General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
Carrot doesn't have any and Yamato has more narration than carrot so dont go too far okay let's not get ahead of yourself 🤣ðŸ˜.the only thing carrot has over Yamato is just because she is friends with the crew(except for luffy)
So this is the next narration u going to use now? 🙃
Post automatically merged:
So this is the next narration u going to use now? 🙃
Remember u said that the anime is none canon so carrot doesn't have a purpose or dream because she hasn't talked about the so-called “ WILL OF PEDRO" in the manga since WCI when Pedro believe luffy is going to be the dawn for the mink in wano just she goes forward just to be part of the raid just like a side character meanwhile Yamato purpose is to fight on the side of wano for opening with momo kinemon and the other, and luffy and his crew to help momo. Also one of her dreams is to see the world, hmm looking at carrot and Yamato we see who have more than another one ðŸ¤, also see who ODA making us pay attention to in this “IMPORTANT ARC THE FIRST BIGGEST CHANGE IN THE ONE PIECE WORLD AFTER YONKO IS ABOUT TO LOSE TO LUFFY AND HIS CREW ALSO THE FREEDOM OF WANO" AND LIKE WHAT ZORO AND SANJI SAY “WHEN WE WIN THIS BATTLE ITS GOING TO BE A STEP IN LUFFY DREAM TO BE A THE KING PIRATE"
If it was special she would be as strong as Pedro or even Nekomamushi which she's not..
Children Mink are born warriors, it's not impressive that some of them can do Sulong at their teens..
Yes really..
" That cat's flying!! "
Maybe you shouldn't read only the Carrot parts
We do, considering they always ruled with one rulers or any kingdoms for that matter..
Easy answer Wanda is Carrots caretaker and she's Inuarashi's daughter that's why Carrot got it too because of Wanda..
Again Carrot is not special...
Children Mink are born warriors, it's not impressive that some of them can do Sulong at their teens..
Yes really..
" That cat's flying!! "
Maybe you shouldn't read only the Carrot parts
We do, considering they always ruled with one rulers or any kingdoms for that matter..
Easy answer Wanda is Carrots caretaker and she's Inuarashi's daughter that's why Carrot got it too because of Wanda..
Again Carrot is not special...
If it was special she would be as strong as Pedro or even Nekomamushi which she's not..
Children Mink are born warriors, it's not impressive that some of them can do Sulong at their teens..
Yes really..
" That cat's flying!! "
Maybe you shouldn't read only the Carrot parts
We do, considering they always ruled with one rulers or any kingdoms for that matter..
Easy answer Wanda is Carrots caretaker and she's Inuarashi's daughter that's why Carrot got it too because of Wanda..
Again Carrot is not special...
Children Mink are born warriors, it's not impressive that some of them can do Sulong at their teens..
Yes really..
" That cat's flying!! "
Maybe you shouldn't read only the Carrot parts
We do, considering they always ruled with one rulers or any kingdoms for that matter..
Easy answer Wanda is Carrots caretaker and she's Inuarashi's daughter that's why Carrot got it too because of Wanda..
Again Carrot is not special...
The coming of the Dawn seems to be shared by the Kozuki faction and Mink Tribe so it really isn't a unique dream. This Wano battle seems to be the big push for the Dawn to happen or start.
Dreams and Wills are personal. Pedro wanted to ride with Roger who became the Pirate King. If we are to believe Pedro thinks the same of Luffy, then part of his Will is to ride on the Sunny. Knowing how long Pedro waited for that moment yet would sacrifice his chance so that Luffy can accomplish his dream is remarkable. For Carrot or whomever to inherit that Will, a more in-depth interaction between them displaying and explaining what is being inherited gives us the readers an understanding of its importance to both characters.
