I was following this game from the first day as there was nothing else to lurk on this forum. I will give an outside viewpoint which might help you guys...
@Noctis played really well
But I can't say the same for townies with exception of
@playa4321 who played well.
@TheAncientCenturion you once again left no stone unturned in projecting yourself as Mafia. You have the potential to play better but you don't. Your stupid acts distract townie planning which you don't realize
@Bogard you were the best bet for townie but you threw the game away.
But more than bogard throwing himself under the bus what shocked me was his mislynch.. townie failed to see that ted actually tried to put a vote on him to save himself which literally puts bogard a confirmed townie yet you guys lynched him...it was really disappointing and to me game ended that istant itself. But playa proved me wrong by playing really well. However, playa like most Townie made a mistake which I will explain below.
Another mistake you guys made was that once it was revealed that game didn't end after Gambit lynch, you guys didn't think even for a second about the possibility of a serial killer and continued to see noctis as townie.( Yup! Noctis literally laid down clues as clear as day light indicating that he is scum. I Know this because I figured him out. Will not say what mistakes he made).
In my opinion, The reason you guys didn't read him well is because you guys don't re read threads again and again as game progresses. You guys need to focus not only on vote pattern but when someone casted vote, how a player is playing (like defensive or opportunistic or diplomatic or aggressive) , what kind of post a player is making and then reach to the conclusion which keeps on changing as we re read threads as game progresses..
Also, the activity in this game was not much except for one day phase which isn't good for townie for example
@Kiwipom not being much active.
Anyway,it was nice seeing you guys play. It was fun. Adios.....