need another member joining the weak trio. Especially one with a PU that depends on circumstances and we are near the end there isn’t enough time to have her much powerful in a short period… But Yamato by far is more suitable when it comes to power level within the crew.

But guys Carrot is not for the weak trio but the mid. She is strong as hell, do I need to remind you of her feets?

Yamato is Commander level easy.. I think Yamato is just too powerful

Daily reminder people Larrot got her ass handed to her by the eldest son of the Big Mom pirates Werospero the mink slayer

Larrot at this stage will be glad to watch Ussops feats during Wano

oh you are the meme lord.. oh yes you are ! Good meme lord !

For them to feel what I felt back then lmao. Even Arlong Park forum banned him not even a week after his joining, and he became a laughing stock for the rest of people there after he got banned.


Anyway I don’t know why “look-out” is an extremely important & interesting job, that it keeps being pushed as the argument as Carrot’s strongest possibility to join. 5-6 years since her debut, CMIIW I don’t remember Oda mentioned anything about her role being specifically as a look-out in any Vivre Card Book.

and I’m also here laughing my ass off that “Robin is a side character”. Dunno, but for someone who said multiple times that he’s an analyst, maybe he should open a youtube channel like Yuderon, Ohara, JoyBoy, etc. but specially for Carrot. I’m honestly curious to see other people’s reaction

Actually they didn't understand why I got banned lol they were not having fun

Look out is an important job because it saved the strawhat in whole cake, without this post, they wouldn't have survived. Of course if Oda was to confirmed the post, Carrot would be confirmed as well, this would not be fun. That's why you have to look at the story.

And yes, Robin was a side character in alabasta, only a fool would deny that.

Usopp having a hard time? Carrot has no problem? Seriously?

Yes

 

[vikas]

do I need to remind you of her feets?

I am not into furry's

 

[thedarkdragon11]

But guys Carrot is not for the weak trio but the mid. She is strong as hell, do I need to remind you of her feets?

Yamato is Commander level easy.. I think Yamato is just too powerful

For a New World recruit?
Mid tier
Commander tier

The SHs are taking on the Yonkos (next would be the DF hunters/powerful guys scouts BBP, then the most balanced crew and potential Haki masters RHP) and an inevitable clash against the Marine HQ and even the entire armed forces of the WG is coming... Then you still prefer a major downgrade to Jinbe and a someone is still "too powerful"? "Too powerful" is exactly what the SHs lack and need...

The grass eater isn't even a mid tier... Take note that Chopper did better against Queen and Peros than Carrot and Wanda in Sulong did against Peros...