For other first impressions:
Misty looks Town-ish, Adam as well. I don't think scum would buddy like that and Adam has his unusual ideas like putting 10 new players on the council which he usually does as Town. Both can fake plays, though, so I'm not firm on either yet.
Noctis seems fine so far, too. Him stating that he is not so lucky to roll scum is kinda...genuine?
I trust Kvothe for now. Suspecting my partner won't do any good and I know more soon enough anyway.
Generally I don't have a firm stance on anyone yet, but guess D1 makes things a lot clearer.
Never lose hope!