However, we only see a short flashback showing that Pedro knew Carrot was a fist fighter not a swordsman. And that shining moments are possible for Carrot. Nothing about the Dawn. Nothing about Pedro's core beliefs, past journeys, or dreams. The personableness is lacking between them IMO. I surmise that Pedro has not been completely forthright on his exact Will or Dream. As a fan, I would like that to be explored.
It's a good question. What else do the Strawhats need as a crew?
Taken officially and debatably:
Captain
First Mate/Combatant
Navigator/Merchant
Sniper/Gunner
Cook
Doctor/Pet
Archeologist/Assassin
Shipwright/Boatswain/Cooper
Musician
Helmsman/Lifeguard/Fireguard
Open for Debate:
Blacksmith: Usopp and Franky seem to share this role and do it well. Not likely someone joins to fill this role unless a Swordsmith is necessary or someone surpasses both their skills. Candidate is Vegapunk though Scientist fits better.
Tailor: Nami has shown some skill stitching Luffy's strawhat. It would be a useful role to fix the sails and ropes but not likely as the best for this role IMO is Strawhat Commander of the 5th division Leo. Candidate is Kin'emon thanks to his DF ninjutsu.
Chronicler: Nami, Usopp, and Robin all have been shown noting information throughout the journey. If a Chronicler were to join it would need to be someone organized and persistent in chronicling everything. Not likely IMO. Candidate is Yamato.
Lookout: Most if not all Strawhats have been shown being a lookout on a ship and/or looking through binoculars. It's quite peculiar actually that no one has been introduced as a lookout nor any Strawhat consistently taken the role. So I'm under the impression if a new crewmate is the "lookout" their position will not be introduced as so. Qualification Wall: Viola. Candidates are Vivi, Carrot, and Pedro.
Apprentice: IMO someone who is comparable to past apprentices in strength/capabilities and age. After all they have to hold their own in the New World. Usopp, Nami, and Chopper are big enough liabilities. 2 Emperors, an Emperor's Right Hand, 2 Mink Kings, and a former Warlord have been introduced as so. Big shoes to fill. Candidates are Yamato, Carrot, and Tama.
Shipguard: Strangely introduced back in East Blue with the Meowban Brothers but never to be introduced with other characters. Most if not all Strawhats have protected the ship but someone qualified in guarding Sunny could be a worthy addition. Qualification Wall: Kuma. Candidate is whoever inherits the Paw Fruit to be able to simultaneously guard Sunny and adventure on land.
Whatever other positions that make sense but those above are most likely.
FIFY
Dreams and Wills are personal. Pedro wanted to ride with Roger who became the Pirate King. If we are to believe Pedro thinks the same of Luffy, then part of his Will is to ride on the Sunny. Knowing how long Pedro waited for that moment yet would sacrifice his chance so that Luffy can accomplish his dream is remarkable. For Carrot or whomever to inherit that Will, a more in-depth interaction between them displaying and explaining what is being inherited gives us the readers an understanding of its importance to both characters.
However, we only see a short flashback showing that Pedro knew Carrot was a fist fighter not a swordsman. And that shining moments are possible for Carrot. Nothing about the Dawn. Nothing about Pedro's core beliefs, past journeys, or dreams. The personableness is lacking between them IMO. I surmise that Pedro has not been completely forthright on his exact Will or Dream. As a fan, I would like that to be explored.
It's a good question. What else do the Strawhats need as a crew?
Taken officially and debatably:
Captain
First Mate/Combatant
Navigator/Merchant
Sniper/Gunner
Cook
Doctor/Pet
Archeologist/Assassin
Shipwright/Boatswain/Cooper
Musician
Helmsman/Lifeguard/Fireguard
Open for Debate:
Blacksmith: Usopp and Franky seem to share this role and do it well. Not likely someone joins to fill this role unless a Swordsmith is necessary or someone surpasses both their skills. Candidate is Vegapunk though Scientist fits better.
Tailor: Nami has shown some skill stitching Luffy's strawhat. It would be a useful role to fix the sails and ropes but not likely as the best for this role IMO is Strawhat Commander of the 5th division Leo. Candidate is Kin'emon thanks to his DF ninjutsu.
