Nah... if you think characters in One Piece are interchangeable, I suggest you learn a bit about the importance of characterization in a story.
Still doesn’t change the fact that if Wanda was the one who tagged along, Oda could give to Wanda what he gave to Carrot
I'm not saying that wanda would do nothing, I said that the story was completely different, what you guyz argued would not happen.
It would. You’re just coping and crying here
You don't remember Carrot's impact because you have a grudge on the character, his fan and a complete bias over her impact on the story. Nothing less.
It needs bare minimum of logic to know that if Carrot’s impact doesn’t affect the whole story, then she’s not relevant. There is nothing to debate here
The problem is that you read half the posts so it's logical that you don't understand what we are talking about and you are shooting the words "moving goalpost" like crazy...
The point of this discussion is to compare Robin and Carrot's relevance before she JOINED to see if Carrot is relevant enough to be accepted as a simple joiner. It's not about the relevancy of the character after that and before they are recruited/accepted as a true strawhat. If that was the case, this wouldn't be a fair comparizon.
Read before you comment please.
LMAO you better be joking. You were the one who said that Robin
officially recruited after Water 7, so it means I can give examples of Robin’s relevance before she officially joined (or as you said, simple joiner), which is as you said that she was officially recruited in Water 7. So that means I can give Robin’s relevance to the whole story from before Alabasta arc until Water 7 arc.
And who was talking about Robin’s relevancy
after that and before she was accepted as a true strawhat? There, I bolded them so you can
read before you comment.
And here’s the thing for your little brain (I doubt if you have any) to comprehend:
Even as a simple “joiner”, Robin’s relevance to the whole story is clear, and it was revealed
before she joined post Alabasta. You can show 11 or even 20 whatchamacallit as Carrot’s big moments, but
even their big moments can’t compare to Robin’s relevance.
Robin has 2 points of relevance enough for the whole One Piece story,
before she was a simple joiner (as you said):
1. She saved Luffy, questioning the act of the ones with “D” in the name. This act of questioning the act of the ones with “D” has a huge impact for the whole story of One Piece. It happened in Alabasta
before Robin appears a simple joiner
2. It was also revealed later that Robin is a Poneglyph reader, only at the same chapter again that Poneglyph is one of the very important items in One Piece world. It also happened
before Robin appears a simple joiner
If you truly are an analyst and have been analyzing One Piece for your whole life, you know both points appeared
before Robin joined post Alabasta, not after that nor that after she was accepted as a true Straw Hat. I have to emphasize them again and again because I know you have terrible english comprehension.
Even as, what you say, a simple joiner, those 2 points of Robin proved that she has huge relevance to the whole One Piece story. 2 points of Robin literally stomps Carrot’s 11 or so big moments you said. It’s clear that even before this reply I gave example of Robin’s relevance
before she joined, even right during Alabasta arc.
Carrot doesn’t have the level of relevance Robin has to the whole story for Carrot to join. There is nothing to debate here.
And if you know it’s not a fair comparison why did you compare them to begin with? You better be joking. Trust me, you will deny your own words again for I don’t know how many times.
Read before you comment please.