Chronicler: Nami, Usopp, and Robin all have been shown noting information throughout the journey. If a Chronicler were to join it would need to be someone organized and persistent in chronicling everything. Not likely IMO. Candidate is Yamato.
Lookout: Most if not all Strawhats have been shown being a lookout on a ship and/or looking through binoculars. It's quite peculiar actually that no one has been introduced as a lookout nor any Strawhat consistently taken the role. So I'm under the impression if a new crewmate is the "lookout" their position will not be introduced as so. Qualification Wall: Viola. Candidates are Vivi, Carrot, and Pedro.
Apprentice: IMO someone who is comparable to past apprentices in strength/capabilities and age. After all they have to hold their own in the New World. Usopp, Nami, and Chopper are big enough liabilities. 2 Emperors, an Emperor's Right Hand, 2 Mink Kings, and a former Warlord have been introduced as so. Big shoes to fill. Candidates are Yamato, Carrot, and Tama.
Shipguard: Strangely introduced back in East Blue with the Meowban Brothers but never to be introduced with other characters. Most if not all Strawhats have protected the ship but someone qualified in guarding Sunny could be a worthy addition. Qualification Wall: Kuma. Candidate is whoever inherits the Paw Fruit to be able to simultaneously guard Sunny and adventure on land.
Whatever other positions that make sense but those above are most likely.
FIFY
Thanks for the reply, and thats how you explain it. Indeed if Carrot is the inheritor, she lacks way too much, and now its too late to expand on that
Im afraid you wont get to see any more exploration on Pedro im afraid. When he was around, i wanted him to join the SH and witness the dawn on the Pirate Kings ship. It made sense. He was a great written character, and he fit well on the ship. A shame hes not around anymore and we are left with Carrot instead
Im afraid you wont get to see any more exploration on Pedro im afraid. When he was around, i wanted him to join the SH and witness the dawn on the Pirate Kings ship. It made sense. He was a great written character, and he fit well on the ship. A shame hes not around anymore and we are left with Carrot instead
No need to scream my boy
Carrot DID talked about the will of Pedro. It can be found in chapter 888 "I will fight for you too, Pedro"
The fact that she hasn't talked about that precise panel but that Oda mentionned that flashback is a clew that this moment is about to happen.
That's called jumping and dodging. Those are the "woosh sounds of a rapid movement" Like you can see, Neko even tho he appears like it, is not flying, he is just teking a big step (you can see his paw on the ground). What Carrot did is completely different, she modified her trajectory mid flight:
And that, only Carrot can do.
No. She doesn't need to be as strong as nekomamushi as they are far more trained than her. She just has a natural capacity for it. And who tells you that Carrot is not as strong as Pedro? Of course it's impressive. You really can't accept that Carrot can do something exceptionnal can't you? lol
Headcanon. It doesn't explain this post at all.
Carrot IS special, you will just have to accept it my dear.
Pedro was just a vessel to transfert a will to Carrot. The real story is hers, to him.
What Carrot lacks is the purpose mainly. But this is something that can be constructed and it has been setup in the story. So the probabilities for this to happen was the Dawn becomes a real subject are very high. This will be enough for Carrot to developp something.
Carrot DID talked about the will of Pedro. It can be found in chapter 888 "I will fight for you too, Pedro"
The fact that she hasn't talked about that precise panel but that Oda mentionned that flashback is a clew that this moment is about to happen.
Post automatically merged:
That's called jumping and dodging. Those are the "woosh sounds of a rapid movement" Like you can see, Neko even tho he appears like it, is not flying, he is just teking a big step (you can see his paw on the ground). What Carrot did is completely different, she modified her trajectory mid flight:
And that, only Carrot can do.
No. She doesn't need to be as strong as nekomamushi as they are far more trained than her. She just has a natural capacity for it. And who tells you that Carrot is not as strong as Pedro? Of course it's impressive. You really can't accept that Carrot can do something exceptionnal can't you? lol
Headcanon. It doesn't explain this post at all.
Carrot IS special, you will just have to accept it my dear.
Pedro was just a vessel to transfert a will to Carrot. The real story is hers, to him.
What Carrot lacks is the purpose mainly. But this is something that can be constructed and it has been setup in the story. So the probabilities for this to happen was the Dawn becomes a real subject are very high. This will be enough for Carrot to developp something.
Last edited:
No need to scream my boy
Carrot DID talked about the will of Pedro. It can be found in chapter 888 "I will fight for you too, Pedro"
The fact that she hasn't talked about that precise panel but that Oda mentionned that flashback is a clew that this moment is about to happen.
That's called jumping and dodging. Those are the "woosh sounds of a rapid movement" Like you can see, Neko even tho he appears like it, is not flying, he is just teking a big step (you can see his paw on the ground). What Carrot did is completely different, she modified her trajectory mid flight:
And that, only Carrot can do.
No. She doesn't need to be as strong as nekomamushi as they are far more trained than her. She just has a natural capacity for it. And who tells you that Carrot is not as strong as Pedro? Of course it's impressive. You really can't accept that Carrot can do something exceptionnal can't you? lol
Headcanon. It doesn't explain this post at all.
Carrot IS special, you will just have to accept it my dear.
Pedro was just a vessel to transfert a will to Carrot. The real story is hers, to him.
What Carrot lacks is the purpose mainly. But this is something that can be constructed and it has been setup in the story. So the probabilities for this to happen was the Dawn becomes a real subject are very high. This will be enough for Carrot to developp something.
Carrot DID talked about the will of Pedro. It can be found in chapter 888 "I will fight for you too, Pedro"
The fact that she hasn't talked about that precise panel but that Oda mentionned that flashback is a clew that this moment is about to happen.
Post automatically merged:
That's called jumping and dodging. Those are the "woosh sounds of a rapid movement" Like you can see, Neko even tho he appears like it, is not flying, he is just teking a big step (you can see his paw on the ground). What Carrot did is completely different, she modified her trajectory mid flight:
And that, only Carrot can do.
No. She doesn't need to be as strong as nekomamushi as they are far more trained than her. She just has a natural capacity for it. And who tells you that Carrot is not as strong as Pedro? Of course it's impressive. You really can't accept that Carrot can do something exceptionnal can't you? lol
Headcanon. It doesn't explain this post at all.
Carrot IS special, you will just have to accept it my dear.
Pedro was just a vessel to transfert a will to Carrot. The real story is hers, to him.
What Carrot lacks is the purpose mainly. But this is something that can be constructed and it has been setup in the story. So the probabilities for this to happen was the Dawn becomes a real subject are very high. This will be enough for Carrot to developp something.
The people anti Yamato are same people who were against Jimbei joining
There is a difference between a "whoosh" and something like floating in midair. This is a competely different ability. If you don't understand that I don't know what to say to you.
Like Brook didn't had One. Like Jinbe didn't had one. Like Franky didn't had one. You are confusing a strong storyline with a story centric arc. Those are different.
In a strong storyline, the character plays a high role in the story (Like Yamato in Onigashima or Usopp in Water seven). In a story centric arc. The character is the CENTER of the story.
And yes Carrot lacks that indeed, But it has been setup so I don't fear that it won't happen.
At the difference that the relation between Carrot and Pedro is compeltely different. I already debunked your argument on that. No need to repeat it my boy.
Carrot's storylines was as helpfull in whole cake that Robin was helpfull in skypiea. There is no difference.
Wrong. Many fights from main characters are skipped over. Irelevant argument.
Carrot is not a strawhat yet, just like Yamato. There is therefore no reason to depict her fight with the strawhats. Irrelevant
I already explained to you twice that defeat was the point of this fight. So start reading before you post the same post on repeat please.
Not at all. The people who want Carrot to join the crew are mostly the same that wanted Jinbe ten years ago.
Wrong. Because you can see the same rethoric put against Carrot and against Jinbe. You can therefore conclude that anti Carrot fan's are the same people that were Anti Jinbe fan with the same lack of knowledge for storytelling. As you can see here:
Like Brook didn't had One. Like Jinbe didn't had one. Like Franky didn't had one. You are confusing a strong storyline with a story centric arc. Those are different.
In a strong storyline, the character plays a high role in the story (Like Yamato in Onigashima or Usopp in Water seven). In a story centric arc. The character is the CENTER of the story.
And yes Carrot lacks that indeed, But it has been setup so I don't fear that it won't happen.
At the difference that the relation between Carrot and Pedro is compeltely different. I already debunked your argument on that. No need to repeat it my boy.
Carrot's storylines was as helpfull in whole cake that Robin was helpfull in skypiea. There is no difference.
Wrong. Many fights from main characters are skipped over. Irelevant argument.
Carrot is not a strawhat yet, just like Yamato. There is therefore no reason to depict her fight with the strawhats. Irrelevant
I already explained to you twice that defeat was the point of this fight. So start reading before you post the same post on repeat please.
Not at all. The people who want Carrot to join the crew are mostly the same that wanted Jinbe ten years ago.
Wrong. Because you can see the same rethoric put against Carrot and against Jinbe. You can therefore conclude that anti Carrot fan's are the same people that were Anti Jinbe fan with the same lack of knowledge for storytelling. As you can see here:
That's called jumping and dodging. Those are the "woosh sounds of a rapid movement" Like you can see, Neko even tho he appears like it, is not flying, he is just teking a big step (you can see his paw on the ground). What Carrot did is completely different, she modified her trajectory mid flight:
And that, only Carrot can do.
And that, only Carrot can do.
not floating towards him and then going up
Carrot is not the only one capable of floating out of Sulong and @Rootbeer has shown the examples, youre denying his evidence to further your agenda
This is as worse of an attempt to make Carrot "SPECIAL" since you said Carrot is the only mink to wear a Green cape without the guardian uniform... when Milky is wearing the same outfit as Carrot lol
Wrong. The reason you think it's a deflection is because you can here in the anime Carrot calshing with the sword at this moment. In reality, none of that happened and Carrot actually flew. In fact the anime rectified that later by making Pedro say that Carrot can float a little while in the air.
Like I said, this is logical as Carrot is just a way for Oday to put in motion the story he told us about in volume 8.
Plus the drawing is is clear as sky, only a blind man would see here a deflection.
Wrong. Like I said, every can jump fast, but none can change their trajectory mid air. It simply NEVER happened. Read the story more carefully and stop trying to deny every bit of point Carrot has because it's starting to show as very ...VERY sexist.
Stop making me sat something and stop inventing words please. I never said that. You better start reading more carefully and stop lying.
I said clearly this : Carrot is the only musketeer wearing a green cape. I have said that multiple times. So you have no excuse not to understand what I meant.
Again, read more carefully. Be it one piece or what I write.
Like I said, this is logical as Carrot is just a way for Oday to put in motion the story he told us about in volume 8.
Plus the drawing is is clear as sky, only a blind man would see here a deflection.
Wrong. Like I said, every can jump fast, but none can change their trajectory mid air. It simply NEVER happened. Read the story more carefully and stop trying to deny every bit of point Carrot has because it's starting to show as very ...VERY sexist.
Stop making me sat something and stop inventing words please. I never said that. You better start reading more carefully and stop lying.
I said clearly this : Carrot is the only musketeer wearing a green cape. I have said that multiple times. So you have no excuse not to understand what I meant.
Again, read more carefully. Be it one piece or what I write.
- Status